Premium Essay

The Congruence Model

In:

Submitted By yayanora
Words 5206
Pages 21
THE CONGRUENCE MODEL

The Congruence Model
A Roadmap for Understanding
Organizational Performance
The critical first step in designing and leading successful large-scale change is to fully understand the dynamics and performance of the enterprise. It’s simply impossible to prescribe the appropriate remedy without first diagnosing the nature and intensity of an organization’s problems.
Yet, all too often, senior leaders– particularly those who have just recently assumed their positions or joined a new organization– react precipitously to a presenting set of symptoms.
They quickly spot apparent similarities between the new situations they face and problems they’ve solved in the past, and leap to the assumption that what worked before will work again.
The imperative to act is understandable but often misguided. Leaders would be well advised to heed the advice of Henry Schacht, who successfully led large-scale change as
CEO of both Cummins Engine and Lucent
Technologies: Stop, take a deep breath, give yourself some time, and “get the lay of the land” before leaping to assumptions about what should be changed, and how.
That’s easier said than done. Without a comprehensive roadmap – a model – for understanding the myriad performance issues at work in today’s complex enterprises, leaders are likely to propose changes that address symptoms, rather than causes. The real issues that underlie an organization’s performance can easily go undetected by managers who view each new, unique set of problems through the well-worn filter of their

past experiences and personal assumptions.
Consequently, the “mental model” any leader uses to analyze organizational problems will inevitably influence the design of a solution and, by extension, its ultimate success.
Although there are countless organizational models, our purpose here is to

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Congruence Model

...The Congruence Model by: Nadler & Tushmans Aligning the Drivers of High Performance [pic] Performance comprises four interlocking elements. © iStockphoto/dt03mbb Is your organization's performance as good as it could be? What could be changed to improve things and why would this help? Does the key lie in the work itself? Or with the people doing it? Should you reorganize the corporate structure? Or try to change the prevailing culture? And why does one organization seem to thrive on a certain corporate structure or type of work, while another struggles to make a profit? The answer lies in understanding the key causes or drivers of performance and the relationship between them. The Congruence Model, first developed by David A Nadler and M L Tushman in the early 1980s, provides a way of doing just this. It's a powerful tool for finding out what's going wrong with a team or organization, and for thinking about how you can fix it. Understanding the Tool The Congruence Model is based on the principle that an organization's performance is derived from four elements: tasks, people, structure, and culture. The higher the congruence, or compatibility, amongst these elements, the greater the performance. For example, if you have brilliant people working for you, but your organization's culture is not a good fit for the way they work, their brilliance will not shine through. Likewise, you can have the latest technology and superbly streamlined processes to support...

Words: 2616 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Congruence Model

...Trident University 1- Introduction In our third case study for the MBA Integrative Project; we the students are require to generate a report using the Nadler-Tushman Congruence Model to conduct an analysis of Whole Food Market’s inputs and how they align with the current company strategy, as well as its outputs. In this case study we will use the strategy we previously discussed in Module 1 and using the Porter’s three generic competitive strategies to analyzed organizational categories input to the strategy using the congruence model. The model should be able to help us determine how aligned the inputs are with the strategy. The model will give us three categories for inputs: the environment, resources and historical inputs and three categories for outputs: organizational level, group level and individual level to help us determine the congruence of the outputs. While conducting the Congruence Model we will use the inputs and outputs categories to determine the organizational level congruence of the Whole Food Markets; using all these various aspects the model will give us a good vision of the current organizational structure and performance of the company. Lastly we will analyzed all three level of organizational inputs and outputs and determine how each of these categories interact with each other to determine their similarity to was the Whole Foods Market business strategy. 2- Whole Foods Markets Inc. Strategy The Whole Foods market’s business strategy is based on...

Words: 2622 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Whole Foods Congruence Model

...Whole Foods Market Congruence Model 1.      Company Performance: Whoel Foods is a Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work for . In 2013 it was ranked: 71. It was best ranked: 5 in 2007 and Worst Ranked: 72 in 2000. Whole Foods Market has gradually decreased on this list since 2007 when in ranked 5th. 2.      Strategic context of the company: Competitive Grocery Store.  Whole Foods tries to raise the bar and innovate the grocery shopping experience.  It directly competes with Trader Joes .  Reputational to provide highest quality product.  It has created and publicly announced their high quality standards. 3.      Identify the strategic choices of the company and briefly explain.  Include your best assessment of how Porter and Miles and Snow would categorize the company’s strategy. Defender and Differentiation Defender: They are in the Defender because the stage has been set and Whole Foods Market is a household name.  They have created a whole new market and other companies are following suite.  Whole Foods needs to corner its market share that it has created. Differentiation: Defined as a Specialty Store compared to a Conventional Grocery Store, Whole Foods Market specializes on product that caters to specific needs such as allergies, vegan diets and non-hydrogenated products. 4.      The CEO and executives are as follows: Mark Ehrnstein Global V.P., Team Member Services A.C. Gallo President & Chief Operating Officer David Lannon Executive...

Words: 494 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Implementation of Nadler-Tushman Congruence Model to Assess an Organizations Output

...THE IMPLEMENTATION OF NADLER-TUSHMAN CONGRUENCE MODEL TO ASSESS AN ORGANIZATIONS OUTPUT CASE: OUTPUTS DIAGNOSIS, SLP: TIME WARP 3 TRIDENT UNIVERSITY INTERNATIONAL AVIE MARIE JOHNSTONE MBA INTEGRATIVE PROJECT BUS 599 MODULE 4 SESSION LONG PROJECT PROFESSOR JEFFREY ROALD SNIDER MAY 20, 2013 Abstract Continuing the work and analysis begun in the first three SLPs, we again project ourselves back in time to the year 2012. I am in responsible for decisions on product development and pricing for the next four years for our line of   tablets. I will show the score, financials and market data at the end of the four year period from my previous time discussions. Finally we can make a detailed discussion and   analysis of the data using   CVP analysis, and   will explain why I recommend specific pricing and research and development (R&D) costs for the next four year period. The Clipboard Tablet Company is...

Words: 1789 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Development of a Water Management Decision Model for Limpopo Province of South Africabased on Congruence Between Sector Challenge and Service Organization Capacity

...Journal of Contemporary Research Vol. 3 No. 5; May 2013 Development of a Water Management Decision Model for Limpopo Province of South AfricaBased on Congruence between Sector Challenge and Service Organization Capacity Khathutshelo A. Tshikolomoa Azwihangwisi E. Nesamvunia Sue Walkerb Aldo Stroebela Izak Groenewalda a Centre for Sustainable Agriculture University of the Free State Bloemfontein, 9300 South Africa. b Department of Soil Crop and Climate Sciences University of the Free State Bloemfontein, 9300 South Africa. Abstract The study highlightedchallenges affecting the water sector in Limpopo Province, identified water service organisations (WSOs), assessedthe degree of congruence between the challenges and capacities of WSOs, and finally proposeda water management decision model for the area. Water challenges were (a) scarce resource availability and inadequate storage, (b) some dam never filling up, (c) poor resource knowledge of water managers, (d) lack of stakeholder participation in resource decision making, and (e) poor allocations to rural communities. The main WSOs were Department of Water Affairs-DWA (congruence rating=2.00) and water service authorities (WSAs), namely: Mopani District Municipality-MDM (congruence rating=2.15), Vhembe District Municipality-VDM (2.15) and Polokwane Local Municipality-PLM (2.15). The degree of congruence was high (2.75) between challenges and strategies, moderate (2.45) between strategies and tasks and...

Words: 5517 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Value Centric Leaders

...The Real Value of Authentic Leaders: A Values-centric Model to understand Follower Behaviors Abstract Deriving from the literature on values, we propose a model which answers the call from scholars to examine the underlying processes through which authentic leadership impacts followers’ behavior and performance. We propose that by developing intrapersonal and interpersonal continuity in their followers’ values (value salience and person-supervisor value congruence respectively), authentic leaders could enhance followers’ task performance and organizational citizenship behavior, and reduce counterproductive work behavior. The model also contributes to research on values by examining the psychological and contextual factors, i.e. person-organization value congruence and self-concept clarity, which moderate the relationship between authentic leadership, value congruence and follower outcomes. Introduction Having witnessed several failures of corporate and economic machinery in the recent past, management scholars have been forced to look into the underlying reasons thereof from several different perspectives. As a fundamental shift in focus onto softer aspects of corporate leadership, leaders are being increasingly scrutinized for their leadership styles and moral values. Through this paper, we aim to contribute to a growing area of research in this domain by proposing a theoretical model to understand how leaders’ attitudes and values impact followers’ behavior and performance...

Words: 8787 - Pages: 36

Premium Essay

Part 3 Diagnosing the Change

...Part 3: Diagnosing the Change – Chrysler Group LLC & Ford Motor Company The congruence model first established in the eighties by David A Nadler and M L Tushman provides a means to an understanding of the sources of organizational performance and the relationship between the two. This model views organizations as components that are interconnected and interacting with goals of tight congruence. The Congruence Model consists of categories that are broken down into components. (Mercer, 2012) The first category of the Congruence Model is input. The components of the input category are environment, resources, and history. The environment consists of factors that are outside of the organization but can influence it. The analysis would want to see what demands or constraints the environment places on the organization. The history will provide the patterns of the past; behaviors, activities, and effectiveness. History can definitely have an effect on how the organization is functioning today. Things to analysis in the history include any major changes, phases of development, and the current impact of these historical factors. These components can consists of external and internal forces that drive the need for a change. (Mercer, 2012) The next category of the congruence model is strategy. There a two levels which are corporate strategy, which will include the legal aspect, and the business strategy. The business strategy will include decisions about how to use the resources of the...

Words: 1371 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Management

...annals.2011.01.015 BRAND EQUITY, BRAND LOYALTY AND CONSUMER SATISFACTION Janghyeon Nam Kyungnam University, South Korea Yuksel Ekinci Georgina Whyatt Oxford Brookes University, UK Abstract: This study aims to investigate the mediating effects of consumer satisfaction on the relationship between consumer-based brand equity and brand loyalty in the hotel and restaurant industry. Based on a sample of 378 customers and using structural equation modelling approach, the five dimensions of brand equity—physical quality, staff behaviour, ideal selfcongruence, brand identification and lifestyle-congruence—are found to have positive effects on consumer satisfaction. The findings of the study suggest that consumer satisfaction partially mediates the effects of staff behaviour, ideal self-congruence and brand identification on brand loyalty. The effects of physical quality and lifestyle-congruence on brand loyalty are fully mediated by consumer satisfaction. Keywords: brand equity, customer satisfaction, brand loyalty. Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. INTRODUCTION Consumer satisfaction is essential to long-term business success, and one of the most frequently researched topics in marketing (e.g., Jones & Suh, 2000; Pappu & Quester, 2006). Because consumer satisfaction has been regarded a fundamental determinant of long-term business success, much of the research on consumer satisfaction investigates its impact on consumers’ post consumption evaluations such as behavioural and...

Words: 9651 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

Output Diagnosis

...wholesale clubs (Sam’s); restaurants and fast food chains and natural food stores (Whole Foods, Wild Oats Generally the concentration of competitors has been fragmented by geography. However, through recent consolidations, the emergence of regional and national chains has started to prevail along with the decline of the independent/local shops. This consolidation activity has allowed many companies to spread their fixed costs over a wider range of output, thus creating more efficiency in operations. Often, it is cheaper for a company to acquire an incumbent due to the location of their stores and access to customers rather than to raise the capital for entirely new stores, which is how Whole Foods has been able to expand following their growth model strategy. Whole Foods acquisition growth plan has helped them to gain enough economies of scale to better compete with the Wal-marts and Sam’s Clubs. Threat of Substitutes Price of substitutes plays a role in determining a company’s profitability. Organic food is priced at a premium to conventional food reflecting the high labor costs in cultivating the product. The price premium may be one reason why organic food has not become mainstream. Another reason is that consumers either lack education about its benefits (or don’t care) so that the price premium does not appear to be justified. However, when comparing upscale organic and prepared foods to competitors such as restaurants, the benefit/cost ratio appears more justified. Market research...

Words: 1851 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Organizational Diagnostic Models

...The following paper looks to inform the reader of the six OD models widely used by organizations. Each of the six models is unique; bringing with them their own pros and cons. Along with the OD models, we will be covering three issues plaguing the Whole Foods Market today. 7s Model McKinsey 7s model is a model developed by McKinsey Consultants with help from Richard Pascale and Anthony G. Anthos in the 1980s. McKinsey 7s model follows the 7 key internal parts of: approach, structure, arrangements, shared values, style, workforce and skills to permit organizations to realize its goals. Approach is a plan established by a firm to bring an economical advantage alongside with success competitor within the market. Structure is the organizational chart of the firm legendary for being one in every of the foremost visible and simple to vary parts of the framework. Arrangements are legendary for being the main focus for how managers accomplish business; particularly throughout structure modification. Skills are the talents of the staff of the firm. Staff is the amount of staff at intervals a corporation required to hold out the mission. Style is the management and leadership of top-ranking managers. Shared values are the basis of each organization and also the core of McKinsey 7s model; the standards that guide employee’s behaviour. The model remains one of the foremost popular strategic designing tools. McKinsey 7s model focus on the soft S’s: style, staff, skills, and shared values...

Words: 2193 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Value Congruency

...September 2012 Value congruence in organizations: Literature review, theoretical perspectives, and future directions Yuanjie Bao Simon Dolan Shay S. Tzafrir ESADE Working Papers Series Available from ESADE Knowledge Web: www.esadeknowledge.com © ESADE Avda. Pedralbes, 60-62 E-08034 Barcelona Tel.: +34 93 280 61 62 ISSN 2014-8135 Depósito Legal: B-3449-2012 Value congruence in organizations: Literature review, theoretical perspectives, and future directions Yuanjie Bao* ESADE Business School, Future of Work Chair, Ramon Llull University Av. Torreblanca 59, 08172, Sant Cugat del Vallès, Barcelona, Spain yuanjie.bao@esade.edu Simon L. Dolan ESADE Business School, Future of Work Chair, Ramon Llull University Av. Torreblanca 59, 08172, Sant Cugat del Vallès, Barcelona, Spain simon.dolan@esade.edu Shay S. Tzafrir Department of Human Services, University of Haifa Mount Carmel, Haifa, 31905, Israel stzafrir@research.haifa.ac.il September 2012 Abstract Extant literature on value congruence is fragmented due to different methodological treatments and theoretical perspectives. Proposing a typology of the value congruence concept, this paper reviews several key themes in value congruence research including staffing, socialization, leadership, job attitudes, performance, among others. By reviewing related antecedents and outcomes, discussing underlying theoretical perspectives, and highlighting future directions, this paper integrates value congruence research into a comprehensive...

Words: 12319 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay

Diagnosing the Change

...Diagnosing the Change Natalie Howard DeVry University HRM/587 Jay Egger June 1, 2014 Diagnosing the Change This paper will discuss the use of a diagnostic model identifying the performance aspects of the two organizations that I chose. Chevron/Texaco and Coca-Cola are the two companies that I will be looking into to get an understanding of some critical cultural issues and to see what strategies were being used to correct the companies’ complaints about racial discrimination. Nadler Congruence Model I chose to use the Nadler congruence model to identify cultural problems within both organizations’ environment. Nadler uses a model that is based on the principle that an organization’s performance is derived from tasks, culture, structure, and people. It’s a systematic way to use the root elements to drive a force to an organization’s performance. In the case of Chevron/Texaco and Coca-Cola, we will be looking at managerial and the social aspects of both organizations (Nadler’s Congruence Model, 2013). It’s a useful model because it provides an effective checklist to those who are involved in creating change in the workplace. I consider it to be more of a problem-focused model to troubleshoot any problems that could cause an organization’s vision not to be achieved. Chevron/Texaco The problem identified with Chevron/Texaco is racial comments being made toward African Americans and complaints of being paid low wages and not being considered for promotions...

Words: 650 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Conguent

...Introduction A manager must manage organisational behaviour. That means that he or she must have the capacity to • understand the behavioural patterns of individuals, groups and organisations, • predict the behavioural responses that will most probably follow managerial actions, and • use this understanding and these predictions to achieve control. The models or implicit theories that managers develop from everyday life to achieve the above mentioned results, are often inadequate because it depends on personal experience that may be narrow or static, and they vary in quality, sophistication and validity Therefore, a roadmap or guide for analysis and action is necessary. Any model influences the kinds of data we collect and the kinds we ignore; models guide our approach to analysing and interpreting the data we have; models help us to choose our course of action. We aim to present a model here that is build on the premise that for an organisation to be effective it subparts must be consistently managed to approach a state of congruence. It is an open systems model. A system is a set of interrelated elements and an open system is one that relates to its environment. It takes inputs from its environment, transforms them and produces outputs. General characteristics of systems As systems organisations display the following characteristics. Internal interdependence: Changes in one component of the organisation have repercussions for...

Words: 1255 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Management

...| Assignment 1 | Essay | | By : Sanjula Hapuarachchi | 4/3/2015 | | Contents 1.0 Introduction 2 1.1 Purpose of the report 2 1.2 Personality 2 1.3 Methodology 2 2.0 Job Satisfaction 3 2.1 Definition and relationship to turnover 3 2.2 Locus of control 3 2.2.1 Definition 3 2.2.2 Internal LOC Vs External LOC 4 2.3 Two-Factor Theory 5 2.3.1 Definition 5 2.3.2 Motivators Vs Hygiene factors 5 2.3.3 Application of the theory 5 3.0 Organizational Commitment 6 3.1 Definition and relationship to turnover 6 3.2 Value Congruence 6 3.2.1 Definition 6 3.2.2 The effect of value congruence on the three types of organizational commitment 6 3.3 The Five Factor Model 7 3.3.1 Definition 7 3.3.2 The effect of the model on the three types of organizational commitment 8 4.0 Conclusion 9 5.0 Recommendations 10 6.0 References 11 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Purpose of the report The purpose of this essay is to provide recommendations for the human resource practitioners to increase employee job satisfaction and organizational commitment in the company by taking into account the personality of an employee and his/her influence on job satisfaction and organizational commitment. 1.2 Personality Personality is defined as the sum total of ways in which an individual reacts to and interacts with others (Robbins & Judge, 2012). In modern organizations, management has started to take employee’s personality in to consideration in order to...

Words: 2338 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Effective Leaders

...Design Determinants of Effective Leader Behavior^ RiCKYW. GRIFFIN University of Missouri—Columbia The theoretical and empirical research literature on task design and path-goal theory of leadership is reviewed. It is suggested that task design and individual variables interact to form a construct called individual-task congruence. A model is then developed which depicts leader behavior as a moderating variable between individuai-task congruence and satisfaction and performance. There is an increasing body of theoretical and empirical behavioral science literature dealing with the design of work in formal organizations. Much of this literature is concerned with the diagnosis and description of existing jobs and/or the implementation of task design change programs for the purpose of improving organizational effectiveness. The rationale seems to be that if the needs and capabilities of an individual are matched with the expectations and requirements of a task, higher 9/els of satisfaction, motivation, and productivity .vill result (6). Most published research on task design, however, has not taken other organizational variables into consideration. The general model for contemporary task design research has investigated the moderating effect of certain variables on the relationship between task design and outcome variables such as satisfaction, performance, and commitment (2, 7, 8, 19, 22, 25, 26, 28, 29, 33). A few empirical studies exist, which indicate that the manner in which employees...

Words: 5464 - Pages: 22