Premium Essay

Source Memory Experiment

Submitted By
Words 841
Pages 4
Method
Subjects
Twenty high school students between the ages of 14 and 18 from a local high school participated in this experiment. Participants were expected to split into two groups, the control and experimental group, and perform the same experiment on two separate days, but due to scheduling conflicts, some participants took the test in an isolated setting at an earlier or later time. This experiment was approved by my high school’s School Site Council and the Long Beach Unified IRB.
Materials
The materials used for this experiment consisted of three videos from YouTube, three narratives with both repeated information and misinformation about the videos, and a source-memory test. The videos and narratives were presented on a projector, …show more content…
There were two parts to the multiple choice test: recognition and source-memory. The test consisted of 18 questions, with six questions on each video viewed. The test originally had 19 questions, but one was redacted as its phrasing was awkward and confusing. Participants were told to answer the questions based on the details they viewed in the videos. Participants were allowed to choose from three options: the correct answer presenting details from the video, the misinformation item present in the narrative, and a foil, or a new answer that wasn’t mentioned in the videos nor the narratives. Subjects circled their answers. Immediately after each of the recognition questions, subjects were asked where they remembered noticing the question’s response, for which they were able to choose between the following options: “Saw in pictures only,” “Saw in text only,” “Saw in both (they were the same),” “Saw in both (they were different),” and “Neither (I’m guessing).” Subjects responded by circling their answer. The tests given to all participants were …show more content…
The three videos were then shown on an overhead projector. After performing a five-minute distractor task, three narratives corresponding to the previously watched videos were shown on the overhead projector. However, these narratives contained details that didn’t agree with the video, which served the purpose of introducing misinformation. The control group merely read the narratives, whereas the experimental group was told that the narratives contained misinformation and was permitted to note down every time they saw misinformation, thus recognizing it. After both groups performed another distractor task, they both took a multiple choice test, which asked the participants to answer the questions as they remember it from the videos, not the narratives. Participants were able to pick from answer choices A, B, and C. The test also asked where they recalled seeing the answer to the question, and gave the answers mentioned above. Participants were able to pick from answer choices A, B, C, D, and E. The answers to this test was statistically analyzed to determine if there was a correlation between recognizing misinformation and recollecting an

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Eyewitness Testimony

...area of research in cognitive psychology and human memory; studies into eyewitness testimony have found that it can be affected by many factors. Elizabeth Loftus, a leading researcher in eyewitness testimony, conducted studies to demonstrate that memory is not a factual recording of an event and that memories can become distorted by other information which occurs after the event. Loftus and Palmer (1974) study consisted of two laboratory experiments; both were examples of an independent measures design. The independent variable in both of the experiments is the verb used. The dependent variable in the first experiment is the participant’s speed estimate and the dependent variable in the second experiment is whether the participant believed they saw glass. In the first experiment 45 students from the University of Washington were shown video clips, short excerpts from safety films made for driver education, which were 5 to 30 seconds long. They were split into 5 groups, with 9 participants in each group. After each clip the students were asked to write a report of the accident they had just seen. They were also asked to answer some specific questions but the crucial question was ‘about how fast the cars were going when they _______ each other’. Each group was given a different verb to fill in the blank. The independent variable was the verb used, which were ‘smashed, collided, bumped, hit or contacted’. The whole experiment lasted about an hour and a half and the films were...

Words: 1683 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Effects of Common Behaviour on Memory

...LAB EXPERIENCE PAPER MEMORY in HUMAN BEINGS SECTION I: OVERVIEW Memory, is an abstract term with no real concrete definition or absolute understanding thus making the word intriguing enough to draw attention to the greater subject of what it is, how it works and why it goes wrong. It is an essential concept in our daily life yet is the most elusive and misunderstood human attribute. Its constant presence in our everyday and its intricately complex mysteries is what ignites my interest in the research conducted in this field of Psychology. As a college student memory plays a great role in our academic performance, from weather we can recall mathematical formulas to recalling something a professor said in class to remembering certain solutions, key words and definitions we read in course material. Therefore from a personal standpoint the topic of memory interests me, as by understanding this complex concept and going into the depths of it’s functioning, I might be able to improve my own. Memory is formed from childhood and I am interested to see if memory is an natural capacity, and if so what factors lead to a better memory and if not can memory be affected by daily everyday factors. From a Psychological perspective memory excites me because the way we remember things and how can help us understand behavior and reactions to various situations. Memory hence affects decision-making and all other spheres of human life. The recollection of memory, the gaps, failures...

Words: 3499 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Essay On Eyewitness Testimony

...Similarly, to Sherrer, Valentine (2011) performed an experiment to show the effect of cross-examination on the accuracy of an eyewitness testimony. Twenty-two students watched a video of a crime individually or in pairs. The paired witnesses discussed the video with their co-witnesses. Yet, they had not known they had seen slightly different versions. Participants in that had pairs recalled less accurately than individual witnesses. In a cross-examination, there was no difference in accuracy between the two experimental groups. Thus, this experiment showed that the results demonstrated negative effects of cross-examination on the accuracy of adult eyewitness testimony. Likewise, as the third reason, some eyewitness testimonies lie to their advantage. For instance, Henry Drake was sentenced to death in 1977 for the murder of a 74-year old barber during a robbery in Georgia. Whether Drake was found guilty or innocent depended on an eyewitness testimony. The...

Words: 719 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Does Music Make You Smarter

...beneficial to early brain development, autobiographical memory of Alzheimer patients, and language development. To provide you with more facts about music and its beneficial impact on the human brain, I found five sources that provided more facts and studies that prove the benefits of using music in everyday life and for educational purpose. I found research on the impact of music on brain development by using the scholarly writing found in Mohave Community College’s database. The purpose for this paper is to educate my readers on the positive effects music can have on...

Words: 1365 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Outline and Evaluate the Different Levels of Accuracy of Different Types of Witness

...Outline and evaluate the different levels of accuracy of different types of witness Eyewitness testimony (EWT) refers to an account given by people of an event they have witnessed; it is an important area of research in cognitive psychology and human memory. Juries tend to pay close attention to EWT and generally find it a reliable source of information.  However, research into this area has found that EWT can be affected by many psychological factors: anxiety, age, reconstructive memory and consequences. Anxiety is almost always associated with real life crime. Deffenbacher (1989) theorized the ‘Inverted U-theory’ stating that low levels of anxiety cause cognitive performance (memory) to also be relatively low. As the anxiety increases, so does the cognitive performance until optimum level. Any further anxiety produces a rapid drop in the performance. Therefore, it can be predicted that stressful incidents leads to witnesses having inaccurate recall due to their high anxiety levels. Research support for this theory and its relevance EWT can be found in a field experiment carried out by Peters (1988). Loftus (1979) aimed to see whether anxiety in EWT affected later identification. An experimental and control group were tested upon in which the control group overheard a low-key discussion in a lab about an equipment failure. A person then emerged from the laboratory holding a pen in grease covered hands. Next, the experimental group overheard a heated and hostile debate...

Words: 1229 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Robotics

...A Seminar Report ON Human-Oriented Interaction With An Anthropomorphic Robot CONTENTS ➢ Abstract ➢ Index Terms ➢ Introduction ➢ Related Work ➢ Robot Hardware ➢ Detecting And Tracking People * Face Detection * Voice Detection * Memory-Based Person Tracking ➢ Integrating Interaction Capabilities * Speech And Dialog * Emotions And Facial Expressions * Using Deictic Gestures * Object Attention * Dynamic Topic Tracking * Bringing It All Together ➢ Experiments * Scenario 1: Multiple Person Interaction * Scenario 2: Showing Objects to BARTHOC * Scenario 3: Reading Out a Fairy Tale ➢ Conclusion ➢ References Abstract A very important aspect in developing robots capable of human-robot interaction (HRI) is the research in natural, human-like communication, and subsequently, the development of a research platform with multiple HRI capabilities for evaluation. Besides a flexible dialog system and speech understanding, an anthropomorphic appearance has the potential to support intuitive usage and understanding of a robot, e.g .. human-like facial expressions and deictic gestures can as well be produced and also understood by the robot. As a consequence of our effort in creating an anthropomorphic appearance and to come close to a human-human...

Words: 7843 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Reflective Essay

...was able to understand that his limbic system was affected. He was very aggressive and angry toward the staff at the hospital which was caused from the damage to his amygdala. He also displayed damage to each brain hemisphere, some symptoms were more severe than others. The damage to his frontal lobe caused him to try to leave the hospital every chance he could, not able to resist the urge to stay. Within approximately two weeks after the accident he struggled to recognize family and friends caused from damage to his occipital lobe. He also suffered from short-term memory loss which is an effect of damage to his parietal lobe. The most damage caused by the accident occurred within his temporal lobe. He explains long-term memories he remembers, however none of his memories actually occurred. He also remembers things that he couldn’t remember before the accident and forgets the memories he had. As soon as he woke up, after sedation, he would confuse his words, an example was when asking for his “clothes” he...

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Accessibility Theory

...attitudes will predict behavior if they can be activated from memory at a time of decision. In order for this to transpire, the attitude must come spontaneously to mind in a memory. Second, the attitude must influence perceptions of an issue or person serving as a “filter” through which the object is viewed. (Fazio & Roskos –Ewoldsen, 1994 P. 85) Accessibility Theory complements the Reasoned Action Theory and the Theory of Planned Behavior approach because people carefully consider the consequence of behaving in a particular manner and weigh out the pros and cons of situation. When all else fails the decision is based more on spontaneity, channeling a thought or memory. The decisions however can also be based on how accessible attitudes are and how likely objects, good or bad can capture the attention of a person. Research supports these propositions (Krays, 1995) because studies found that individuals who were in touch with favorable attitudes toward a certain topic or product were more inclined to select or choose those with less accessible attitudes. Attitudes play a very important role because they range from strong attitudes to weak attitudes. When a person has a strong attitude toward something most likely the persons mind is made up and set in his or her ways. Vice versa with a weaker attitude which is more susceptible to change. When strong and weak attitudes are already implemented in the mind, thought and memory are automatically activated. Accessibility is also known...

Words: 1835 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

It Innovation

...Formal pathways for innovation that already exist Pg. 8 Opportunities to make processes and the business more innovation friendly Pg. 8 Systematic ways to track innovations and mesure their success Pg. 9 Processes that will help manage innovation Pg. 10 Conclusion Pg. 10 Works Cited Pg. 12 Executive Summary This report contains a current evaluation and analysis of applying strategic rules to innovate the entire Sea Ray organization. The 10 fundamental strategic rules will be discussed and I have chosen three of these rules as the most critical to Sea Ray’s success. Sea Ray must operate in fundamentally different ways when forming an innovation experiment to avoid organizational memory. The success of the experiments will hinge more on experimentation than the initial strategy used. Sea Ray then must not base success on financial performance, but on the ability to learn and adapt. Formal pathways which are currently being used for innovation will be assessed and characterized. Using this pathway data, new modern opportunities will be discussed in order to make Sea Ray more innovation friendly. Sea Ray will also use human resource data instead of research and development data to track and measure their success. Finally, an innovation committee will be formed to manage innovation across Sea Ray. INTRODUCTION Sea Ray Marine is recognized as one of the top premier boat manufacturers in the world over the last half...

Words: 2767 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Bibliography

...Memory Drugs http://web.ebscohost.com.proxy.devry.edu/ehost/detail?vid=11&hid=17&sid=d55b4c31-fd6e-4988-99bf-359d8e35f8f0%40sessionmgr13&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=a9h&AN=12371571 Hijman, R., Jolles, J., Verhoeven, W. M. A., van Ree, J. M., Elderson, A., & De Wied, D. (1992, January 01). Human psychopharmacology: Clinical & experimental. This source talks about experiments involving a new med named vasopressin. This is a series of five trials that were for aid of neuropsychological ability to see if it could improve brain function in those with memory loss and other issues from trauma. The result was that this med helped minimally for those suffering with more severe brain trauma. I found this to be helpful in my research because it shows that meds can only do so much and how much more we still have to learn to improve medication in the future for trauma patients. It helps me to understand that not all brain functions can be cured with medication yet and therefore when you’re dealing with injuries to the brain you have to be sensitive to the fact that some people may have permanent effects such as memory loss. This to me shows that memory drugs today are not quite where they need to be but that they are a helpful tool. Vergano, D. (2011, October 05). Scientists debate the benefits of memory drugs. USA Today, News, 08A. Retrieved from http://web.ebscohost.com.proxy.devry.edu/ehost/detail?vid=6&hid=17&sid=d55b4c31-fd6e-4988-99bf-35...

Words: 523 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Comparison of Some Os Booting

...execution all other processes can get the chance to execute , so we may say that booting is the first process because of which all other OS processes can execute. This experimental study gives an overview on the similarity and difference in Booting Process. As every operating system have to initially do the booting and as every OS providing different feature of each others, the paper is highlighting those micro and essential similarities and differences having by the operating systems during the Booting Process. Keywords: Booting, Cold booting, Worm booting, Linux Booting, Windows Booting, Mac Booting. In Worm Booting the computer get restart without shutdown the system, in which the system application and memory just get cleared and then reloading the operating system in primary memory. With the above two booting types we also have some other flavor in the computer booting like Sleep, Hibernate. Power - ON Load Instruction from ROM Detect OS from HDD 1. Introduction Find Attached H/W Booting Process is the first step gets happened in the computer system when you switch on the computer. In computing, booting is the initial set of operations that a computer system performs when electrical power to the CPU is switched on. The process begins when a computer is turned on for the first time or is...

Words: 2846 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Psy111

...PSY111- Foundations of Psychology for Health and Human Services Workbook- Assignment 2 Sonia Chiciak Student No.11534832 Word Counts (excl. citations) provided for each section. PSY111- Foundations of Psychology for Health and Human Services Exercise 1- Memory Question 1- Summary: (253 words) Grant, H. M., Lane, B.C., Clay, J., Ferrie, J., Groves, J.E., McDorman, T. A., Dark, V.J. (1998). Context-dependent memory for meaningful material: information for students. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 12, 617-623. This study tested whether the environmental context dependency effect is seen through test performances where matched and mismatched study and test noise conditions were used. Throughout the study, the researcher used the same text to test the difference context dependency has on short answer (recall) and multiple choices (recognition). Using previous research that has shown that characteristics of environment are encoded in the memory, and can be used to retrieve other information; the researchers changed whether or not there was general background noise in controlled study and test conditions and measured the results based on performance in the test. Overall, studying and testing in the same environment resulted in better performance than in mismatching studying environments. This study also found that, unlike in Smith (1986, as cited in Grant 1998), the context dependency effect for newly learned material is seen regardless of whether short answer or...

Words: 3291 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Matthew Lieberman Analysis

...When asked about pain, what first comes to mind? Memory of a broken bone, a stubbed toe, or a migraine? What about a heart break? Weirdly enough, most don’t consider emotional pain is real pain until it is it happening to themselves. Matthew Lieberman thinks otherwise, he believes emotional pain can be just as painful as physical pain and just as useful. Within the article Matthew Lieberman started with a personal example within his family which used emotional appeal, then continued with examples proving his point with experiments that showed the logic behind his science, and concluded by giving advice to the audience seeming to try to motivate them yet seemed to weaken his credibility. Matthew Lieberman is a fifteen-year veteran in the field...

Words: 1220 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Age Psychology a Level

...Age and EWT 1. Describe the aims, procedures, findings and conclusions of Poole and Lindsay’s (2001) study of the effects of age on EWT – science demonstration Aims- The aims of their experiment were to assess whether children were able to source monitor. Procedures- They used child participants aged 3-8 years of age. They were shown a science demonstration throughout the day; later that day their parents read them a story, which contained aspects of the science demonstration. The next day, the children were questioned about the science demonstration and then were further asked to think about where they got their information from (source monitoring). Findings- It was found that the younger children were unable to source monitor as they could not identify where they learnt the information whereas the older children could. Conclusion- Poole and Lindsay concluded that the younger children are poorer eye witnesses than the older children as they are unable where they learnt the information. This means that they aren’t able to distinguish between original eyewitness memory and post event information. 2. What does this suggest about age and EWT? This suggests that age does affect EWT. 3. Explain why the story told at home could have been an extraneous variable… Interview bias (how the parents read the story) could have influenced the accuracy of the child’s response. The parents could have unintentionally prejudiced the child by how they read the story; techniques...

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Research

...real-life context, especially when the boundaries between phenomenon and context are not clearly evident.(Robert K.Yin)” Historical background: Case study method emphasizes the study of a single individual. And it comes in the category of single-case research designs. Single-case designs have been used since scientific psychology began in the19th century. Psychophysical methods had their origin in the work of Gustav Fechner and were described in his 1860 book, Elemente der Psychophysik. Fechner,and countless other psychophysicists since, relied on data obtained through experiments with one or two individuals. Hermann Ebbinghaus is another major figure in the early history of psychology who used a single-case design. In fact, the single case that Ebbinghaus studied was himself. He was both the participant and the experimenter for the research he published in his monograph on memory in 1885. Over a period of many months he learned and then attempted to relearn hundreds of series of nonsense syllables. His data provided psychologists with the first systematic evidence of forgetting over time. Single-case studies appear regularly in psychology journals, dealing with issues ranging from cognitive therapy for Vietnam veterans (Kubany, 1997) to the study of brain processes in amnesic patients (Gabrieli, Fleischman, Keane, Reminger, & Morrell, 1995) and the treatment of motor and vocal tics associated with Tourette’s...

Words: 3558 - Pages: 15