Free Essay

Trapped Orcas

In:

Submitted By lvv1234
Words 2147
Pages 9
For many years now SeaWorld has provided people with an opportunity to see many sea creatures and Killer Whales perform. These creatures have been trained over the years to perform various times throughout the day. Sea World, however, took these killer whales (orcas) away from their families and home. Throughout the years this has caused damage to the orcas causing rebellion and other forms of defiance. There have been many incidents following the rebellion of these orcas and yet nothing is done about the issue. Sea World should not keep killer whales against their will or keep them captive. Orcas are sea creatures, meaning they belong in the ocean. So why is it that they ended up in large fish tanks held against their will? SeaWorld claims to people that killer whales are better off under their care (Black Fish). Indicating that by taking the orcas from their families, it is rescuing them and giving them better help. Stating that they took them to show others how caring and talented they can be. The park implies that people will learn a lot about life in the sea. Many think that if they come to the park, they are doing a good deed and will be educated on life in the ocean. The employees working on the tours are also obligated to say all these lies to the guests about the park. For instance, a commonly asked question is why some whales have their fins bent, in other words, have a dorsal fin collapse. The park answers to guests that it is normal, but in reality that is not supposed to happen and is caused by the tanks (Black Fish). Orcas were not meant to live in big tanks they were meant to live in the ocean with other orcas. People being misinformed on what is really going on to the orcas is a huge problem that contributes support to the continuation of the park. The fact that trainers are often times also misinformed on many things that go on in the park makes you wonder what else they could be lying about. Trainers like anyone else want a job that they love and feel passion for. The trainers come to SeaWorld to learn more about the creatures and build a relationship with these mammals. Many times trainers get in the water with the killer whales not knowing the back story. Going into the job they are warned not to go into the tank alone with certain killer whales (Black Fish). They then wonder what it is that everyone is so scared about. They are just as misinformed as other guests. Sometimes they have to find out through others, but tend to stay because they have grown an attachment to them. The trainers often grow such an attachment to these whales that after finding out how they are feeling they still decide to stay. They think that no one else is going to care for and understand them the way they do. They don’t know that some of the whales in the park had been captured when they were very young. The killer whales at the SeaWorld theme parks have been captured when they were young and taken from their families (Black Fish). These orcas were too innocent and young in age to be taken from their families. They took these baby orcas and put them in large tanks for others to come and see for entertainment. Tilikum is a popular killer whale that had been taken at a young age. He reacted as any child being taken away from their family would. In the film Black Fish we see that the family of killer whales are watching people take away their baby while it is crying (Black Fish). Tilikum has been in SeaWorld for a long time now and his anger has grown. These creatures have feelings just like anyone else and over time this anger begins to build up. These orcas also become depressed, as in Black Fish we see a child being taken away from its mother (Black Fish). As all these emotions begin to pile up the orcas begin to rebel against their trainers. It’s like a switch turn is turned on and they begin to go against the ones that truly care about them. There is no telling when these orcas can suddenly turn against the trainer and begin to attack. Having these mammals in captivity has led to several attacks in the park. Some of the best trainers have lost their lives while working with the orcas. Sometimes the orcas know during a performance that the trainer is running out of food and become angered by it. If the orcas see that they are beginning to get less fish and ice, that is when they can tell that food is running out (Black Fish). This is when they begin to feel angry and begin to rebel against the trainers. Back in 2010, a case in Florida, where a trainer had been killed, was all over the news. This trainer was said to be one of the best trainers out there to train these killer whales (Boniface 1). Then there was another trainer alone in the tank with a killer whale. The killer whale had the trainer’s foot in his mouth and wouldn’t let go as he brought him down underwater (Black Fish). Luckily, this trainer was able to survive and quickly escape from the whale. This comes to show that no one is safe working with these orcas. Even the best trainers have no idea what these animals are capable of doing. They are not able to read minds, even if they do think they have a strong relationship with these creatures. There is just no way of knowing what can happen in a performance with these huge creatures. They are not meant to be performing, let alone performing various times throughout the day. Given that orcas become depressed and angry stuck in these tanks, it is reasonable to infer that attacking the trainers, is their way of indicating that they are fed up. Orcas are not meant to live this type of life; they are to be set free in the ocean with their families. This is their way of communicating with humans that they hate the lifestyle they are living. They are sick and tired of being trapped where there is nowhere to go but in circles. Realizing this, the park seems to do nothing about it but letting it go on. Sea World tends to not do much about the attacks, as they continue on with various performances. This is indicating that they do not care about the trainers or the orcas. Orcas are doing everything in their power to be set free but no one seems to listen to them. They have hurt many people as a statement as what they are capable of doing. Instead of acknowledging what the orcas are doing is wrong they simply brush it off as an accident. SeaWorld trainers do not deserve to get hurt from the mistakes the park is guilty of by allowing to keep these dangerous creatures around. SeaWorld has never really confronted the attacks. They don’t want people to look down on the park or their creatures. They want people to think that what they are doing is amazing and that they care so much about these creatures. However, they know what is really going on but refuse to admit it. They want people to believe, just like their show, that the attack was in fact an accident. Instead of owning up to the truth, they lie and back up the accident story. For instance, there was an attack reported in Florida where Dawn Brancheau had been attacked and killed by Tilikum in the park (Boniface 1). This had everyone talking about the killer whale and horrific scene at SeaWorld. Dawn Brancheau was one of the best trainers at SeaWorld, so it was a big surprise to hear that she was killed. When the park was asked what had happened, they said that Tilikum’s teeth had gotten caught to Dawn’s ponytail (Boniface 1). To then find out that this was not Tilikum’s first attack. He has reportedly attacked three other people (Boniface 1). SeaWorld had kept the fact that there had been previous problems with Tilikum a secret from many people. Many were surprised to find out that Sea World had kept this a secret from many. It stunned many to find out this information about Tilikum and that they still put many trainers in the tank with him. Knowing what they know, SeaWorld still had the audacity to put trainers in danger by putting them to work with Tilikum. So why keep these killer whales captive? It is pretty obvious why SeaWorld hides these little secrets; for the money of course. Sea World is going to keep going through with this business as long as they have money coming in. They clearly do not care about how these killer whales are feeling after so many years of performing. They see all the damage they have caused too many trainers and yet they hire more trainers to put in the tank. They know it is dangerous to keep Tilikum but they don’t want to lose money, so they keep him. It is reasonable to infer that the reason why they haven’t released the orcas is because they are making money. Although they might think they are keeping the trainers safe by not allowing them to swim with Tilikum, they still let him out during the performance. Keeping Tilikum captured and letting him out for a bit in the performance isn’t helping anyone. They might as well release him into the ocean where killer whales belong. It’s wrong to keep these creatures captive for as long as they have for their own benefit. The park is trying to make it seem as if they are caring for the mammals when they really aren’t. If they really cared for these creatures they would have set them free. They would not have waited until the third attack to separate them from the trainers. The SeaWorld Park has been cited for many safety violations that have been ignored (OSHA 1). This illustrates that the park cares more about the money than the safety of their workers. Since all of the attacks, Sea World has come back with more false advertisements to attract more people to come to the park. From this research I hope that more people will become aware of this subject. Maybe then people will stop taking their kids to SeaWorld creating less business for them. I know that after my family found out about the various attacks and hidden secrets, they no longer wanted to go back to the theme park. This just comes to show what a difference getting informed can make in everyone’s lives. The more people are aware of the problem going on in Sea World the more customers they lose resulting in no other choice but to close down all SeaWorld Parks. This will force them to return all Killer Whales along with all other sea creatures back to their natural habitat. Sea World should not keep killer whales against their will or captive. Keeping them captive all these years has caused so much damage to not only them, but their employees as well. Trainers have died and yet they continue on with the business as if nothing happened. Instead they hide attacks and misinform people in order to receive business. They would much rather keep the orcas trapped knowing they are fed up with it than release them and actually help them in preventing more deaths. To keep them captured in the tanks is a cruel and unusual punishment. The creatures deserve to be in the ocean with lots of room surrounded with other orcas.

Works Cited/Consulted
1. Boniface, Susie. "Psycho Killer of SeaWorld: Humans Messed with His Mind and Tilikum the Orca Took Savage and Bloody Revenge. What Next for This Giant of the Deep? [Eire Region]." The People, (2013): 30.
2. Kryukova, N., E. Kruchenkova, and D. Ivanov. "Killer Whales ( Orcinus Orca) Hunting For Walruses ( Odobenus Rosmarus Divergens) Near Retkyn Spit, Chukotka." Biology Bulletin 39.9 (2012): 768-778. Academic Search Premier. Web. 3 Nov. 2014.
3. "2010 - 08/23/2010 - US Labor Department's OSHA Cites SeaWorld of Florida following Animal Trainer's Death." 2010 - 08/23/2010 - US Labor Department's OSHA Cites SeaWorld of Florida following Animal Trainer's Death. N.p., n.d. Web. 03 Nov. 2014. .
4. SeaWorld Theme Parks in Orlando, San Antonio and San Diego." SeaWorld Theme Parks in Orlando, San Antonio and San Diego. N.p., n.d. Web. 02 Nov. 2014. .
5. Blackfish. Dir. Gabriela Cowperthwaite. Perf. Tilikum, Dave Duffus, Samantha Berg. Sundance, 2013. Film.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Conversations in the Community

...When I was a child I eagerly watched my parents in the kitchen, fascinated by the way they would make something delicious out of what seemed like nothing at all. This frequent observation sparked something in me and from that moment forward, I knew I was born to cook. In speaking to local restaurant owners about their businesses, my initial awkwardness and apprehension towards approaching unfamiliar people faded away. I found that conversation came easily when discussing ones passions. I first met with Cindy, who owns Paddy Cakes and Candy. She has owned and operated the shop for several years, and has been expanding it slowly. What started out as a simple candy store has now grown to be so much more. There isn’t a need for specialized equipment in her shop, as she has all her tempered chocolate products premade, but they make all the items that require melting chocolate in the store. Cindy assured me that while no culinary or business management degree is necessary, it would certainly be helpful. Despite seeming content in the busy atmosphere of her store, Cindy confided in me that this was nothing more than a convenient opportunity. She had lost her previous business to bankruptcy after 9/11, and this store just “fell in her lap.” Although she loves what she does, she’s bored and has put the store up for sale in order to pursue another business venture – Cindy would love nothing more than to open her own craft store. Shane, owner of The Pizza Man, had little to offer...

Words: 849 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Blackfish Film Analysis

...We all have the option to leave, to get away and travel to anywhere in this world. We are not confined to one specific area, trapped without an escape. For some odd reason, some people believe the kidnapping of natures creation, wild killer whales living its own life, is acceptable to make a profit. About forty-two years ago, the capture of young whales was a hit job. One diver, who jumped on the opportunity of a lifetime, tells his story in the documentary Blackfish. This diver, John Crowe, explains how this job brought excitement at first sight. Then, as he captures his first whale, he realizes that he had just taken a baby from its mother. He continues his work while the baby is crying out to its mother for help, and John begins to cry...

Words: 313 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Free Orcas

...Free Orcas How much do you really know about whales in captivity? Do you think the whales at sea world enjoy being there? Imagine you're walking down the street with your family when out of nowhere you're trapped in a net and being taken away from them. This happens to young whales almost everyday and is very unnecessary. Orcas should not be kept in captivity because it causes premature death, anxiety, and violent behavior. Many people would consider these results to be animal abuse. It has been confirmed that whales in captivity have higher mortality rates than those in the wild and these rates have only worsened over the years. According to the report “Killer Controversy: Why Orcas Should No Longer Be Kept in Captivity,” "Captive female orcas give birth too young and too often, leading to both high adult and high infant mortality." Also, the chronic stress of being confined weakens their immune system which leads to infection. This is the most common cause of death for captive orcas. The average life expectancy of a wild orca is 30-50 years. Orcas who have died at Sea World have an average age of death of 13 years old. The shocking fact is that over 161 whales have died in captivity, and it can easily be prevented by leaving them in the wild where they belong. Another outcome of the confinement is anxiety. Orcas who are not compatible with one another are placed in relatively small tanks which results in anxiety and tension. This tension often leads to brutal fights...

Words: 766 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Orcas In Captivity

...SeaWorld has animals, whales and dolphins, that would be better off in the wild than trapped in tanks and forced to perform. The safety of both the humans and the animals would be better if separated. SeaWorld shouldn’t be able to have whales and dolphins in their parks because it hurts the life expectancy of the animals, the peoples safety is in danger, and the health of the animal can be affected greatly. The life expectancy of orcas in captivity is nowhere near the wild life expectancy. The life expectancy for an orca is very low compared to in the wild (wild male, about 30; female, about 50). The orcas are losing their lifetime in captivity as for orcas in the wild are trying to live life to the fullest. Out of 160 whales that died in captivity,...

Words: 1177 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Free Tilly

...world's view of whales. He has killed three people. Tilikum is a male Orca, more commonly referred to as a killer whale, with a complex background. In 1983 Tilikum was violently captured in Iceland and then illegally sold to 'Sealand of the Pacific' aquarium in Canada. He was two years old when this happened, ripped away from his family and cruelly sent to foreign waters. In the wild, Tilikum was used to swimming over 100 miles every day; in 'Sealand of the Pacific' Tilikum was used to floating in a concrete prison only ten feet longer than his body. When Tilikum was not confined in these small spaces, he was taken into a pool where he would perform tricks for audiences in order for him to receive food. The food was frozen fish which deprived the Orca of his necessary nutrients and food was withheld from Tilikum if he did not respond to the trainers' instructions. Tilikum was a highly intelligent whale and due to this he seems to have noticed his mistreatment. Tilikum began to become restless, frustrated with being trapped in a concrete box and performing tricks for slivers of food. The trainers registered Tilikum's agitation but they did not see it as being significant. It was too late when Sealand of the Pacific finally realised that Tilikum's emotions were important. In February of 1991 a part-time trainer at Sealand fell into the pool whilst Tilikum was performing with two female Orcas. Tilikum, along with the other whales, began to drag Keltie Byrne under the...

Words: 1305 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Aquatic Parks

...around pressing their faces against the glass to get a closer look at the large, black and white  creature swimming in the tank with fatigued parents trailing behind them. The orca appears to be  intrigued by the child and the visitors by constantly bumping against the thick layer of glass,  however in reality, the orca is pleading for escape. With not much space to live in thrive in, orcas  and other massive mammals spend their whole lives swimming around small enclosed pools.  Behind those glass tanks are beautiful, living animals who do not deserve to be trapped in  compact pools. Guests and children are just far too blind to notice it. While marine parks are  entertaining for families and visitors, they should be shut down and banned because of the  negative mental and physical impact occurring on the animals being held captive.  Whale and dolphin capturing for captivity have been around for a long time and it needs  to be put to an end. From 1964 to 1989, a total of 138 orcas were captured for entertainment in  aquatic parks. In 1972, 1,133 dolphins were picked out of the United States’ ocean to be held  captive (Zimmermann). As of August 2015, there are 59 orcas being held in captivity in 14  marine parks in 8 different countries ("The Fate of Captive Orcas”).  People do not realize these  mammals have been horribly treated since the early 1960s until now. Orcas and dolphins have  been kidnapped from their families and friends so people could keep them in enclosed pools for  He 2  entertainment...

Words: 1646 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Animal Cruelty In The Film 'Blackfish'

...The Trainer or the Trained Going to parks such as SeaWorld and the zoo are typical childhood things, until adulthood when that cute lion turns into a man-eating beast that has been taken out of its’ natural habitat and placed behind bars. Seeing these animals trapped and put on display for a profit ruins the fun and raises question as to who is responsible for thinking that animal cruelty for profit was a good idea. Gabriela Cowperthwaite exposes the corporate company of SeaWorld in her documentary Blackfish for their negligence to animal captivity and allowing the attacks of innocent people to continue to happen. Along with the theme of animal cruelty, Jurassic World also portrays the company as reckless in pursuit of money and greed. Both...

Words: 1551 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Steven Spielberg's Jaws

...This resulted in Brody finally convincing Vaughn to hire Quint. Later, Quint, Brody, and Hooper set out on Quint's boat, the Orca, to hunt the shark. The shark appears behind the boat and it drags the barrel underwater and disappears. At night, the great white returns, ramming the boat's hull and killing the power. The men work through the night, repairing the engine. In the morning, Brody attempts to call the Coast Guard, but Quint smashes the radio. Then, the shark drags the boat backwards, swamping the deck and flooding the engine compartment before breaking the cleats off. He tries to suffocate the shark by taking it to shallower but the overtaxed engine fails. With the Orca slowly sinking, Hooper puts on scuba gear and enters the water in a shark-proof cage, intending to lethally inject the shark with strychnine using a hypodermic spear. The shark demolishes the cage before Hooper can inject it, but he manages to escape. The shark then attacks the boat directly, killing Quint. Trapped on the sinking vessel, Brody stuffs a scuba tank into the shark's mouth, and, climbing the mast, shoots the tank with Quint's rifle, destroying...

Words: 408 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Facts About Dolphin Research Paper

...10 True Facts That Prove Dolphins Are Evil Don't letter "Flipper" fool you. These high-pitched, bottle-nosed fiends are the scourge of the seas. ---- They're Part of a Killing Family Killer whales are really dolphins. It's true. They're not actually whales, they just look like them. Orcas and bottlenose dolphins are cousins, of a sort. ---- They Work as Spies More than one government has used dolphins to spy on other countries, Russia even sold combat-trained dolphins to Iran. That's real. http://www.realclear.com/defense/2014/03/26/russians_seize_military_dolphins_6328.html ---- They Engage in Sexual Assault It sounds awful, but it's rather well-known that dolphins frequently engage in sexual activities with each other, even with unwilling partners, and will even move suggestively against other animals...including humans. ---...

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Melanie's Whales Watching Case Study

...Melanie’s Whale Watching > Orcas > Transient and Resident Orcas are classified into two categories: resident and transient. The Resident Orcas frequent coastal waterways of British Columbia and Washington, living off a fish-based diet, which is primarily made up of Chinook salmon. These whales are a matriarchal multi-family group and are more vocal in comparison their Transient counterparts. The Transient Whales, on the other hand, live in small groups, consisting of a single matriline (matriarchal family). Their home range is vaster than the Residents, ranging throughout the Eastern North Pacific, with infrequent visits to inland waters. They are much quieter than their Resident counterparts, allowing them to sneak up on their preys which...

Words: 1520 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Is Animal Captivity Wrong

...” (“Welcome Progress on captive wildlife” 1). When I was a little girl, I loved to see animals doing tricks. After doing some research, now I know some shows are wrong. Animal captivity is wrong because it’s dangerous for people and for the animals, and it’s not natural. Animals such as orcas should never be in captivity. Having animals in captivity can be dangerous for people. “There is no established record of orcas killing human being in the wild… In captivity, however, it’s a different story. Since the 1970’s killer whales in captivity have attacked 24 people around the world, and some of these encounters have been fatal… so why do they attack people in captivity when they don’t in the wild? The answer seems to be captivity-related stress.” (Should We Be Keeping” 1, 2). When animals in captivity get stressed,...

Words: 751 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Comparison of Jaws and Free Willy 2: the Adventure Home

...The Comparison of JAWS And Free Willy 2: The Adventure Home Some films often have themes and messages in them that are only relevant to the time the film was made. One such example is the movie Jaws, which depicts a shark as the main antagonist. For its time the movie was incredibly successful playing upon the fears people had of sharks while swimming. However with awareness of the planet increasing and people understanding that sharks are endangered species which humans are invading their habitat in the first place, movies like Jaws are less acceptable. This is the reason why most rip off movies of Jaws are these terrible B grade movies. The only way a movie like this could exist in this current time is by having a really far out plot like a mutated or genetically modified shark terrorizing everyone. The focus of this essay will compare Jaws (1975) to Free Willy 2 (1995). The focus is on the treatment of animals and how they are represented in these two films. As well as this other events such as what happened between these two periods will be looked at to understand not only how both films are different but why they are different. Jaws was originally made in 1975 by director Steven Spielberg. Spielberg is a good example of a director who has perfect timing to releasing a film at a time when the public wants it. Due to the films success and the nature of Spielberg means that Jaws is an expression of the society’s conscious and articulates the current fears and trends...

Words: 1823 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Persuasive Essay Against Zoos

...where animals are removed from their natural habitat, placed into cages, and used as entertainment as a source of income. Although many people would argue that zoos do a good job at protecting animals, zoos should be banned around the world because animals are mistreated, zoos are not an effective way to help endangered species, and zoos are not a good source of education about wildlife. The first reason zoos should be banned is because animals are mistreated. In the Salon article “Are Zoo Animals Happy? There’s a simple empathy test we can apply”, Marc Bekof and Jessica Pierce tell the story of an orca whale named Tilly who was captured when she was only a few years old and was sold and traded to several different places until she finally ended up at Sea World. They state, “By weaving together ethological details about the abuses and cognitive, emotional, and social lives of orcas in the wild with a catalog of the abuses and deprivations experienced by Tilly, the film leaves the reviewer in no doubt that Sea World is a living hell for these sensitive and intelligent creatures, who go crazy and must be pumped up with psychoactive drugs like Valium to control their behavior.” Even though there are laws that regulate how animals must be treated in zoos, many animals become depressed due to the horrific living conditions. In the article “Zoo Animals and Their Discontents” in the New York Times Magazine by Alex Halberstadt, Virga, an animal cognitions researcher, explains his observations...

Words: 1300 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Animal Captivity Research Paper

...them out of their pods. Next, studies have shown that life in captivity can alter or even reverse an animal’s natural tendencies. For example, “they spend only 10 to 20% of their time at the surface [in the wild] tanks only allow a few strokes in any direction before coming to a wall. Because tanks are shallow, the natural tendencies of whales and dolphins are reversed- they spend more than Norman 2 50% of their time at the surface.” This shows that life in a small, shallow tank forces the animals to make accommodations to its instincts based on the zoo/parks budget for a tank. Lastly, captivity causes animals to develop a huge range of medical problems. Just like in humans, “unnatural situations can cause skin problems”. Orcas, better known as killer whales, can also develop “dorsal fin collapse, as without the support of the water, gravity pulls” the fins down into a curled position. (“Marine Animals in Captivity” ) For someone who thinks that dorsal fin collapse happens in wild, they wouldn’t be wrong, however that occurrence of this is much higher in tanks. Only 1% of all whales in the wild de velop it while all males and most females develop it in captivity. The facts add up, marine animals are not suited, for captivity. Captivity has the same effect on their heads just like confinement in a prison would. The only difference here is that the animals did nothing wrong. Along with marine parks, zoos also trap animals and say “it’s educational,” or “we are...

Words: 935 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Water Pollution

...Zox by Susan Photos he s from t Excerpt With de ion GNuLiINE Broadcast DiscussPBS FRO T Welcome to POISONED WATERS This discussion guide and DVD are drawn from the PBS FRONTLINE investigative report, POISONED WATERS with Hedrick Smith as correspondent. In that program, we showed the kinds of pollution now contaminating America’s waterways, political obstacles blocking restoration of great estuaries like Chesapeake Bay and Puget Sound, and some local strategies that have scored successes. We have designed this kit to stimulate public discussion of effective techniques and crucial issues of educational reform. It is intended for teachers, parents, principals, administrators and anyone interested in improving public schools. Photo by: Susan Zox How To Use This Guide This guide can be used either with a DVD of the two-hour documentary, POISONED WATERS, or with the special DVD clip reel of program excerpts. The guide is broken into several sections. On pages 1 and 22, you’ll find a description of the main elements of the program. Pages 2-21 set out ten topics for discussion, selected to highlight important issues in protecting our waters. For example, stormwater runoff, agricultural pollution, new chemical contaminants, how grass-roots action can force a Superfund cleanup or control development. Each topic is covered by a two-page write-up and suggested questions. A matching video segment illustrates the issue. Select a topic and read the summary. Watch the matching segment on...

Words: 8725 - Pages: 35