Premium Essay

Trouillot: The Power Of History

Submitted By
Words 1229
Pages 5
I. The Power of History:
If we look at the United States history archives, it would be deeply written that the so founder of North America became known as Christopher Columbus. How Columbus set foot in soon the be named “The New World.” He became cherish by many and hated by others. As Trouillot claims, a professor of Anthropology and social sciences at the University of Chicago, history is a form of power and mostly a story of those who won. In this instance, Columbus expansion became a story of bravery that brought forward a New World that will eventually bring freedom and a pursuit of happiness. This story illustrates a main point in Trouillot main thinking, to what happened to what is said to have happened is not usually cleared. To expand …show more content…
For this reason, the U.S and Mexican War is the perfect example of contrasting history facts told by those who won. Moreover, the United States began their expansion into the Mexican land in order to cultivate additional acres of land in order to supply the demand for sugar. While bringing slaves were legal in the that time period, Mexico was mostly more concentrated on their independence against Spain. Settlers later claimed, that the Mexican Government after becoming independence began to summit rules of their religion, and rules that they should follow under the dictatorship of the Mexican president. The Mexican government eventually law an anti- slavery settlement that will outraged settlers. On the other hand, Mexico history describes the war as being an essential battle in order to domain their land from further settlers. The government in 1830 prohibited further American immigration into Mexican territory. They began forcing settlers to convert into Catholicism and sign an oath of allegiance to Mexico in order to them stay on their land. The Mexican government became economically unstable after their independence making them extremely vulnerable against other countries. Their poor government structure became the tipping point that proved once more the significance of the Manifest Destiny and the idea that God given them the right and destiny to expand their freedom westward. In consequence Mexico lost half of its land, and their population suffer substantially. The war added one million acres into the U.S while costing them million of dollars and thousands of lives in the process (Olson). Even though, it became an unpopular battle in both countries, it became a grounding point on pro and anti slavery that will push the United States into a Civil

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Critical Response

...860987602 ETST 001: Intro to Race July 7, 2012 Critical Response 1 The Conquest Of A True Identity The ‘survival of the fittest’ was a theory coined by the English naturalist Charles Darwin in which only the fittest organisms will prevail. This phrase has unfortunately been connected to his name with the negative view that it sparked the racial hierarchy that esteems one race over the other. However, Darwin meant for this theory to apply to animals; the predator-prey relationship, and not to human-beings. His cousin, Francis Galton was responsible for tying the theory to the social construction of humans. This helped spark the concepts of colonialism, slavery, and enlightenment in Europe and America which ultimately was the conquest of many people’s identities most especially to the colonized and oppressed who were deemed inferior to the White man. Hegel’s dialectic states that freedom was a condition achieved first by the ownership of oneself (Lowe, 200) During the age of US imperialism, African Americans were held under slavery precisely under this notion that the Whites were more “fit” than non-Whites. Because of this, African Americans were driven to lose their identity not just of being the inferior race but they were dehumanized as well. Black female slaves were not viewed as “mothers” by slave-owners but merely as “breeders” like animals. (Davis, 7) The slave system also discouraged male supremacy in Black men. Because of this, Blacks did not have a chain of command...

Words: 865 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Abina and the Important Men

...Abina and the Important Men Abina and the Important Men: a Graphical History was written by Trevor R. Getz and Liz Clarke. The story of Abina Mansah is somewhat an inspiring graphical history based on an 1876 court transcript. Abina, a woman of West Africa, was wrongfully enslaved and as a consequence, she took her former master, Quamina Eddoo, to court. The overall setting took place on the Gold Coast during the 19th century. The main scenes take place in the court room, which is filled with many “important men.” The men included a British judge, two Euro African attorneys, countrymen, and an entire jury of wealthy, high class local town leaders. This book is broken down into several parts; the graphical history, transcript, historical context, reading guide, and classroom version. All of these parts combined help to reconstruct and create a better interpretation of the story of Abina Mansah. The Gold Coast at this time was under English rule as the British began to abolish slavery. Abina was born into one of the protectorates, Asante, and enslaved in her youth. She was formerly the wife of Yaw Awoah and sold to her former master, Quamina Eddoo, to begin working in his sister Eccoah’s household. While staying at Eddoo’s plantation, Abina was told she had to marry, against her will, Tando. Tando was a man of Eddoo and because Abina didn’t want to marry him, she was told if she didn’t she would be flogged. “They say that in Cape Coast all are free.”(Chapter 1 page 7) Knowing...

Words: 1497 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

How Did African Americans Influence The Haitian Revolution

...Scholars of the Haitian Revolution have also considered the role that African ideas may have played in the Haitian Revolution. In ““I Am The Subject of the King of Congo”: African Political Ideology and the Haitian Revolution”, John Thornton contends for the role of Congolese political history and thinking in influencing the Haitian Revolution. At the time of the Haitian revolution the majority slaves in Haiti were of Congolese origin or descent. Thornton contends against earlier interpretations which interpreted the slaves’ African political heritage as encouraging a support for absolute monarchy and slavery. He analyzes the political practices of Congolese Kingship and the dynamics of the civil wars which had taken place in the 18th century,...

Words: 1196 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Trouillot's The Presence In The Past

...Our present day lives, both on an individual and societal level, are so heavily influenced by the past, that at times it seems as if the past, is in fact the present. The association and consequence of the two are considered by Trouillot in The Presence in the Past. He reminds us that time is not chronological as we’ve come to represent it and that the past is not fixed or separate from the present, instead, he contends that practices of the past more specifically those of slavery, coexist with the principles of the present day. Initially he argues that historical representation, most notably formulized images and text, should be scrutinized as the production and consumption of such works may not only misrepresent the experience, but it...

Words: 304 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Call for Further Research: Afro-Chinese Marriages in 20th Century Cuba

...A Call for Further Research: Afro-Chinese Marriages in 20th Century Cuba Katie Wang UCLA Professor Wright-Dixon I. Introduction Coalitions through marriage is a long understood concept. Kingdom alliances through marriages are ones that first come to mind. Often fictional portrayals of real pressures for pressures to gain resources or military alliance for a capital or imperial need involve young princes and princesses who are forced to marry. However, in a nonfictional example for this paper, Chinese indentured laborers or former indentured laborers and African slaves or former slaves married in 19th century Cuba both romantically and strategically. I argue that there needs to be further research around Afro-Chinese marriages in Cuba and a recentering on women. I had originally planned to center this paper around African slave women who married Chinese men in Cuba in the 19th century but was not able to because of the lack of literature available. However, I aim to focus on a reading against the grain for indications of women’s agency and voice in this set of literature. My personal stakes in this topic are two-fold. First, my mother’s side of my family lived in Cuba for a few decades from the late 1920s to 1960 as a part of an entrepreneurial endeavor and as refuge from persecution from the Communist Party of China. Because of my personal tie to Chinese in Cuba, I seek to uncover untold stories and hidden transcripts. Second, this paper is a part of a larger project...

Words: 3789 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

The American Occupation of Haiti: Identifying Coin Objective to Protect American Interests from 1915 to 1934

...Abstract The purpose of this paper is to focus on the objectives of the American involvement in the occupation of the Caribbean nation of Haiti. Highlighted are the pretenses under which America began their involvement and the subsequent results of the invasion. The economic, political and social effects that the US had on the Haitian community had it’s successes in areas such as the rebuilind of the infrastructure, but were significantly countered with blatant violations in human rights laws and corruption within the government. These areas of failure reject the fundamental basis of what a successful counterinsurgency entails. Although there is much evidence of successes and failures in Haiti, to conclude, a realist argument will be presented in order to provide some answers as to why decisions were made to occupy Haiti under a COIN objective, but withdraw without meeting those objectives. Keywords: cacos, violence, attitudes, counterinsurgency “For our forebears, for our country, Oh God of the valiant! Take our rights and our life under your infinite protection, Oh God of the valiant! For our forebears, for our country.” –Haitian National Anthem Haiti, which is officially the Republic of Haiti, is a Caribbean country. It occupies the western, smaller portion of the island of Hispaniola, in the Greater Antillean archipelago, which it shares with the Dominican Republic. The country's capital is Port-au-Prince. Haitian Creole and French are the...

Words: 3984 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

The Haitian Revolution

...Trouillot’s An Unthinkable History, presents the argument that Haitian revolution becomes a non-event in all aspects of history because it was never perceived as ‘thinkable’ event, therefore, dismissing the movement at its origin. The Haitian Revolution as a non-event was further cemented by the Western ontological framework that prevented even conceiving a rebellion led by black slaves, but also by the explicit dismissal of the Haitian Revolution by the academia itself. Thus, the ‘cancellation’ of the Haitian revolution only creates further implications for the study of social movements. The Haitian Revolution is a monumental anti-slavery, social movement led by both free and enslaved blacks, that successfully challenged and overcame the...

Words: 1333 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Study Guide

...LAST 170 Midterm Exam:   Wednesday, October 22 and Friday, October 24, 2014.   Wednesday and Friday during usual class time   •Students with last names beginning with A-K will take the test in 100 Gregory Hall   •Students with last names beginning with L-Z will take the test in 1LIB 66 •Please bring a #2 pencil.   Friday: students will go to their scheduled discussion sections and take the second part of the exam.   Format: 3 mini-essay answer; 40-60 multiple-choice questions; 5-10 fill-in-the-blank questions; and 5-10 two-sentence answers.   Short-essay answer: concisely answer the following questions. Be prepared to answer all of them. ACTUAL QUESTIONS FOR THE EXAM 1) Consider what you learned in lecture and from the readings by Rohter, Guimarães, Goldstein, Vaughan, and Stout. Discuss how people are racialized in Brazil and Cuba. Be sure to cover the following issues:   a. What historical conditions explain the high level of inequality in these countries? Why are socio-economic conditions connected to race? (10 pts) b. Provide one concrete example from the readings that shows how constructions of race in Brazil and Cuba are similar, and one concrete example from the readings to show how they are different (10 pts) c. Discuss why identities are mediated and how media is used as part of the process of racialization (10 pts). Use one example provided in class to explain your argument (10 pts). 2) Considering the movie “Even the Rain”  and from...

Words: 1467 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Significance of the Haitian Revolution for the Practice of Contemporary Theory.

...The significance of the Haitian Revolution for the practice of contemporary theory. 1. Introduction Philosopher Peter Hallward claims, “If the French Revolution stands as the great political event of modern times the Haitian Revolution must figure at the most decisive sequence of that event” (Hallward, 2004:2). From a historical perspective, it is important that one recognises the significance of this event. The Haitian Revolution was a struggle for self-determination against colonial imperialism and slavery but it was also so much more than that as it was a struggle for the liberation of the African mind too. The Haitian Revolution influenced thinkers such as Peter Hallward and Alain Badiou, C.L.R. James as well as pan-Africanist thinkers such as Marcus Garvey and later Franz Fanon himself. In this paper I will analyse the Haitian Revolution not in a historical context per se but rather by examining its significance on the practice of contemporary theory. My argument in this paper is that the Haitian Revolution as an empirical event challenged many assumed theoretical universalities and in so doing has made contemporary theory ever more useful in terms of making sense of the world and uncovering hidden truths. For the purpose of this paper, theory as a concept as well as the practice of theory as process needs to be discussed in detail. Theory as a concept can best be understood as a system of ideas that are meant to explain a facet of existence. Thory can be very bold...

Words: 2437 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Final Study Guide

...pictured Latin Americans to be lazy individuals. •Modernization Theory: Once the previous idea was settled, it came to the reality that the Latin American countries had to go through modernization, such as the United States, and their feeble network on which their society rested upon was that being criticized. •Dependency Theory: Students were sure that these two previous explanations were merely methods to blame the victims of abuse. They believed that Latin American economies stood in a dependent position relative to the world’s industrial powers. Therefore other nations took their overpowering stand, and forestalled Latin America’s industrialization. “Economic dependency” is why the nation did not follow the path it was supposed to follow. •Social Constructionism: The way race, gender, class, and national identities are “constructed” in people’s minds. Discuss Michel Rolph Trouillot’s theory of historical narratives •History understood as the distinction and overlap of the socio-historical process (“what happened”) and the narratives about it (“what is said to have happened”). •Three capacities people have within socio-historic processes: actors, agents, subjects a) Agents: or occupants of the structural positions. (b) as actors in constant interference without a context. (c) as subjects, thats is...

Words: 3338 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Living It on the Skin: Italian States, Working Illness

...´ NOELLE J. MOLE PRINCETON UNIVERSITY Living it on the skin: Italian states, working illness A B S T R A C T In this article, I examine the codification of an Italian work-related illness caused by mobbing, a type of psychological harassment that emerged at the moment neoliberal policies transformed Italy’s historically protectionist labor market. I trace how the medicalization of mobbing has expanded workers’ access to compensation, resources, and discursive tools for criticizing neoliberal labor conditions, even as it has produced new structures of surveillance. I unravel the neoliberal politics of a state that protects workers’ health yet governs worker–citizens through an apparatus of medical experts. I find that workers’ labor problems are experienced and managed as bodily problems in ways important to remaking Italian citizenship. [neoliberalism, state, labor, biopolitics, citizenship, bodies, Italy] An institution, even an economy, is complete and fully viable only if it is durably objectified . . . in bodies. —Pierre Bourdieu1 It was the spirit of capitalism made flesh. —Upton Sinclair2 n 2003, a new psychophysical disturbance, organizational coercion pathology (disturbi psichici e fisici da costrittivit` organizzativa sul a lavoro), or OCP, became a work-related illness that was insurable by an Italian state public-health institution (Istituto Nazionale per l’Assicurazione contro gli Infortuni sul Lavoro [INAIL] 2003).3 Telltale symptoms, often likened to those...

Words: 18731 - Pages: 75