Free Essay

Equal Pay for Equal Work

In:

Submitted By leecygirl
Words 1556
Pages 7
In the 1800’s women were held to a higher moral standard then man which enabled women to enter the workforce. American culture expected women to preserve the family values not become “money makers” or head of the household. Women were unable to enter the workforce, vote, or get an education until the 19th century and even after they had received rights their rights were not equal to a mans. Institutions refused to allow women in educational programs and since they were economically dependent upon men, women had a poor socioeconomic status. Until the World Wars, that demanded women’s help in all areas of the labor market did society start to accept women as more than Susie-Home-Makers. The role of women drastically changed after the World Wars yet pay for women remained unequal to that of men, this led to the equal rights movement were women demanded “equal pay for equal work” (4). Working women ranked equal pay as a top priority for Congress in 2001 and the issue reemerged under President Barack Obama when he signed an amendment to the Fair Pay Act last year. The consequences of not acting on this important issue is plummeting tax revenues and further widened income inequality during an already starving US economy. Personal income taxes, child care taxes, earned income tax credits, payroll taxes, and state and local taxes all have aspects that affect the majority of women. Most of the tax system was drafted during the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s when most women were not in the workforce.

Women’s Contribution to Labor
In the 19th century primarily women’s work was “duties around the house”. Examples would be domestic services, clothing shops, and commerce services that handled the trade of common goods. A number of occupations became "professionalized" through the 19th and 20th centuries requiring higher educational status. As a woman’s access to higher education was often limited, this effectively restricted women's participation in these professionalized occupations.
During World War I thousands of women were called on to perform field nursing services within the military. The overwhelming demand for nurses was due to the massive number of wounded soldiers. This was an opportunity for unskilled women to enter the workforce and receive much needed training that otherwise would have gone to men. Women became truck and ambulance drivers as more and more of the men were called to the front line. Other areas that needed to be filled on the base by women during the war were tasks such as cooking and catering, storekeeping, clerical work, administration, printing, and motor vehicle maintenance.
Another organization that was created during World War I out of pure necessity was “Women’s Land Army” which was set up in 1917 to provide a workforce that would run the farms and agricultural business. Many farms had been left unattended with 6 million men away fighting in the First World War which left a massive food shortage. Since the soldiers needed to eat to fight the government decided women should get more involved in the production of food to do their part and support the war efforts. During World War I 80,000 women worked as farm laborers (2). Eventually, women were called to assist in the war effects of World War II.
During War II there was a movement towards modern industrialized factories which women had another chance to penetrate the workforce. The previous wars were fought on the battlefield with single barrel guns and knives. World War II hinged on industrial production with the war being fought with modern guns, aircrafts, and ships. Although, society never would have allowed women to work in areas that were preserved for men, the government had no choice but to allow women into these forbidden fields. It was out of necessity to use collective skills due to the nature of the war itself.
Many men left their jobs to join the war in Europe and elsewhere, opening opportunities and places for women to take over in the job force. With a massive shortage in labor and a huge demand for military services women were called on to work in the war factories and take on positions within the military that were outside their traditional gender expectations. Women joined the federal government in massive numbers during World War II. Nearly a million "government girls" were recruited for war work. They performed volunteer aid work for the war efforts by planting victory gardens, canning produce, selling war bonds, donating blood, salvaging needed commodities and sending care packages. The entire population made an expansion of the role of women during World War II.
In 1944, more than 1.8 million women were working towards the war efforts building ships, aircraft, vehicles, and weaponry all while not receiving equal pay to men (1). The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 established a national minimum wage, guaranteed time-and-a-half for overtime in certain jobs, and prohibited most employment of minors. However, the FLSA act did not prohibit discrimination on account of gender in the form of payment of wages to employees. Because of the large number of American women taking jobs during World War II, the National War Labor Board urged employers to voluntarily make "adjustments which would equalize wage or salary rates paid to females with the rates paid to males for comparable quality and quantity of work on the same or similar operations” (2). The outlook of what women could do had been established and they gained their place in the workforce as women were now getting paid to do traditional “men’s work” just at a lower pay scale. Nevertheless, employers failed to heed this "voluntary" request and at the war's end most women were pushed out of their new jobs to make room for returning veterans. The number of women in the labor force went from 1.1 million in 1945 to 6.4 thousand in 1946 and continued to decrease each year (1).
The pay gap for women has narrowed slightly over the past decade but women remain underrepresented in management positions, according to a 2007 report from the Government Accountability Office (7). Despite women being 47 percent of the U.S. workforce, women only filled 40 percent of managerial positions. Female managers earned 81 cents for every dollar compared to their male counterparts during that year. That's an average salary of $52,000 for women and $75,000 for men.

Women’s Significance to Income Taxes
By the 1960s the women’s right movement that some called "feminism" or "women's liberation” was well under way pushing for women’s equality. Reformers wanted the same pay as men, equal rights in law, and the freedom to plan their families or not have children at all. President John Kennedy responded in 1961 by establishing the President’s Commission on the Status of Women (PCSW). The legislation discouraged discrimination against women in the workplace and encouraged employers to make specific recommendations for improvement, including fair hiring practices, paid maternity leave, and affordable child care. The Equal Pay Act of 1963 was passed which amended the FLSA to make it illegal to pay workers lower wages strictly on the basis on their sex. This was a major step towards closing the wage gap in women’s pay.
Due to the expense of the Civil War Congress abolished internal taxes, which supported US government through taxes on refined sugar, snuff, corporate bonds, property sold at auctions, and slaves, The federal income tax became a permanent fixture in the tax system with the United States Revenue Act of 1913. Today, gender differences in tax treatment may affect women’s decision to work. Women may have more incentives to participate in the labor market where equal income distribution is favored by tax rules.. married couple faces a "marriage penalty" if their two incomes are similar and they file a joint return, since the second income (usually the wife's) is taxed at a significantly higher marginal rate than if she filed as an individualBut if a couple forgoes the wife's second income (or if one person's income is appreciably lower), they may pay less as joint filers than they would have as singles (the marriage "bonus"). Both situations can reduce the incentive for a married woman to work outside the home. When women work, they pay taxes into the Social Security system, providing for their own benefits
Conclusion
By the early 1980s, it was largely perceived that women had met their goals and succeeded in changing social attitudes towards gender roles. Over the course of the past 40 years women have taken on greater roles in society such as serving in government and many have taken advantage of opportunities in higher education. Progress has been made in professional fields such as medicine, law, and science. Today the number of women in government and traditionally male-dominated fields has dramatically increased, and in 2009 women were expected to pass men in the American workforce. Although, the wake of the feminist movement has narrowed the wage gap, there still exists a significant wage gap between the sexes so women will still have to fight to gain equal pay for equal work so we can contribute to the tax system.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Equal Pay Act

...variations with the “Equal Pay Act”. The thoughts and ideas of discrimination against those of different genders and how they relate to the pay scale. Being based on experience and time on the job plays a major part in the role of individuals involved in the working environment. Exploring the ideas and concepts behind this act and how it has transformed over a course of 50 years. Looking at real cases and even scholarly articles from individuals such as Christina Hoff Summers. Keywords: Equal Pay Act, Gender, Male and Female There are many laws that have prohibited individuals from being able to do certain things. One of the main things that we have seen throughout our time is the idea and concept that laws are not always for the people. When it comes to working a job, many people will focus on experience, education and previous job training that an individual has held to determine their pay. However, we have seen other issues that do not even apply to that. The “Equal Pay Act” was created so no one in the working lifestyle would be or could be discriminated against for any reason pertaining to the job and their pay. In a world full of opportunities, no one expects to go into somewhere and not receive the correct pay due discrimination which is illegal and unfair in many aspects of life. The Equal Pay Act requires that men and women in the same workplace be given equal pay for equal work. The jobs need not be identical, but they must be substantially equal. (http://www.eeoc...

Words: 3577 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Executive Summary: Equal Pay For Everyone

...Equal Pay for Everyone Equal Pay: Equity is all that women are asking for their time worked, and that is what they deserve. Women should be given just as much as men because they have the right to fair and equal pay, like men they are educated and skilled, and they can be just as productive as men if not more. For this to happen it would take time and change within the Government. There is not an established date or time for it to occur. It is a work in progress that has to be approached carefully. No one lives to work we all work to live in hopes of building a free community for our families. Both women and men work hard each day to make ends meet financially. Women are not worthy of the pay that men may receive for working the same amount...

Words: 1515 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Equal Pay Act

...Equal Pay Act Equal Pay Act, which was introduced by the Unite States, was intended to prohibit discrimination of sex in the payment of wages by employers. Nowadays, when designing the internal alignment piece of compensation program, we should pay more attention to the law. Personally, I believe that Equal Pay Act plays an indispensable role in designing the salary program and the reasons are as fellows. First and foremost, the importance of Equal Pay Act largely lies in that it plays a part in eliminating discrimination by law. Equal Pay Act, which was issued in 1963, takes the lead in advocating the concept of equal pay for equal work in the Unite States. Therefore, we should conform to the law in the progress of making compensation program. In other words, we should attach importance to regulate the internal alignment piece of compensation program according to law. Secondly, there is no denying that equal pay for equal work persists in maintaining the internal equity, which is one of the most important object of pay management. According to Adams’s equity theory, when employees get paid, they care about not only the absolute amount of the salary but also the relative pay. They will use many kinds of methods to judge whether the salary is reasonable and the result will affect the enthusiasm of employees. Last but not least, equal pay has its great values for improving the company performance in the long run. On the one hand, equal pay can reduce...

Words: 350 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Wilson Brothers Case

...------------------------------------------------- Wilson Brothers case 1. The notion requires that the pay is equal when men and women are doing similar work. Men and women must receive equal pay when doing substantially the same work, effort, responsibility, skill and working conditions in the same company. This notion is in the Employee Standards Act legislation. 2. For the notion Equal Pay for Work of Equal Value is based on the level of skill, effort, responsibility and work conditions involved in the job. Male tradition jobs consist of truck driving, fire fighter, factory, etc. Female tradition jobs consist of childcare worker, secretary, nurse, etc. because of the differences in skills, effort and responsibilities for the traditional jobs for men and women the Equal pay for Work of Equal Value come into play to make it fair. This notion is part of the Pay Equity Act. (Your Legal Rights, 2015) 3. To implement the notion Equal Pay for Work of Equal Value I would start by making sure there’s no gender based pay discrimination. I would also produce and require that all the employees do a job evaluation to determine their position/roll in the workplace and to determine what they’re salary/wage would be. In the Job evaluation I would specifically be looking for four factors which are the skills, effort, work condition and responsibilities of each employee. To make sure that this is a successful decision I would review the results periodically...

Words: 487 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Equal Pay Inequality In America

...Right now, the unfortunate truth in America is that men and women are not receiving equal pay. An issue since the 1960’s, pay inequality based on gender still seems to an issue running rampant in today’s business world. While many people believe that equal pay is a must for men and women, there are many reasons why bridging the pay gap would hurt the economy, thus actually reeking more havoc than gender pay inequality ever has. Pay inequality is a major issue for many that remains in the forefront of the news. Pay inequality, otherwise known as the pay gap was brought to light in 1963 when the Equal Pay Act of 1963 labor law was amended to abolish wage disparity based on sex (“The Equal Pay Act: Equal Pay for Women”). While this amended law...

Words: 1399 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Women's Rights in Denmark

...market in Europe, with close to 80 percent of women being employed. They are highly respected in business and generally receive equal pay as men. To continue, women also have access to senior positions and can easily arrange flexible hours which make it possible for them to maintain both a career and a family. Before analyzing the different legislations in Denmark concerning women’s business rights, we will first discuss the concept of gender equality. II. Minister for Gender Equality Since July 1, 1999 Denmark has a minister for gender equality. He is responsible for the Government's overall activities in the field of gender equality and co-ordinates the equality work of other ministries. Gender equality between women and men has always been a general principle and objective of Danish policy. Changing governments have continuously worked to review and improve the quality of legislation and other legally binding rules to achieve gender equality between women and men. Today, women and men in Denmark share the same formal rights, obligations and opportunities in society. This is clearly stated in section 1 of the Danish Act on Gender Equality, which reads that “The purpose of this Act is to promote gender equality, including equal integration, equal influence and equal opportunities in all functions in society on the basis of women's and men's equal status.” Next to the minister of gender equality there are also other actors like the Board of...

Words: 1621 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Not Always Equal

...What does “equal pay for equal work” mean? It means that two individuals should be paid identically, if they perform similar jobs and work for the same amount of hours. Everyone should be treated equally in the work place, no matter their gender or race, if the playing fields in which they are participating are equal. This refers to a controversial topic: should male and female tennis players receive the same prize money if the playing fields are not equal? Females compete for less time than the men do, yet get paid an equal amount. Men should be earning more money than women in the sport of tennis if “equal pay for equal work” was really being applied. The men and women’s tours are completely separate entities, with different schedules and different sponsors, for all of except six tournaments throughout the tennis season, in which they compete at the same venues. The Grand Slams: the Australian Open, the French Open, the Wimbledon Championships and the US Open, comprise four of these six tournaments and are the holy grails of the sport. The winner has a daunting task of winning seven matches over a twoweek period against the best players in the world. The incredibly rewarding financial prize that is rewarded to the champions at the end of the two weeks is identical between the men and the women. There would not be a problem or an opposing argument against women receiving equal pay at the Grand Slams if the playing fields were the same. The problem is that the...

Words: 965 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Discriminatory Wage Gap

...40-year career, the average woman will lose $431,000.00 to the gender wage gap” (Cooper 1). Does this seem fair? It seems quite obvious to the common observer that there should be equal pay across the board for the same job accomplished regardless of gender, education or any other factor one might dream up. Nevertheless, according to most research and authorities on the subject of equal pay, there is a gap between the earnings of men and women. Moreover, as one delves into the subject more thoroughly, one notes it is much more complicated than simply equal pay for the same work performed. Women are greatly affected by the wage gap over time where they lose a significant amount of money the closer they are to retirement. As of April, 2014, the Center for American Progress states that to every dollar a man makes, a woman makes 77 cents (Cooper 1). Thus, it is apparent that women are still behind the men in terms of equal pay in the workforce. While women's pay in the workforce has traditionally been less than a man’s it nevertheless has increased over the years; however, as of 2014 there still exists a pay gap which can only be addressed through legislation, enforcement of that legislation and awareness by all that inequality is unacceptable. Throughout history women have never been given equal pay in the workforce and this inequality extends to modern days. “Until the early 1960s, newspapers published separate job listings for men and women. Jobs were categorized according...

Words: 2903 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Eeoc

...Sues Extended Stay Hotels for Pay Discrimination Based on Sex Equal Employment Opportunity Commission EEOC Sues Extended Stay Hotels for Pay Discrimination Based on Sex Blair Morse Sociology/315 July 15, 2013 Professor Ms. Anne Tindall EEOC Sues Extended Stay Hotels for Pay Discrimination Based on Sex Abstract In the paper it will discuss why EEOC Sues Extended Stay Hotels for Pay Discrimination Based on Sex. The paper will include the following: A description of the compliance issue that led to the lawsuit and its ramifications for the organization, a brief summary of the functions of the EEOC in one paragraph, the EEOC’s role in this lawsuit, whether or not this lawsuit promotes social change; justify your reasoning, a comparison of the EEOC press release to the news item. What accounts for the differences, and strategies you would implement, if you were a senior manager of this company, to ensure future compliance and inclusion in the multicultural workplace. The lawsuit that I have chosen is about a company paying lower wages because of their gender. According to the EEOC, female guest services representatives at Extended Stay Hotels received lower salaries than male guest services representatives, which, if true, is a violation of the Equal Pay Act of 1963 (EPA) and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The Equal Pay Act requires that men and women in the same workplace be given equal pay for equal work. The jobs need not be identical...

Words: 1178 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Res/351 Bussiness Research Part 1

...Week Three Team “C” Business Equal Pay Paper RES/351 October 12, 2013 Instructor: Fredrick Ohanesian Business Equal Pay Paper Many years in the pass, it has always been known that the pay scales or opportunity for men and women have been unequal in favor of men. There have been many reasons for the indifferences but none of them have been proven to be true. It is only now that it has become an issue for business due to the government regulations have now made it an ethical issue that has to be addressed or a business can be fined or shutdown if found not to be within the government standards. So the research question then becomes why management or companies continue to try to justify the need not to be regulated when it continues to be a problem within many organizations. Based on the history of this nation it was determined back in the 60’s that there were evidence that pay and benefits differences for women in similar jobs was not equal. The Equal Pay Act of 1963 and reinforced later with the Lilly Ledbetter Act of 2009 which has given the government the tools to address the problems for businesses for now and the future. It stated that if male or female or in a similar job with the same set of skills required to perform it the pay and benefits must be the same. If there is evidence of sex based wage discrimination within the same company or organization the employee or government can open an investigation to see if any equal opportunity laws have been violated. Once...

Words: 973 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

A Study of Pay Inequity Between Genders

...A Study of pay Inequity between Genders   Abstract As long as an American woman is putting in the same amount of hours with the same qualifications and experience in the same occupation as an American male, and yet taking home a wage that is any lower, she is not being treated fairly as an equal. Contrary to many arguments, it is unquestionable that a wage gap exists, and while there are various ideas as to the most probable cause, there is no reason why this gap should continue to go uncorrected or unchanged. Our government should take concrete steps to close the gender wage gap because it violates women’s rights and equality. The story begins at a local Radio Shack, it is Friday, payday. As employees open their paychecks, they are awaiting their annual raise. As one employee, Neha opens up her paycheck she finds she has not yet received a raise; she has waited all year for this raise. She is very sad to find she did not receive one. She begins to think maybe she did something wrong. She starts to think back through the year, and cannot seem to come up with any solutions as to why she did not receive one. She worked especially hard that year in hopes to receive a good raise and felt she deserved to be recognized for it. In the break room she overheard her co-worker John bragging to their colleagues about his second raise. Now John is making a dollar twenty five more per hour than her even though they both have been working at Radio Shack for...

Words: 2595 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Haspayequity Legislation Worked

...purpose of this paper is to discuss if pay equity legislation has worked to eliminate the wage gap between males and females in the workforce. This paper will discuss current pay equity legislation. Federal legislation includes the Canadian Human Rights Act, the Equal Wages Guidelines, and the Canada Labour Code, Part III. Provincial legislation includes the Ontario Pay Equity Act. This paper will also cover a brief time line of the history of pay equity and who is actually covered by pay equity legislation. Lastly, this paper will discuss the gender wage gap and why it exists. Graphs from Statistics Canada will aid in demonstrating the current wage gap and the significant difference in pay for males and females. Has Pay Equity Legislation Worked? Men and women are different in many ways, physically, genetically and anatomically; however they are the same in that they are both human beings who have a right to fair and equal treatment. All throughout history women seem to have taken a back seat to their male counterparts, as women were not officially deemed persons until 1929 after a Supreme Court hearing, they had to struggle to get recognition in the workplace, and to this day are continually fighting for pay equity in the workplace. Pay equity is defined as “the principle that men and women should be compensated equally for work requiring comparable skills, responsibilities, and effort” (Pay Equity, n.d., para. 1). The goal of pay equity “is to stop discrimination related...

Words: 2574 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Discrimination in Promotions and Hiring

...individual merit (Discrimination, 2012). Discrimination can be seen as far back as the beginning of time, and is a thorn in United States history. In US history there were segregated schools, bathrooms, and everything else. Segregation was abolished and other laws had to be passes before the US become like it is today. Voting was restricted to only white men, but laws were passed for everyone to be equal. Many things have changed throughout the years, including working environments. There are laws to protect potential or current employees from being discrimination against. Laws that protect employees from discrimination are the employment discrimination laws. These laws protect the age, race, gender, sexual orientation, disability, and religion of the current or potential employee. Federal and state laws make up the employment discrimination laws. These laws cover the protection of employees in promotions, transferring, dismissal, compensation, benefits, recruiting, testing, training, pay, and much more. Two laws that protect current and potential employees from discrimination are The Equal Pay Act and The Americans with...

Words: 993 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Equality Of Pay Research Paper

...Government 2306 - 014 Equality of Pay It is interesting to realize how anybody can go to the store, see a male and female cashier who both have been working at the store for 7 years, both work equally as hard and even sometimes the female will work harder than the male. Little do people know, is that the female, like many others in the United States, especially in Texas, are only receiving 77% of what her fellow male co worker is making. Currently in Texas, employers are protected by a pay equity policy called the Fair Pay Act of 2013. They are also pending the Fair Minimum Wage act to raise minimum wage in which the costs from $8.20 would rise to $9.15 after one year and...

Words: 1007 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Building a Diverse Workforce Trough Nondiscrimination

...determined efforts to expand the scope of their civil rights. Although equal rights for all were affirmed in the founding documents of this country, many American’s were still denied essential employment rights. Because of the 1960’s Civil Rights Movement, many laws were passed and enacted barring an employer from discriminating against employees on most grounds. Aside from the quality of an employee's work or the nature of his or her personality, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, prohibited an employer with 15 or more employees from discriminating based on race, national origin, gender, or religion (Dessler, 2013). Although under Title VII it was deemed illegal for an employer to refuse to hire or promote, or to unjustly fire, demote, or harass an employee, the law failed to address important equality of pay issues, acts of age discrimination, and discrimination against individuals with disabilities (Dessler, 2013). As a result, federal and state governments enacted additional laws that barred employer discrimination in these three important areas. This paper will describe and discuss how the Equal Pay Act of 1963, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967, and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 came to be. Moreover, this paper will address why the world of human resources must understand, abide by, and execute these three crucially important Equal Employment Opportunity Acts. Equal pay for the sexes Because a large number of American women took industrial...

Words: 1698 - Pages: 7