...Compare and contrast the presentation of John Webster’s The Duchess of Malfi and Shakespeare’s Cleopatra. Your study should refer to relevant contextual material and also include appropriate readings of the plays by other critics: The Duchess of Malfi (Main Text) In Jacobean England (1603-25) the theatre enjoyed enthusiastic royal support and the period was notable for some of the greatest plays ever written. Webster was already part of the ‘second generation’ and Shakespeare was already one of the most revered dramatists of his time. Both Webster and Shakespeare produced remarkable plays in this period, which gave dramatic prominence to complex tragic women. The Duchess of Malfi (1612) and Antony and Cleopatra (1607) are two plays that explore the contradictions of social and sexual relations in a patriarchal and misogynistic period of England as seen through the presentation of there two heroines The Duchess and Cleopatra, and also through the different forms of linguistical and structural methods employed by both writers that ultimately highlight the two women’s similar yet opposing natures. Essentially both plays are Jacobean tragedies of gender politics where the Duchess and Cleopatra seek freedom of action and desire but are defined and shaped by patriarchal oppression and thereby doomed for their perceived subversive sexuality. Through language both writers present their two heroines’ as powerful women who challenge the traditional male restrictions. The Duchess...
Words: 3036 - Pages: 13
...disgrace, which still does not necessarily hurt anyone. That’s to say, since I am not selfish at all and I can think emphatically, guilt causes more infliction upon me. If I define shame as a public disgrace, in my culture, as I perceive it, shame comes first since everybody lives for her/his honour. So if you are publicly condemned because of what you did, you can easily lose your self- respect and respect among public. However, for me; guilt tortures soul, mind and heart more if you are a good and responsible person. To relate this to the play, I could give Antony as an example of feeling guilt more powerfully than shame. When the news of Fulvia’s death comes to him, Antony immediately questions where she died, which comes out of his curiosity about how much he is guilty of Fulvia’s death in case she had died on any battle field in the absence of Antony. This feeling of guilt turns Antony away from his precious beloved Cleopatra at once by reminding him of his responsibilities and destructive idleness. There is no direct, correct answer to that question as the speaker creates ambiguity about whether thunder brings rain or no. Although in other parts of the poems, there are allusions, metaphors and implications about water with rebuilding and destroying effect, in the last part the speaker voices a cry for water, rain. He says, “there is not even silence in the mountains /But dry sterile thunder without rain” signifying the fact that thunder is not able to bring rain, which symbolizes...
Words: 794 - Pages: 4
...Cassius Dio once said Cleopatra “captivated the two greatest Romans in her day, and because of the third she destroyed herself” (Biography.com Editors). Cleopatra ruled Egypt with such confidence and maturity for her age. She lost the throne and managed to reclaim it, eliminated the threat of her siblings taking the throne from her, and fell in love not once, but twice. Cleopatra’s ending captivated the hearts of the people of her time, and still continues to capture the hearts of people today. Her perseverance and confidence inspires women all over the globe. The life of Cleopatra VII Thea Philopator, struck with tragedy more than once, remains a well known story that no one can forget; however, she strongly and intelligently proved she could...
Words: 1487 - Pages: 6
...Cleopatra (1963) More at IMDbPro » In 48 B.C., Caesar pursues Pompey from Pharsalia to Egypt. Ptolemy, now supreme ruler after deposing his older sister, Cleopatra, attempts to gain favor with Caesar by presenting the conquerer with the head of Pompey, borne by his governors, Pothinos and Achillas. To win Caesar's support from her brother, Cleopatra hides herself in a rug, which Apollodorus, her servant, presents to Caesar. The Roman is immediately infatuated; banishing Ptolemy, he declares Cleopatra Egypt's sole ruler and takes her as his mistress. A son, Caesarion, is born of their union. Caesar, however, must return to Italy. Although he is briefly reunited with Cleopatra during a magnificent reception for the queen in Rome, Caesar is assassinated shortly thereafter, and Cleopatra returns to Egypt. When Mark Antony, Caesar's protégé, beholds Cleopatra aboard her elaborate barge at Tarsus some years later, he is smitten and becomes both her lover and military ally. Their liaison notwithstanding, Antony, to consolidate his position in Rome, marries Octavia, sister of the ambitious Octavian. The marriage satisfies no one. Cleopatra is infuriated, and Antony, tiring of his Roman wife, returns to Egypt. There he flaunts his liaison by marrying Cleopatra in a public ceremony. Sensing Antony's weakness, Octavian attacks and defeats his forces at Actium. Alarmed, Cleopatra withdraws her fleet and seeks refuge in her tomb. Written by alfiehitchie The story of Queen Cleopatra VII...
Words: 1472 - Pages: 6
...Cleopatra’s Sexual Dominance The struggle to find a well-rounded female character in literature is a task in itself, yet William Shakespeare has outdone himself with his version of Cleopatra. She is a queen, a lover and a mother, juggling the complexity of fitting into mainstream Roman society. Shakespeare’s humanly complex characterization of Cleopatra shows the prevailing female sexuality and the influence it has over men. Throughout the entirety of the play Antony and Cleopatra, the Egyptian queen is the topic of almost every conversation between the Romans. She is called a differentiated amount of names, all resonating as a negative connotation. She’s been called ‘whore’ ‘witch’ and ‘wench’ numerous times throughout the play. It felt...
Words: 1992 - Pages: 8
...affects her presentation. He uses minor characters to create a rather negative depiction of Cleopatra. The presentation of Antony uses the settings and monologues to portray a rather divided person. Shakespeare presents Cleopatra as being insatiable. In the first scene, Cleopatra is compared to a gipsy and Antony's infatuation with her has reduced him to being 'the bellows and the fan/To cool a gipsy's lust'. By likening the queen to a common gipsy, Cleopatra is diminished in the eyes of the audience as being nothing more than a wanton, dishonest woman. Contextually, gipsies were seen as cunning and having fortune telling...
Words: 907 - Pages: 4
...Topic 1 Cleopatra Throughout time Cleopatra has been distinguished with many different characters, some as a kind hearted others as the ruling queen that can conquer anything. When relating to the Horace’s Odes and Plutach’s Life of Mark Antony to the 1999 movie of Cleopatra directed by Franc Roddam. Cleopatra might have taken many characters throughout years but when comparing everything she has some characteristics that are the same and some that are pursued differently. She was smart and clever woman that knew everything that was going around her. Cleopatra was also considered a strong independent women by being able to rule Egypt without any King. Even though she was powerful queen she always had a love for men. Cleopatra can be portrayed with many different characteristics but will always have be loving and powerful queen of Egypt through all points of view. Cleopatra was recognized as a very smart woman that has the capabilities to outsmart anyone. She knows the plans of men in which she is able to outmaneuver them when needed. Cleopatra shows her cleverness through the actions with Mark Antony and Julius Caesar. For example in the movie, Cleopatra is being seen as a sneaky women that just wants power and does things strategically to get what she wants. She wanted to become queen and by taking over Caesars heart she was able to marry and get what she always wanted. People hated Caesar for having Cleopatra become queen of Egypt and people always thought of Cleopatra as Caesars...
Words: 1588 - Pages: 7
...Cleopatra Essay Cleopatra was born in 69 BC. She was the queen of Egypt and she was the last Ptolemaic ruler of Egypt. Even though in Egypt the society was ran by men Cleopatra was the only girl who ran the whole country. As a child Cleopatra was intelligent and she always cares for other. Cleopatra was a daughter of Ptolemy XII Auletes and she was interested in politics from her father. When her dad died, her brother kicked her out from Egypt when she was 48. Cleopatra wants to get back at her brother by force. One day Caesar came to Alexandria and Cleopatra thought she could get Caesar to help her. Later Caesar was in a battle against Cleopatra’s brother and at the end Cleopatra’s brother died. Then Cleopatra was restored to her throne and Caesar gain control of Egypt through Cleopatra. Then Cleopatra was married to her youngest brother Ptolemy XIV. For this occasion Caesar arranged a trip for Cleopatra to visit the Rome. While Cleopatra was in Rome, some of Caesar’s friend decided to kill him because of his behavior. One night Cleopatra dreamed that Caesar was about to be murdered, so Cleopatra warned Caesar not to leave the palace to meet the senate. When Caesar left he was assassinated and Cleopatra got scared losing her life, so she left Rome after the event. When Cleopatra is in Egypt Mark Antony led the army in Egypt and after that Cleopatra fell in love with Mark Antony and later they got married. After they got married and started to rule together, Octavian came in...
Words: 422 - Pages: 2
...relationship. However, in the plays Much Ado About Nothing and Antony and Cleopatra, Shakespeare shows that either man uses love to achieve his own goals (like Claudio who wants to marry Hero as she is the perfect Elizabethan woman) or love is influenced in man by other people (like Beatrice and Benedick) or the intensity of love even brings about the death of lovers (as in Antony and Cleopatra). In addition, some characters explain their actions by professing or implying that they did them out of love (or heart-break due to lost love) when that is not actually the case. A key scene in Much Ado About Nothing occurs when Claudio publicly declares Hero to be sexually promiscuous just because he apparently saw her speaking to a man outside her bedroom window; Claudio’s tries to redeem his honor in the eyes of the public while giving people the impression that he is a betrayed and heart-broken lover who is shaming Hero. Similarly, in the Battle of Actium which takes place in Antony and Cleopatra, we see Caesar making a grave mistake of following Cleopatra when she sails away mid-battle. “Egypt, thou knew’st too well My heart was to thy rudder tied by th’ strings, And thou shouldst tow me after.” (3.12.60 – 62) Antony states that his heart is tied to her and will follow her anywhere, implying that he is very much in love with her that he would do anything to keep her by his side. But in reality, it seems as though Antony is insecure and followed her as he thought she was leaving him;...
Words: 3779 - Pages: 16
...Cleopatra VII Thea Philopator was born into the country of Egypt at the time Rome was on the rise. She would suffer loses of her husbands, her country, and eventually her life. From her birth in 69BC to her suicide in 31BC, she did not live the life of what one would consider to be that of a princess. Cleopatra was the daughter of the pharaoh of Egypt, thus a princess. One would think that being born a princess leads a life of happiness and the eventual life goal of being the Pharaoh; however, this was not the case for Cleopatra. She did not get to live a happy life. This princess lived in Egypt at the time when Rome was extremely powerful. Rome was a growing world power and conquering country after country. During Cleopatra’s rule,...
Words: 1045 - Pages: 5
...SUPERSTITIONS AND DREAM INTERPRETATIONS IN THE DUCHESS OF MALFIAND ALL FOR LOVE Superstition, a sort of a feeling that takes umpteen number of forms and at times frightens life out of people, takes a special place in the life of a person which might make a person float on cloud nine or perish in dungeons. Superstitions are universal and they do exist even now in the 21st century and the plays before three centuries are no exceptions. The plays during the 16th and 17th centuries were abounding with superstitious beliefs which might seem ridiculous in the present scenario. In this paper we shall see the role of superstitious beliefs and dreams in The Duchess of Malfi by John Webster and All for Love by John Dryden. The Duchess of Malfi is a revenge tragedy and unlike other revenge tragedies here the villain himself avenges the death of the Duchess. The Duchess is a young widow who is in love with Antonio, the manager of her house hold and is steadfast on marrying him. In spite of the threatening of her brothers she marries Antonio with the aid of Cariola. Ferdinand, one of her brothers employs Bosolo to spy her. Ferdinand apart from eyeing the fortune of the Duchess he also eyes her beauty. But Cardinal, the other brother of the Duchess is worried only about her wealth. Bosola passes the news that the Duchess has given birth to a child and Ferdinand in unquenchable fury banishes the Duchess. Ferdinand with the help of Bosola gains a fake key to the chamber of the Duchess and...
Words: 1837 - Pages: 8
...NO THANKSGET THE APP cleopatra Dana Livelli GEO-101-001 Professor DiBello November 16, 2015 When thinking of Egypt, typically, one would associate Cleopatra with that thought. However, more often than not, a person’s depiction of her is usually in the form of Elizabeth Taylor from her role of Cleopatra in the 1960’s film, or even a Halloween costume. As a result of this portrayal, people fail to acknowledge or aren’t even aware of how strong of a leader she actually was. Through a timeline of events, this essay will prove she was intelligent, determined, and brave and exhibited these traits throughout her life. In approximately the year 69 BC, Cleopatra VII Thea Philopator, most commonly known as Cleopatra, was born. She was the second daughter of Ptolemy XII Auletes, the Pharaoh of Egypt at the time. It is unclear of who her mother was, however it was most likely Cleopatra V Tryphaena. Cleopatra was born to a family of royals, the Ptolemaic Dynasty. The Ptolemaic Dynasty was the last dynasty to rule Egypt. Prior to...
Words: 1701 - Pages: 7
...to Rome, and Cleopatra ruled over Egypt once again, with her other younger brother, Ptolemy XIV, as her associate and next husband. 46 BC became the year of Ptolemy Caesar’s birth, Julius Caesar’s son. He was most commonly called Caesarion, or ‘little Caesar’. The next year, Cleopatra traveled to Rome with her new child and husband. As written by famous playwright, William Shakespeare, Julius Caesar’s rise to power resulted in jealousy from his fellow senators, and he was assassinated by them on the ides of March in 44 BC. The next month, Cleopatra left Rome to return to Alexandria. Shortly after, Ptolemy XIV was poisoned by his sister’s orders so Caesarion could become co-ruler....
Words: 416 - Pages: 2
...After the battle of Philippi, the time came for the members of the second triumvirate to take up their duty’s in their agreed upon provinces of Rome. When the second triumvirate was established they also divided the provinces of Rome. According to Michael Grant “Antony, in the subsequent division of the Roman empire, emerged as very much the senior partner” (71). Then Lepidus got the next pick, and being the junior member Octavian was left with the rest. Octavian portion of the provinces was embarrassing but “he knew that he just had to bide his time and before too long he would turn tables on his colleagues” (Weigel 81). After the battle of Philippi, the eastern provinces that were previously under the control of Brutus and Cassius came up...
Words: 317 - Pages: 2
...Cleopatra, the final ruler of Egypt, was an immoral temptress that would let nothing and no one stand in her way of power. Although some believe her to be an intelligent role model in history for women’s rights she was absolutely nothing of the sort. Of course, she was intelligently educated, but she mainly seduced world leaders in order to acclaim the power she thirsted. So basically she was a prostitute that was being paid in power for her services. Not exactly the ideal role model. Cleopatra had an interesting early life. First off, she was born in Egypt in 69 BC. One important fact to note is that she was not even of Egyptian descent; in fact, she was of the Greek lineage. Her ancestor, Ptolemy 1 Soter, happened to be one of Alexander...
Words: 1554 - Pages: 7