Free Essay

A Brother with a Disability

In:

Submitted By chicote95
Words 2145
Pages 9
In August Wilson’s play “Fences,” the author establishes a dynamic relationship between two brothers that struggled with one another due to one being mentally disabled due to a World War II battle injury. In this dramatic play, Troy, who is described as a bitter and selfish man, has a challenging time for loving, respecting, taking care and accepting his disabled brother, Gabriel. This inspired me to write about my life dealing with a severely autistic brother. I know how laborious it can be for Troy to look after his brother. It takes a lot of hard work, but the most important part is to have patience and to fully understand a brother with a severe disability. I had to learn to be patient to overcome my brother’s disability and to love, respect, and accept him for who he is regardless of how it affects me. In this paper, I will explore the ways in which Troy interacts with Gabriel, comparing them with how I interact with my brother, Bryan, and discuss how the people in America perceive and treat individuals with disabilities.
The relationship between Troy and Gabriel is strained at best. Although, Troy struggles to provide his brother Gabriel with tenderness, dignity, and acknowledgement, he doesn’t know how to express his true feelings and emotions about his disabled brother. For a good and positive relationship between brothers to exist, there has to be good communication, and appreciation for each other. However, Troy doesn't seem to accept his brother and his disability. The way Troy interacts with Gabriel is very frustrating and painful to write about. The first reason why Troy does not demonstrate enough compassion to his brother is because he feels guilty about how he is taking his brother’s monthly check from the government for his own personal uses. In the book to support this notion, Troy states “If my brother didn’t have that metal plate on his head, I wouldn’t have a pot to piss in or window to throw it out of ”(1070). Troy used that money so that he could purchase his own house and so that he could support his own family. What about his disabled brother, does Troy even concern under what condition his brother is in? All the years that Troy received the support check intended for his brother, Troy should’ve done something beneficial for him. Troy should've used the money to place Gabriel in a rehabilitation center that would provide treatment to Gabriel and improve his mental conditions. It infuriates me that Troy did that to his own brother who needs a great deal of support since he is disabled and can’t manage their own life. This clearly explains how Troy appears to be a heartless person to his brother. Troy just doesn’t seem to have any feelings towards his brother and his disability. During a scene in the book, Gabriel is approaching to Troy’s house, Rose who is Troy’s wife is affected by the Gabriel situation. Rose convinces Troy to do something about his brother and asked Troy if he can put Gabriel in a hospital where he can receive treatment for his disability. Troy’s immediate reaction was “ What do you want me to do about it, Rose? I done everything I can for the man. I can’t make him get well, ain’t no sense for him to be in a hospital” (1070). Troy doesn't recognize the conditions his brother is in, he is an ambitious person, and selfish who profited from his brother when he should’ve supported his brother with tenderness, dignity, and acknowledgement. In this scene Gabriel was living in an apartment away from Troy. Troy only cared about the money from Gabriel. Later in the story, Rose thought Troy signed some papers, allowing Gabriel to receive half of the money and other half to the hospital (1097). Troy denies in the book that he signed papers concerning the money. From the book, quote”I told you ain't signed nothing, woman! The only thing I signed was the release form. I aint signed nothing about sending Gabe away” (1097).
Eventually in the mid 60’s, Troy dies of a heart attack and Gabriel escapes from the hospital to go to his brother’s funeral. He explains to Rose, “It’s time to tell St. Peter to open the gates. Troy, you ready” (1111)? Gabriel has been waiting for a long time for this moments when he sees Troy enter heaven. This is an emotional scene because it shows that Gabriel truly loves his brother and it seems to me that Gabriel forgive his brother, regardless of the mistakes his brother made. At the end brothers have to accept and forgive each other because thats what brother have to do, they have to accept their mistakes. As for me, I had a tough time with brother, however, I realized that by not loving or accepting my own brother, I knew that regardless of his disability, I have to accept him and respect my brother’s disability. It has changed my personality because I’ve become more responsible, become a better man, become patient, and have showed my mother that I could be a more than a good brother. My brother, Bryan is my salvation because I proved myself and to everyone that having a disabled brother is greater than having a brother without a disability. I truly believed my brother is a gift from God and I see my own brother as an angel.
Although Troy and I had some similarities and difficulties in looking after our disabled brothers, I feel I show more compassion and respect for brother than Troy did for his. Since I was a young, I had to look after my brother Bryan. He has a very severe case of autism and probably will never be self-reliant. When my brother was born on Valentine’s Day of the year 2003, we were so glad to see his little arms and a beautiful face. However, when my brother, Bryan was about two years of age, my parents and I noticed that my brother wasn’t smiling as much, didn’t interact with others, no words came out of his mouth, and had an inflexible behavior; we didn’t know what was happening to him. My parents and I got frightened so my parents decided to take my brother to see a doctor, my parents were so worried that something really bad was happening. When my brother was diagnosed with autism, we were totally confused. We didn’t know that this shocking news was going to changed our lives forever; we didn’t even know what autism was.
To support a disabled brother, my family and I had to look for therapies as soon as possible so that it could help my brother. As my brother Bryan started to grow up with this illness, his autism was getting worse each day. From four through six years of age, he experienced bad behavior when we went to public places such as hitting, screaming, throwing himself on the floor. He would cry out loud each time my family and I went to a grocery store, mall, park, restaurants, and many places. People would always stare at us like “what’s wrong with that kid or why is he acting like that.” Most the time we were embarrassed and sometimes people got frightened. My family decided to stop taking my brother to public places because every time we would be embarrassed. As growing up, my family and I suffered from high stress, my parents’ marriage was unhealthy, and at one point my parents got a divorce because of my brother. It really affected my family because my mom had to work so she could feed us and now it was my job to take care of my brother. It did affect me too, because instead of going out with my friends, I stayed to take care of him. It was so frustrating because I couldn’t spend my free time, no one was willing to take care of my brother. To support an autistic child is 60,000 dollars a year and my mother didn’t have that kind of money. (Medicine Net) My father didn’t want to support my brother financially because he basically ran away. So my mother got my brother some support from the government. She was very lucky because my mother didn’t know what to do my brother. She was going to take my brother’s life away, but she realized that wasn’t the best decision. My mother earned some therapies for my brother at age six. Bryan started taking behavioral, speech, and motor sensory therapies. Such studies have demonstrated that many children with autism experienced significant improvements in learning, reasoning, communication, behavior and adaptability when they participate in high-quality programs. (Southwest Autism Research & Resource Center) My brother was able to get a check from the government every month to help my brother to pay for the therapies, to pay for his food, clothes, and even help us to pay the rent. Thanks to the therapies and medication, Bryan was communicating more, he was interacting with other people, and he wasn’t so aggressive. My brother has taken therapies and medications for about six years now and has improved a lot. Although it is very frustrating for me, people still do not understand what it is like to have a disabled person in the family.
In America, disabled people and families with a disabled member, are often discriminated because society see them as stupid who can't learn anything or of how differently people behave. Many people will say horrible things to an autistic child because most people think they are stupid or something. About 60% of autistic children are discriminated and most autistic children suffer from it. (Autism Speaks) Autistic children have feelings too, they are smart, however they are very delayed in their learning. That doesn’t mean they are stupid. One time my friends told me that my brother was mentally sick, but in an offensive way. I was so frustrating when one my friends told me that I felt punching him. Not only did my friend was discriminating him, other people as well. When we go into public places, people will say something and you know it hurts my feelings when people say horrible things to my brother. To me, the remarks seemed strikingly rude and offensive. Yet seemingly respectable people uttered the words in earnest. Some of them might have been intended as mean but my sense was, most people said what they said with a straight face, meaning well. Why did they do it? I cannot imagine any answer but ignorance. Clearly, there is a lot of ignorance out there. Judging from the comments, many recipients of the ignorance are parents and young people with autism. Sometimes I think to myself what if those people who told me horrible things, turn out to have an autistic child. Well, obviously they would suffer the consequences as well.
Although, Troy was so heartless to his brother, I learned that being so selfish and hateful towards a disabled brother is not how you should treat a disabled brother. It’s frustrating to me personally because there are parents and brothers or sisters who have a disabled children and treat them with injustice. Also people should be educated to end discrimination towards disabled children and adults. There are many people who don’t know about children with disabilities. It infuriates me that America isn’t doing something. As families, we should do something about it, to tell society that many children are being born with disabilities and how they are unique, intelligent, and tell them about how it is living with a disabled child. By reading “Fences,” It gave me more motivation to make my brother proud and support him so that one day he could move forward in life and live a healthy life. This reflects the difference between Troy and myself where he had a miserable life with his brother because he wouldn't accept his brothers disability, I in turn, although frustrating at times, feel rewarded due to the fact I have been involved with brother. As for me, I love my brother to death, I accept him for who he is, not because he's disabled. Although he’s my little brother I have to be an example to him and treat him with love because to me he’s like an angel who deserves to be loved. If God sent him with his disability is because He did it for a reason. He wants me to be mature and to be responsible, and to take care of him because he can’t take care of himself. I really believe this because one time my mom told me this and she is very appreciative that I’m always there to help her and I truly believe in those words.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Scarlet Ibis Theme Essay

... In the story “The Scarlet Ibis”, Doodle's older brother was irritated by Doodles disability, because he wanted a normal brother. Because of this, he tried to make Doodle more normal by teaching him to walk. But Doodle's brother should have accepted him from the start In the story, “The Scarlet Ibis” by James Hurst, the theme, people don’t accept others who look different, is shown through tone. In the first place, people who are unique are...

Words: 675 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Oscar Pistorius Character Analysis

...Pistorius, a runner who had both legs amputated at eleven months old once said, "You are not disabled by the disabilities you have, you are able by the abilities you have." As human beings we see disabilities as a bad thing. The disability was the only thing the brother from The Scarlet Ibis saw when he saw his baby brother, Doodle, for the first time. When the baby was born he was expected to die or never be able to do things that most kids would be able to do. The brother had resentment of Doodle and taught Doodle to walk, climb, and swim only because he was embarrassed to have a disabled brother. Doodle did everything he could to win his brother's pride and he never gave up. As the story goes on the brother sees Doodle not for his disability, but for his personality. Then one day a scarlet ibis fell from one of the trees, sick and injured the scarlet ibis passed away. Doodle buried the bird and sang to it. Later, after Doodle refused to do his daily training it started to rain. Upset with Doodle, the brother left him. When Doodle did not follow after him he went to look for him, only to realize Doodle had passed. Doodle's determination, kindness, and dependence on others, changed his brother's opinion on disabilities and that is more important to important to love...

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Rain Man

...a vacation with his girlfriend Susanna to Palm Springs. On the way to Palm Springs he received a call saying his father died. Charlie and Susanna goes to Ohio to bury Charlie's father. After the burial function he met up with his fathers lawyer to discuss his inheritance. Charlie being distinct from his dad since the age of 16 was informed that he would only get his dad’s car Buick Roadmaster and Rose bushes. When Charlie heard his he got angry and wanted to find out who was entitled for his dad’s three million dollars. While on the process of finding who was unnamed person who was entitled for the three million dollars, he found out that he has a older brother and his parents kept that a secret from Charlie. He found out that he has an autistic older brother who lives in a mental institution. Charlie kidnaps his brother Raymond played by Dustin Hoffman, and tries to bring him to Los Angeles. At first Charlie was angry that no one told him about Raymond. Charlie did not understand what it means to be autistic. So, on the way to Los Angeles he got angry at Raymond for being scared of airplanes and having to watch television shows on specific times. On the journey to Los Angeles Charlie realized that Raymond was the Rain Man Charlie always dreamed about. Charlie constantly got phone calls from Los Angeles that no one was buying his cars and customers want their down payments back. Charlie realized then that he can use Raymond’s autism as a way to gamble and count cards...

Words: 1903 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

My Autistic Sister Research Paper

...It takes a family to raise a child, it takes a child with autism to raise the consciousness of the family. My autistic brother is named Nathan Borjas he was diagnosed with Autism and Agenesis of the corpus callosum (ACC) at the age of four. Nobody ever thinks of a brother or sister being born with a mental disability. Nathan faces so many problems, obstacles, problems, obstacles, problems obstacles in his life and for the rest of his life. At the end of the day Nathan is family, he will be loved and cherished by all of his brothers, sisters, mom and dad. Autism changes the way a family thinks, sees, and feels. When a sibling is born u never say I hope he does not have a disability, we assume for the best outcome all the time but the truth...

Words: 679 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

People First Language Research Paper

...and not the disability that is associated with them (The ARC). In other words, People First Language is utilized to acknowledge the individual as a person, not the disability that they may have. In a way, it is used to show respect to those who have a disability. If a person does use First People Language, it could also mean that the person understands that the disability does not define who they are. People may not even have to specifically identify the disability, but if one uses the appropriate words, a common understanding can be established. A person may have a disability and it could have a serious impact on their everyday life, but that does not mean their disability defines them. Some examples of People First Language are, instead of saying birth defect it would be more appropriate to say congenital disability; instead of saying someone is autistic, saying someone has autism or have a diagnosis of autism would be more appropriate as well (Snow). In schools, teachers and administrators are especially expected to use People First Language because...

Words: 691 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Charlie Mollison Assassination Speech

...Award Presentation Speech: Good evening and welcome to the inaugural Australian Disability Film Awards, held in recognition of the efforts of several individuals and organisations in promoting awareness and understanding for Australian families living with disabilities. Tonight, I am privileged to be presenting the award for best supporting actor to someone who has excelled in their transformative portrayal of a young character with low-functioning autism and ADHD. The ability of this young man to play a character, not just his condition has stolen all our hearts, and I am honoured to present this award to Luke Ford, for his role as Charlie Mollison in the Black Balloon. The Black Balloon dances a delicate line in it’s depiction of autism, with the film succeeding largely due to the consistent performance of Luke Ford enabling his character to stray away from the savant autism typical of the genre and create a unique, authentic character. Charlie’s autism is scarcely mentioned in the film, with Luke Ford ensuring that the mischievous humour of Charlie’s character is only exacerbated by his autism, with the audience growing to view Charlie as a human, rather than the result of a condition....

Words: 867 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Road Less Traveled

...The Road Less Traveled Many people do not realize what it’s like to undergo a disability or even take care of someone who has a disability. During this assignment, I realized how our society could be selfish and view a person with a disability as dumb, incapable, or broken. You never know the sentiments or emotions until you are in those person’s shoes. Therefore, we need to cherish everything we have in life and live a fulfilling life because one day we can be a happy family and the next we are going through a road less traveled. On March 26, 2014 I was scheduled to meet with my neighbor whom is two houses down from me. Mrs. Villarreal is a 48-year-old woman born and raised in McAllen TX, a mother of 2 children, and a loving wife. She has two girls named Lizette who is 5 years old and Yvonne who is 6 years old; both who are healthy and very active. Raising them was no problem for her and as they grew up, they routinely did every thing as a family. However, she did mention that she has a brother named Ruben who has a disability, and would visit every so often at her mothers house. Ruben has severe rheumatoid arthritis disease in which led to high levels of disability, the use of a wheelchair, and inability to work. In addition, he has heart disease, anxiety, and depression. As for her, everything seemed to go perfectly fine with her mother being the primary caregiver for her brother for three years. Her mother was very active and on top of Ruben’s needs. Until, a year later...

Words: 800 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Scarlet Ibis Figurative Language

...condition. When he was born William’s brother was six years old, and when William died his brother was thirteen. The story is called “The Scarlet Ibis” because the family saw a bird dying in their backyard which was far away from its native land, and William died away from his home. Mr. Hurst was born in North Carolina at a farm by the sea. He studied singing and in Italy and he became a banker. During his thirty four years as a banker he also published a few short stories including “The Scarlet Ibis”. I personally did not like how the story went but I do like how Mr. Hurst wrote it. I also like how he referred the scarlet ibis...

Words: 1444 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Arnie In What's Eating Gilbert Grape

...which in some instances is comorbid with autism. Arnie’s character is also stereotypic to some extent. Arnie is shown as being unkempt with hair that is unbrushed and always being covered in dirt. While it is likely that autistic persons do not care much about how they look, the trait is also sometimes true for people that are not autistic. Therefore, the fact that Arnie was the character whose appearance is untidy appears to point towards the fact that autistic persons are lesser in appearance and do not take enough care of themselves, but this is not true. Conclusion In conclusion, the film is an effective representation of mental disability and its probable implications to the family. Arnie’s family is constantly worried about him as would any family with a mentally challenged individual. While in some instances Arnie’s portrayal of mental disability appears to be farfetched, it is still a proper representation of the condition. In this case the film does a great job shedding light on the...

Words: 1401 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

A Scarlet Ibis Literary Analysis

..."They want me to be perfect, but they don't know that I'm hurting." In the short story, "A Scarlet Ibis," the narrator, also known in the story as "Brother," is faced with the embarrassment of having a younger brother, Doodle, who is not physically able to walk, so the narrator sets out to teach his "disabled" brother to walk, even if Doodle does not agree with it. Brother caused Doodle's death because he was embarrassed,he did not care about Doodle's health concerns, and he left him in the thunderstorm. The narrator causes Doodle's death because he was embarrassed of his younger brother's disability. "Doodle walked only because I was ashamed of having a crippled brother."(419) Over the course of a couple months, after a lot of hard...

Words: 408 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Intellectual Disability Case Scenarios

...Goodwill’s Supported Employment Services by Arkansas Rehabilitation Services. Ac reported that he had heard about Goodwill’s disability program from a counselor at his high school before he graduated. Now that Ac has graduated he desires to find employment but expresses that he needs help doing so. Ac’s presenting problem is that he has a primary impairment of Intellectual Disability as well as a history of seizures. He has always been in special education classes growing up but only has experienced having seizures 3 months ago. Ac is currently taking medication for his seizures and has not had any occur since begging the medication 3 months ago. Due to Ac’s intellectual disability he has difficulty with working at a fast pace, following multiple directions/instructions; and demonstrates limited academic skills. He also has no job experience or form of dependent transportation. These are all things that he would need assistance with so that he can be successful at gaining competitive employment. Description of the Client and his/her Environment: • Client (micro) System: Ac was dressed casually and was visually well groomed at the time of our interview. He appeared to be calm and collective throughout the entire interview and willing to answer any questions. He was very friendly and...

Words: 1870 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Jealousy In The Scarlet Ibis

...The Bleeding Tree of Despair The short story “The Scarlet Ibis”, written by James Hurst, is about the narrator and his brother Doodle, having a so called “good relationship” as Brother teaches Doodle how to be “normal” before he starts school. Brother is embarrassed to have Doodle as a brother because of his physical disability. Brother teases, torments, and somewhat abuses Doodle because of it. Doodles body is very weak and because of Brothers forceful acts, Doodle died. Many may say Brother is caring because of his eagerness to help, but in reality Brother is selfish and impatient. Brother can be very kind to Doodle even when he doesn't realize it. Although, Brother is very cruel to Doodle, there are some moment when he realizes that...

Words: 602 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Similarities Between Doodle And Lennie

...Many people have goals for their life, like Lennie and Doodle. Sadly some goals can never be reached. The novel Of Mice and Men and the story “The Scarlet Ibis”, Lennie and Doodle never achieve their dreams. Both Lennie and Doodle die without a dream. Lennie always has to listen to George and Doodle needs his brother. The following passages have many similarities. One being both Lennie and Doodle Die.; Also Lennie and Doodle both are disabled. They never get a chance to try on their own. Lennie and Doodle die without something to be happy about. Lennie’s last words were “Le’s do it now. Le’s get that place now pg.106”. Lennie dies talking about the place him and George were going to get; which happens to be his dream. If Lennie did not have...

Words: 600 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Autism In Rain Man

...turns out that his father left him only a car and some rose bushes. The rest, estimated at over three million dollars, went to a trustee at a mental health institution. Charlie goes to the mental health institution to find this person, and while he is there he meets his brother, Raymond. The only problem with this is Charlie thought he was an only child. His mother died when he was young, and he didn’t remember having a brother. Charlie also quickly learns that his brother has a mental disability. Raymond has autism, which the movie describes as him not being able to communicate or even control his own emotions. He is not completely disabled, though, as he has an amazing memory which is actually stronger than most others. So while he is challenged in some areas, there are others in which he excels. Charlie quickly realizes that the best way to get his half of the money is to gain control over his brother. Therefore he takes him from the intuition and uses him. Throughout the rest of the movie Charlie and Raymond spend time together, on their quest to get back to L.A. On the way back they go through many situations which are made worse by the fact that Charlie doesn’t understand Raymond’s disability. Charlie treats Raymond’s autism very rudely at times, but as the film goes on he does seem to understand that Raymond needs stay in his routine to stay happy. Charlie tries to communicate and change Raymond, but he doesn’t force him to do anything that he doesn’t want...

Words: 1496 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Scarlet Ibis Conflict

...Doodle is a one of a kind. He loves to have fun but, he some troubles that stop him. The short story The Scarlet Ibis By James Hurst is about a young boy named Doodle. Doodle is born with some unfortunate disabilities. Doodle and his brother fight together to help doodle become more normal. But, doodle gets really sick and he passes away. The Scarlet Ibis by James Hurst is full of conflicts, emotion and happiness. The story begins with it’s first conflict that it seems hopeless but they don't give up. “It seemed so hopeless from the beginning that it’s a miracle I didn’t give up” (Hurst). This quote from the text explains that when his brother started to help him and wanted to teach him how to walk he was hopeless and knew that he was never...

Words: 519 - Pages: 3