Premium Essay

Why the Golden Rule Does Not Work

In:

Submitted By bethelism
Words 943
Pages 4
The Golden Rule is a universally recognized guideline for proper ethical behavior. Many support it because it has a feel-good factor, and this rule is viewed as ‘good’. Unfortunately, this ethic of reciprocity may not always work. It seems to be merely a goodwill gesture, and is not necessarily a practical belief to enforce. There are different ways that people seem to practice the Golden Rule. There is the high end of the rule, in which we are taught to be kind to our enemies. While this action might be truly selfless, this aspect has often been the catalyst of historical atrocities. Indoctrinated masses, failing to revolt against corrupt and ruthless rulers, have easily been led into war and oppression. In A History of Sin, Oliver Thompson says, “At its higher level it becomes more generous and less mercenary, recognizing the superior quality of idea as formulated for instance by Lao Tzu in ancient China: 'For good return good: for evil return good’”. (Thompson, 1993) This impractical ethic has only ever been truly realized by asocial groups who tend to break away from the rest of the world. Rather than creating a working ethic that increases the overall goodness of the world, they abandon the world to the more cruel leaders who they fail to oppose. (Crabtree, 2001) On the lower end of the Golden Rule, it is stated that you should do to others as they do to you. This more common form of the ethic of reciprocity is as impractical as the first. As an example, soldiers at war are going to have a different view of what may or may not be acceptable. Fighting for their own survival, they are willing to attack others and defend themselves. Taken literally, the ethic of reciprocity states that it is acceptable for the soldiers to attack others, simply because it is something they are expecting to happen to them. Consider those who expect others to

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Cheating

...of breaking the rules, or attempting to achieve personal gain through fraud or deceit.16 To cheat is to deprive of something valuable by the use ofdeceit or fraud, to influence or lead by deceit, trick, or artifice, to practice fraud or trickery, to violate rules dishonestly, or to be sexually unfaithful.11 A cheater (sometimes called acheat) gets something by dishonesty or deception; or by depriving one of his or her rights and usually connotes deliberate perversion of the truth; or by large-scale cheating bymisrepresentation or abuse of confidence.11 Cheating is an act of lying, deception, fraud, trickery, imposture, or imposition. Cheating characteristically is employed to create an unfair advantage, usually in one's own interest, and often at the expense of others. Cheating implies the breaking of rules. Cheating is a primordial economic act: getting more for less, often used when referring to marital infidelity.3 Cheating is when a person misleads, deceives, or acts dishonestly on purpose.17  Cheating fundamentally includes several elements of both lying and stealing, with specific motivations to gain something of value by illegitimate means. That is why lying and stealing are discussed before cheating. Cheating is lying and/or stealing with the intention for acquiring something for more than merely the "pleasure" of fooling or depriving others.  Children Cheating as a concept is not understood by children until around age seven. Preschoolers often change the rules to a game...

Words: 19938 - Pages: 80

Free Essay

Book

...explains why it all is happening and how the international system is transforming the world affairs. It also shows you all the things that he said in his book that they would come true and some of those things actually did come true. This books helps you understand about how globalization is working and why it is happening. It also shows and tells you how the world reacts to it and what the bad and good thing about globalization. In the first part of the book of the books it explains what the title ‘Lexus’ and ‘’olive tree’’ means. The Lexus stands for half the world emerging from the Cold War and people intent on building a better Lexus, modernizing economies in order to thrive globalization. The olive tree stands for the other half who are still caught up in the fight over who owns which "olive tree." The Lexus stands for the emerging of new things like 300 new Lexus being built everyday and people are moving on from the Cold War. The Olive tree represents our roots, anchors us, and identifies us. The Olive Tree also represents people fighting over who own what. That was the main thing in the beginning because it tells you what the title is all about. After that it goes into more detail about other things about globalization. It asks what a golden straightjacket it the golden straightjacket is an economic group where you need to have some standards to be apart from. To be able to join the group you have to adopt or make a progress towards the golden rules. Some of...

Words: 820 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Golden Rule

...Book final final THE GOLDEN RULE as THE SUPREME PRINCIPLE implications for FAITH Faith within the Limits of Love and Reason SECTION ONE: Why Reason Must Have the Final Word To see why reason must have the final word in all things, I will illustrate the role of reason in three different cases. This I think should suffice to make the point. (1) Consulting Some Authority Suppose we are confronted with two or more conflicting alternatives concerning what to say, think or do and in hopes of resolving this confusing conflict, we seek out some wiser person, some authority, who can give us the correct answer. This raises the question: Who is the authority we can turn to: our Mom, our Dad, our grandparent, a priest or a clergyman, a Rabbi or Ayatollah, a bodhisattva, a therapist or counselor, the Pope, a lawyer, a real estate agent, an auto mechanic? Well, of course, our choice depends on the nature of our problem. So, reason needs to play a role here in helping us to determine what kind of authority to consult. Okay, let us suppose that our conflict is of a religious nature. We still need to ask which priest, which clergyman, which Rabbi, which Ayatollah or which bodhisattva etc. to choose. So here again, reason has a role to play. There is more. After we have settled who to consult, sometimes we will find that the advice is really bad advice. Sometimes we will find that the advice is really good advice. On still other occasions, we won't know what to make of the advice...

Words: 4569 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Managmebt 591 Discussion

...Rules for High Performance Organizations (graded) | This week our text discusses the definition of organizational behavior and in particular its applied focus, and our lecture focuses on high performance organizations (HPOs). Right at the intersection of those would be the “Ten Golden Rules of High Performance” listed below. What do you think should be added to the list? Is there anything on the list that you disagree with? Please support your opinion with evidence from our readings and also from your own work and life experience. Please also remember to respond to your classmates’ posts to stimulate further discussion. Ten Golden Rules of High Performance 1. Hire by committee – make sure recruits talk to their future colleagues. 2. Cater to every need – make it easy, not hard, for people to perform. 3. Pack them in – put people to work close to one another. 4. Make coordination easy – use technology to keep people talking together. 5. Eat your own dog food – make use of the company products. 6. Encourage creativity – allow freedom to come up with new ideas. 7. Strive for consensus – remember that “many are better than few.” 8. Don’t be evil – live tolerance and respect. 9. Data-driven decisions – do the analysis and stay on track. 10. Communicate effectively – hold many stay-in-touch meetings. Responses | | | Response  | Author | Date/Time* | | | Ten Golden Rules of High Performance | Zachary Brechler  | 9/2/2012 5:43:26 AM | | | I think...

Words: 19453 - Pages: 78

Premium Essay

Nursing Philosophy

...registered nurses (RN) can be viewed as role models for personal health behaviors. Attempting to teach a patient about the adverse effects smoking has on one’s health can be more than challenging if the RN smells like smoke, or has visible cigarettes in their pocket. This RN has observed this behavior in others and has difficulty understanding these actions. Nurses are more aware than the average person of the consequences of smoking, obesity, drinking, or drug use, but research has shown that “in spite of nurses’ knowledge, no difference exists between the health behaviors of nurses and those of the general population,” (Chitty & Black, 2010, pg. 290). This author has strong beliefs and opinions about smoking, drinking, and drug use, but does struggle daily with eating healthy and exercising. As a personal health philosophy, this author and RN, who is also an ex-smoker, believes smoking cigarettes is one of the most disgusting habits one can begin. Being non-judgmental toward others regarding smoking, especially nurses, can be challenging, but possible. My struggle with weight may be challenging for others to understand as well. As a nurse and role model, my philosophy...

Words: 1026 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Free Basics - Branded Internet

...Who decides the Basics? Man is condemned to be free – Jean Paul Satre It can be argued that mankind has never been truly free and that many have chosen their own poisons or construct their own prisons, with the trappings of work place, gated community dwellings etc (aka walled gardens of today’s internet era) – the trappings of living seemingly free. If so were the case, then why not let the internet be as it is and each to his own creativity or poison, than circumvent the same with new rules. Facebook’s ongoing ‘Free basics’ ad blitz is possibly propping up this very dream – and is doing so very vividly. Backed with the promise and benefits of connectivity for masses (not just the privileged few), it does a brilliant execution on both narration and rendition, with Mark Zuckerberg positioned as the voice of the masses for connectivity and digital equality (and a fine print that leaves much to be understood, on costs, speeds, places one can visit, walls that will keep out more than what the mind and eyes of the avg netizen can/will see for now, etc etc). A bold strategy for sure indeed and if it works – Mark Zuckerberg has clearly created history (yet again, as a marketing genius this time). For he would be credited with changing (i) the rules of net neutrality (ii) for heralding the advent of branded internet and (iii) for kicking of the leadership battle for ‘share of internet’ in the times to come. And yet several question remain: As to how credible is this campaign...

Words: 1809 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Empathy and the Platinum Rule

...The Platinum Rule Delvin KWA A0072584Y Everyone knows the Golden Rule: “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” This sounds like a sound starting point for an ethical approach. So sound that it has earned itself its golden title. Many philosophies and religions worldwide incorporate this rule, and it is not without surprise. The Golden Rule might not be all-encompassing, and hence its negative form, the Silver Rule, which states: “Do not do unto others as you would not have them do unto you”, was born for complementarity. Together, these rules are based upon the importance of empathy and this ethic of reciprocity has been what many different cultures have resolved conflicts with. However, the Golden Rule is no panacea. Think about it: “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” This is based upon the assumption that other people would like to be treated the same way that you would like to be treated. And we know instinctively that this cannot always be true, because everyone is different and has differing tastes and preferences. So now what? Could there be another rule that might tie up the loose ends? Enter the Platinum Rule: “Do unto everyone as they would have you do unto them.” This rule obliges us to respect and consider the needs and wants of people, and then act based on this understanding. It is what prevails in gift-giving, in earnest advice-giving, and so on. The focus of the relationship shifts from “this is what I want, so I'll give everyone...

Words: 1976 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Assignment 2 Legal Issues Case Study Part Ii

... Marcus is a second year law student working as an intern for the largest law firm in Chicago, Illinois. The senior attorney introduced Marcus to a new client, Kay Roc, the founder of the famous fast food chain, McWilliams. As the owner of this large organization, Roc is looking to your firm to handle all of her legal needs. Marcus learns the following information from his meeting with Roc and her staff. • McWilliams recently hired a former high-ranking official from the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to help improve the image of McWilliam’s products and ensure compliance with state and federal government regulations. Roc is concerned about a recently proposed rule that will require McWilliams to obtain additional permits and result in more frequent inspections by the FDA. The agency published the rule in the Federal Register last week. These new permits will create...

Words: 1344 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Equality 7-2521 In Ayn Rand's Anthem

...society he lives in, which condemns individualism. He does this by seeking knowledge from the Unmentionable Times after realizing how powerful it can be, alluding to his individuality. Next, he breaks free from...

Words: 1014 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Master Plan

...culture standardize operating procedure across the globe. Tailor made interiors to give local flavor with standardize operation of global standards Cultural cameleon Implementing local learnings globally Globally Uniform standards:- Global “service culture standards” (exhibit 4) 270 core operating standards (exhibit 5) applicable world wide Exception permitted if they make local sense (exception of leaving coffee pot at france) Minimum expectation Performance evaluation through External and Internal Audit Delivering intelligent, anticipator and enthusiastic services world wide Just for you Intelligent service If employees are empathetic, anticipate guest needs to reduce distance between employee and guest Human resource and golden rule One should treats others as one would wish to be...

Words: 1787 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Diversity

...company, giving them the opportunity to speak out on subjects such as diversity in the workforce as well. When managing diversity there are many questions you ask yourself as a manager. Being a manager at my organization we go through monthly goal boards, what motivates employees, and how would they like to be recognized. Going through each step has been productive with having multiple ethnic backgrounds. What may work for one team member may not work for all. So coming up with an overall plan for the organization that does not exclude anyone works perfectly. Giving negative feedback to someone culturally different from myself works fine as we use open door policies as well. I also realized that during promotions the company continues to be very diverse insisting on diverse screening committee and usually making additional efforts to ensure that it’s a diverse group of candidates applying for the position. As stated in the article I read “gender, race, and cultural diversity create better organizations”, (Griswold 2013). Most people believe in the golden rule: treat others as you want to be treated. The implied theory is that how you want...

Words: 459 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Aristotle's Tackling The Perpetrator

...Picture this: as you are walking home late at night after work you witness a victim being harassed by a perpetrator. What do you do? Do you play as a bystander and continue watching without assisting or heroic and intervene to assist the victim? Aristotle would not choose either. Instead he would assess the situation and act according, if the perpetrator deemed much bigger than himself he’d standby and call for help and if he had the capability of tackling the perpetrator he would. This decision is relative of Aristotle’s golden mean which is a component of virtue ethics he introduced. Unlike the others, Aristotle ethics did not include a set of rules of what to do or what not to do and how to systemically approach situations, but more of focusing...

Words: 640 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Rules of Thumb, Ethics

...Rules of Thumb Misha McCulloch March 10, 2013 Rules of Thumb Misha McCulloch March 10, 2013 Every day ethical situations arise. How people solve these ethical dilemmas vary based on each individuals’ ethical thinking, or, Rules of Thumb. My personal tools for ethical decision making are the Golden Rule and going with my gut instinct. The Golden Rule states “do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” The Golden Rule has been a part of my life for as long as I can remember. It was one of my parent’s favorite teachings. As the bossy, older sister, I found it my prerogative to be a diva. Sharing and playing nice weren’t exactly my strong suits. But like most parents, mine would always say, “Would you like it if your sister didn’t share with you?” Luckily for my parents I possess empathy; and therefore this teaching worked rather well on me. I suppose sharing isn’t the worst ethical dilemma, but as time passes you realize how vital implementations of these rules become. For instance, I’ve never cheated on a test. Why? Because if I had spent hours studying for an exam and someone cheated off of my exam I would be down-right livid. I don’t work my butt off just so someone else could skirt by. I would never cheat off of someone else because chances are that that person would have the same reaction as I would. In a more extreme case, murder, theft, and abuse are just a few other things that I would never do. I wouldn’t like any of those things to...

Words: 815 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business and Ethics: They'Re Surely Not Your Top Running Candidate for 'the Golden Rule"

...Abbey Bartosiak Final Paper Wednesday, December 10th, 2008 Businesses and Ethics: They’re Surely Not Your Top Running Candidate for “The Golden Rule” The Golden Rule is a rule that is universally known. Although it has been translated differently and all the words may not be the same, it has the same universal meaning: “Do to others what you would want done to yourself.” This rule is one of the few rules that every person is the world is taught and abides (or tries to abide) by in their everyday life. When young children learn this rule, they are told to never forget it and to use it for the rest of their life: through school, for families, for work. There becomes a gray area, though, when The Golden Rule is brought into the workplace. For some reason, offices and workers feel that this rule doesn’t apply to them. They don’t need to be honest because, in some way, they are benefitting themselves. Business is where The Golden Rule gets tossed and people and firms start to act out of egoism, a form of moral belief. To uncover the “how, where and why” of business ethics, one must explore deeper beyond the surface. First, to understand how big businesses violate ethics, one must know what business ethics are and what they consist of. Second, to understand how businesses and workers act of out egoism, one must know what egoism is and what the beliefs pertain to. Then, connections and examples of businesses violating their ethics and how this unites it with egoism...

Words: 3006 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...evaluate the following rules of ethics as they apply to the world of business: utilitarianism, moral rights and the justice rule. In this paper, I will define each approach and provide the strength and weakness of each as well as compare and contrast the theories I have chosen. UTILITARIAN APPROACH When employed in the use of making business decisions, the goal of utilitarianism is to maximize the greater good for the greater group of people or on the contrary, minimize the negative effects of a decision experienced by a group of people. (See essay by John Stuart Mill, Utilitarism, 1863) While it forces you to consider how the actions of a business could affect its employees, consumers, shareholders, etc., the problem is that it is often very difficult to give value to and measure the benefits of a decision versus any negative result of said action. As an example, you could look at a business’ decision to outsource jobs on a global level. The decision to outsource would benefit the business, shareholders and consumers if it increases the company’s profit margin. However, this decision would no doubt result in layoffs of domestic employees which would also affect that community. Although the business may dislike the effects of outsourcing on the community, they have to consider certain outcomes resulting from resident production such as the bankruptcy or liquidation of the business. The utilitarian approach is being used in current issues such as why healthcare should...

Words: 1085 - Pages: 5