Premium Essay

Arguments Against DACA Policy

Submitted By
Words 452
Pages 2
Jorge Garcia was brought into the United States by his parents at the age of 10. Garcia was protected under DACA which allowed him to stay in the United States legally and guaranteed him that he would not be deported. The DACA policy should remain the way it is because DACA provides a possible and easier path to citizenship for the Dreamers, it would be a revenue generator, and it would allow law enforcement officers to focus on more important and possibly deadly cases. DACA isn’t just a policy, it is people’s lives.
To start off, DACA can provide a possible path to citizenship for the Dreamers. Dreamers are people who were brought into America under the age of 18 by their parents. Many Dreamers will start being deported back to the countries they were born in. According to americanprogress.org, “Each day congress delays acting on the Dream Act from now until March 5, 2018 approximately 122 people will lose their DACA protection. That is 851 people each week, and more than 7,900 since the announcement.” For most of the Dreamers, America is their home and they don’t know any other place. With the Dream Act Dreamers have an open path to legalization. …show more content…
For example, “If the 800,000 people under DACA right now each paid a 2,000 dollar fine to resolve their illegal status and paid their back taxes, several million dollars in additional revenues would be created while the United States also gets the benefit from the enhanced GDP of these additional workers” (vittana.org). With DACA more legalizations would occur. Mandatory fines and back taxes that may be owed will add to America’s economy. Vittana.org also says that more workers will appear and won’t be “working under the bench”, meaning won’t be paid in cash. This would also boost our

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Miriam's American Dream (DACA)

...“DACA means everything to me...DACA has become a reassuring force to many students like myself who’s only desire is to be given an education in order to become a successful factor of this society ” (The New York Times). This quote came from Miriam Ochoa-Garibay, a political science major at UCR and a participant in the Deferred Action for Children Arrivals program, who recently told her story as a part of a New York Times opinion piece. Miriam is one of the 800,000 “DREAMers” who came to the United States as children who find protection through the DACA policy and a perfect example of a life improved by the program (Lind). She came to the United States as a two year old but would have been incapable of receiving financial aid or legal work...

Words: 1438 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

DACA Argumentative Essay

...One of the major complications when dealing with the DACA programs is the fact that it is just an executive order. “We need a fix desperately, and the simplest way to get one that works is to enact DACA into law, precisely as it is.” (Epstein) By making it into a clean deal it has the best chance of succeeding as a political compromise. By allowing them to have the ability of obtaining a driver’s license, Social Security, and employment, it reduces the risk that DACA recipients will burden society. By keeping the two-year period cycle, it leaves more room for deliberation after “greater experience with a policy” (Epstein) This allows for more cooperation also, and not going into a solution too quickly that would hurt the citizens and DREAMers...

Words: 595 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Persuasive Essay: Making Children's Dreams Come True

...Making Children’s Dreams Come True Immigration has been a heavily debated issue in United States politics for decades. It is a topic that policymakers weigh in on concerns of the nation’s security and its economy. Congress, which is in charge of evaluating laws is unable to effectively resolve an agreement on establishing a reform for immigration, making the decision policies transfer onto the executive branch. The executive’s responsibility to place a definitive reform on immigration will lead to dissatisfaction with the states and local governments. The notion of the immigration system has always been confounding to its own legislature that constitutes regulations on the naturalization process. In these case, children who came here illegally...

Words: 1119 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Obama's Immigration Executive Orders 2016

...Public Policy: Immigration The reforms that President Obama are trying to properly execute throughout the states is changing life for immigrants today. Obama recently gave two Executive Orders, the DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) and DAPA (Deferred Action for Parents for Americans), which are helping families resist separation. The big question on Obama’s immigration Executive Orders are if they are within the President’s power. It is Congress’s job to made the laws and the president’s to executive them, but with the creation of DAPA and DACA, many think that Obama is overstepping his authority. One big reason why President Obama felt the need to create his Executive Order is because of the what happened in 2013 when the Senate first created a bill addressing immigration. The bill was created by the Gang of Eight, which were composed of four Democrats and four Republicans, which was lead by Democrat Senator Chuck Schumer. They passed a bill with a vote of 68-32. The bill “promises to overhaul immigration laws for the first time since 1986…” (Silverleib). The 1,200 page document would change four things, the first is that it creates a new 13-year pathway for citizenship for a majority of the undocumented immigrants. It would also raise the cap on visas for highly skilled workers, while also creating a new visa program for lowly skilled workers who would be working on America’s farms. The issue that House of Representatives were most concerned with was border security...

Words: 1316 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Inmigration Reform

...solution for creating a stronger, more successful, and unified nation. America is a nation of immigrants, and welcoming immigrants reflects the key values on which this country is based: hard work, perseverance, taking on challenges, demonstrating individuality, and showing compassion. In addition, immigration reform is a bipartisan issue where everyone can agree that a working immigration system contributes to a stronger country—economically, socially, and culturally. Anti-immigrant pundits often downplay the importance of immigration to America’s future, treating immigrants and immigration as a threat. While there are plenty of legitimate issues to question and debate in immigration policy, choosing to use the topic as a wedge issue, stirring up fear and uncertainty, hoping to pit people against each other, is not only unproductive, but damaging to our civic life. The facts make it clear that reform of our immigration system can benefit everyone. We must ensure that we have a legal immigration system that works, which will make it far easier to...

Words: 4017 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Newborn Health

...U.N. Commission on Life Saving Commodities for Women and Children: Country Case Studies May 2012 This is a working document. It has been prepared to facilitate the exchange of knowledge and to stimulate discussion. The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this paper are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the policies or views of the United Nations Commission on Life-Saving Commodities for Women and Children or the United Nations. The text has not been edited to official publication standards, and the Commission accepts no responsibility for errors. The designations in this publication do not imply an opinion on legal status of any country or territory, or of its authorities, or the delimitation of frontiers. Contributors and Acknowledgements Sarah Blake,1 Aubrey Cody,1 Anjali Kaur,1 Nejla Liias, 1 Christopher Lindahl,2 Emily Bell,1 Julie Kragh,1 Jessica Mack,1 and Kristin Cox Mehling1 served as researchers and authors of this working paper. The authors would like to thank the following individuals for their contributions to the development and conceptualization of these case studies: Oliver Sabot Hans Hogerzeil Patricia Mechael Catherine Taylor Kanika Bahl Julia White Kabir Ahmed Mark Young Renee van de Weerdt Deborah Armbruster Jennifer Lockwood-Bergeson Michael Mbizvo Clinton Health Access Initiative Groningen University mHealth Alliance PATH Results for Development Institute UN Secretariat UNFPA UNICEF UNICEF USAID USAID WHO ...

Words: 60793 - Pages: 244