...THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTERMANCHESTER bUSINESS sCHOOL | “Double-Edged Sword”, Emotional Labour | :The examination of the extent to which emotional labour is harmful for workers | | | BMAN31430: Human Resource ManagementCourse Coordinator: Dr. Isabel Tavora799264112TH NOV 2013 | This paper aims to explore fundamental concept of emotional labour, based on the empirical case studies in order to attempt to answer the question, “Is emotional labour really harmful for workers?”, and also investigate the contradictory claim that it is not harmful, including the practical recommendations for problematic emotional labour. | CONTENTS 1. Introduction………..………………………………….…..…… 2 2. Emotional Labour……….…………….…………….………… 3 Surface Acting………….………………………………………………….….……. 3 Deep Acting……………………………………………………………………….... 4 3. Is Emotional Labour Really Harmful for Workers?................ 5 4. Does Emotional Labour Positively Affect Employees?............. 7 5. Recommendations for Problematic Emotional Labour.............8 Creating ‘Downtime’………………………….…………………………….......... 8 Calming Strategies………………………………………………………………... 9 Cognitive Restructuring…………………………………………………………... 9 6. Conclusion…………………………………….……………….. 10 7. References….………………………………….……………….. 11 1. Introduction “Every time you see a guest, smile and offer an appropriate hospitality comment. Speak to every guest in a friendly, enthusiastic and courteous...
Words: 3222 - Pages: 13
...All work is emotional work. Discuss. Emotions are described as reactions to objects or situations, whereas emotions in the workplace, for instance emotional labour, are referred to as organisationally desired emotions during interpersonal transactions that employees express. Emotion at work, as describe by many researchers, can push individuals to behave in unusual ways and for this reason, organizations have tried to curb the level of emotion that is displayed at the workplace. Often, the problem that most management teams have is in finding the right balance between the levels of emotions that can be displayed within their company and how stringent should their rules be to ensure that emotional displays are curbed. The management teams across organizations are often accuse of being insensitive towards the needs of their employees, where they have been so occupied with trying to maintain a certain degree of discipline in which they have failed to recognize the emotional issues that creep into individuals. According to Hochschild (1983), emotion involves the physical coordination of the body, the mental planning of actions, and the emotional inducement or suppression of feelings. He defines emotional labour as the use of techniques in emotion management, or emotion work, to control the emotions that are expressed as an integral part of a particular process of labour. Emotional labour are undertaken whenever a job requires one to induce or suppress feeling in order to sustain...
Words: 2022 - Pages: 9
...sociological studies into emotions. The theoretical perspectives of Durkheim (1976), Kemper (1978; 1987), Barbalet (1992), and Hochschild (2003; 1979; 1975) will be discussed. Furthermore, this paper will critically evaluate Hochschild’s (2003) concept of emotional labour. Critics have positively appraised and defended her thesis, where they argue that the concept is applicable and relevant in the workplace. However, many scholars have negatively evaluated her thesis by highlighting many...
Words: 1385 - Pages: 6
...A Report On Employee Demotivation Submitted to: Mr Shaiful Islam CEO Human Resource Department Grameen Phone Submitted by: Mr Khalid Mahmod(1020088) Director Mr Atiqur Rahman(1020102) Sales Executive Mr Taifur Rahman(1020099) Planning Executive Mr Toufiq Islam(1020077) Procurement Executive Date of submission: 22 November 2010 Grameen Phone Block-B,Road-16 Bashundhara Residential Area Dhaka 1217 Telephone:+8802 9987456 Fax:+8802 9652314 E-mail:info@grameenphone.com Websie:www.grameenphone.com ...
Words: 4254 - Pages: 18
...Florida, Florida, FL, USA SHTM, Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong, Hong Kong a r t i c l e i n f o Keywords: Burnout Occupational commitment Emotional intelligence Emotional labour Organizational citizenship behaviour Task performance Moderation a b s t r a c t This study examines how emotional intelligence and occupational commitment have a moderating effect on the relationship between emotional labour and its potential outcomes. Two acting strategies reflect emotional labour, namely surface and deep acting, with burnout and performance as the prospective outcomes. Burnout is operationalized into emotional exhaustion, depersonalization and diminished personal achievement; whereas performance is operationalized into task performance and organizational citizenship behaviour (OCB). The study investigates employee responses from several tourism and hospitality organizations in Florida, USA. The results show that emotional labour relates most positively to task performance and to burnout in the case of surface acting. Tests of moderation show that occupational commitment enhances performance outcomes by facilitating emotional labour strategies, and the prevalence of higher emotional intelligence amongst employees reduces burnout. These findings contribute to the literature on emotional labour by...
Words: 6122 - Pages: 25
...keep calm and should be polite to the client despite the customer may be impolite, annoying. And it is what we call a way of controlling him/herself, overcoming difficult and negative situations. According to Ashforth and Humprey, there are 10 dimensions of feeling rules including reliability, truthfulness, understandability etc. And these change according to the situation, depending on the behavior of customers. Depending on the service sectors the degree of using these rules change. Some industries require using more, some do less. Overall, we can conclude that emotional behavior is one of the most crucial and fundamental issues that big organizations and companies should obey its rules. “Feeling rules” are set of rules to analyze and understand emotional labour. Emotional labour has two types which are surface and deep acting. Clients expect from companies good service according to 10 dimensions. Emotional labour is very...
Words: 313 - Pages: 2
...occupations which required the emotional labor to perform the job. Child Care Worker is one of the occupations which need emotional labor. According to ( Lopez, 2006) child care worker jobs involve the emotional labor while delivering the emotional care to the children. Child care worker plays vital aspects in developing emotional, socialization of the Children ( Ahn, 2005). The profession of the Child care worker is expected to deliver with well-established rules and practises regarding emotional display. As the job of the child care worker required emotion displays which may form the dissonance between the child worker true emotion and the emotion child care worker enactment during the role (Lee and Brothering, 2011). The authors also explain that in order to decrease this dissonance, the child care worker may hide their true feeling in order to display the emotion required for the job( surface acting ) or the child worker may raise up the emotion which is essential for the display ( active deep acting). According to ( ) young child care workers generally display the deep acting, but the experienced child care work hide their true feelings in order to display the emotions required for the job. Due to the daily contact with the children and their parents, child care worker frequently experience pressure at work which results to the job stress and exhaustion ( Cordes and Dougherty 1993). Different research and findings discussed that gendered emotional labor and the sexual difference...
Words: 777 - Pages: 4
...DOING EMOTIONAL LABOUR: DEALING WITH IRATE AND MESSY GUESTS The reception section had to deal with multifarious demands and queries by guests: ‘the front desk is more pressured [than switchboard], they get millions of questions’ (Guest Services Manager). This constant questioning regularly involved being on the receiving end of complaints, or as one woman who had transferred into the front desk from another department described it, ‘when you’re actually at the front desk, you get it’ (FDA1).5 As Faulkner and Patiar (1997, p. 104) have commented, ‘whatever the cause of the guests’ dissatisfaction, it is the front office staff who are required to deal with them face to face and resolve the problem’. Resolving guests’ problems involved having to manage both the guests’ and their own feelings and in so doing undertake emotional labour, along the lines indicated by Hochschild (1983), in which smiling through adversity was an expected part of the job. Dealing with ‘lots of complaints’ and the complex negotiating skills involved in doing so was described at length by one of the women front desk agents: That’s one of the things that’s tiring. I have to sit there and smile and be happy and be jolly for eight hours a day. And then have somebody come and like scream 51 Just Labour: A Canadian Journal of Work and Society – Volume 10 – Spring 2007 in my face or like, getting all upset. We’re obviously here before the restaurant, here is where the housekeeping [unclear], we’re always here...
Words: 907 - Pages: 4
...capture the realities of work in a modern economy. Because traditionally thought that in terms of their technical aspects in many front line service job is low skilled , then actually suggest as form of skilled work since they require their employers to perform skilled emotional labor in their dealing with customers ( Bolton, 2004, Korczynski ,2005). Thus , According to Payne, he seeks to open up a critical discussion of the opinions and the key arguments of those authors who look a view the emotional labour as a form of skilled works in his article “ Emotional Labour and Skill : A Reappraisal “ was published by 2009 . Transfer to another aspects between gender and work, Leidner (1988) feels that the gender typed interaction is an expression of workers in their occupation. So, he did analysis of two highly routinized interactive services job “Serving Hamburgers and Selling Insurance”. This article explores the interrelationship of work, gender and identity. In this paper, we will have a critique in the main points of the two articles about emotional labor and skills, and the difference gender in the routinized interaction. Firstly, According to Payne (2009), the ability of front –line staff to perform emotional work, whether it takes the forms of enthusiasm, politeness or remaining calm under pressure, is seen as making a vital contribution to customer satisfaction and competitive advantage ( Heskett ,1997) .As a evidence, the readers also permit that today, for many front-line...
Words: 1457 - Pages: 6
...Chapter 4 Workplace Emotions, Attitudes, and Stress Y Learning Objectives After reading this chapter, you should be able to: LO1 Explain how emotions and cognition (conscious reasoning) influence attitudes and behaviour. LO2 Identify the conditions that require, and the problems associated with, emotional labour. LO3 Describe the four dimensions of emotional intelligence. LO4 Summarize the consequences of job dissatisfaction in terms of the exit-voice-loyaltyneglect model. LO5 Discuss the effects of job satisfaction on job performance and customer service. LO6 Distinguish affective and continuance commitment, and discuss their influences on employee behaviour. LO7 Describe five strategies to increase organizational (affective) commitment. LO8 Define stress and describe the stress experience. LO9 Explain why a stressor might produce different stress levels in two people. LO10 Identify five ways to manage workplace stress. ou know the fun is about to begin at Suntech Optics when employees spot the pineapple wearing sunglasses. The bespectacled fruit is mascot for the North Vancouver-based eyewear supplier’s Have Fun Team, which is responsible for creating various forms of workplace levity. Employees might discover a puzzle on their desk, with a prize awarded to the person who first solves it. Dozens of stuffed bears are brought to work on Bring Your Teddy Bear to Work Day. Halloween is a special treat as staff dress up...
Words: 15522 - Pages: 63
...decisions are made, how managers are able to motivate their employees to increase productivity, and how conflicts and negotiations are handled. It stands to reason that if employees are happy and enjoy coming to work then they will be more productive. According to Barsade and Gibson, “…the evidence is overwhelming that experiencing and expressing positive emotions and moods tends to enhance performance at individual, group, and organizational levels” (Barsade & Gibson, 2007). Frost describes a mechanism of “emotional contagion” where when the leaders express positive emotions, the staff will be influenced by this and the outcomes tend to be positive (Frost, 2004). It would stand to reason then, that in a company with displays of negative emotions, the opposite would result. Affect is an umbrella term used by Barsade and Gibson as a range of discrete emotions (fear, anger, joy), moods (cheerful, sad), dispositional traits (negative, upbeat) and even emotional intelligence (understanding other people’s feelings). The following chart illustrates the Model of Affect. (Barsade & Gibson, 2007). On this chart the x axis is a measure of pleasantness and the y axis measures energy. It would make sense that the top right quadrant would represent a successful company and that the bottom left quadrant would represent a company...
Words: 5752 - Pages: 24
...fail to keep up with others in the movement of the world today, especially to their competitors. Organization need to work even harder to attract, develop and to retain the best candidates to serve as the next generation of leaders. In the history of various cultures, women have always excelled than men. According to the list of Fortune 1000 list of companies publishes by Fortune Magazine, women hold 4.6 percent of Fortune 1000 list of CEO position. Despite of being minority in managerial world, women make a better manager because they are highly motivated, easy to communicate, have the power to convince people and have a capability called emotional intelligence (EQ). Women have different driven factor which can boost their desire that makes them highly motivated than men. The survey conducted in October 2004 by Research Institute of Labour and Social Affairs found that men place their motivation factor on ‘instrumental values’ such as basic salary and bonuses. On the other hand, women are motivated as they do...
Words: 1793 - Pages: 8
...Final Project Proposal Introduction | Forensic accounting may not be a new field in accounting. However it becomes so important recently and has been an interest to various stakeholders, from the government, investors, and practitioners to regulatory bodies. In public sector, the increment in frauds, money laundering, corruptions, illegal or unethical acts and other wrongdoings are the main factors to support the needs of forensic accounting skills in public sector working environment especially in public sector accountants. The need for forensic accountant has been ascribed to the fact that the audit system in an organization had failed to detect certain errors in the system.Demand for Forensic Accountants (FAs) is growing fast because of the use of information technology to commit crimes, growing corruption, and harsh economic times that are making some workers to steal from their employers or assets of organization. In more recent years, Accountants (FAs)who worked in public practice were often called after owners suspected that fraud had been committed.This research is to study the needs of good forensic skills in public sector working environment especially within public sector accountant. | Problem Statement | The public sector constitutes the largest sector of the economy of any nation, It employs the largest population of the labor force and controls the bulk of financial resources of any country. It therefore calls for a proper financial resources...
Words: 1012 - Pages: 5
...EMOTIONAL QUOTIENT “A TOOL FOR INDIVIDUAL AND ORGANISATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS ” M.Badmapriya , School Of Management Hindustan University, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India ABSTRACT Emotional Quotient is a concept, which comprises Emotional Competency, Emotional Maturity, and Emotional Sensitivity. Emotional Competency constitutes the capacity to responding tactfully for various situations, Emotional Maturity constitutes evaluating emotions of oneself and others, and Emotional Sensitivity constitutes managing immediate environments, Maintaining rapport, harmony, and comfort with others. Emotional Quotient is considered as the subset of social Intelligence that involves the ability to monitor one's own and others' feelings and emotions, to discriminate among them and to use this information to guide one's thinking and actions. This research work makes an attempt to establish the magnitude of emotional quotient among the management executives of the Manufacturing Industry. The research is restricted to management executives who will be key decision makers in terms of both long and short-term goals. INTRODUCTION Happiness, fear, anger, affection, shame, disgust, surprise, lust, sadness are emotions, which directly affect our day-to-day life. For long, it has been believed that success at the workplace depends on our level of Intelligence quotient (IQ) as reflected in our academic achievements, exams passed, marks obtained, etc. All these are instances of intelligence...
Words: 6542 - Pages: 27
...SUMMIT GROUP Words- 3098 University of Chittagong Assignment on Organizational Behaviour Topics:Emotional Intelligence (EI) Submitted to: Md. Sahidur Rahman Associate Professor Dept. of Management Studies University of Chittagong. Submitted by: |S/L |Name |ID | |01 |Md. Tanvir Rahman (L) |08302067 | |02 |Md. Sazidul Karim |08302073 | |03 |Md. Arfatul Islam |08302116 | |04 |S.M. Almas Hossain |08302118 | |05 |Md. Abul Basar |08302140 | |06 |Jolakha Afrin |08302012 | |07 |Bristy Rani Banik |08302023 | |08 |Lipi Barua ...
Words: 3639 - Pages: 15