Free Essay

Art Piece Comparison

In:

Submitted By tnn515
Words 852
Pages 4
Joshua Agbaosi
5/5/14
Williams
ARTH1010-81
Final Project
George Inness. Old Aqueduct (1971)
Frederic Edwin Church. Andes of Ecuador (1855)
Space
Both of the works depicted above use “Space” as their primary formal visual element. Inness’s work uses relative size and linear perspective to portray the appearance of a distant horizon by utilizing relative size. The cliffs in the background are painted on a relatively smaller scale than the man in the foreground of the painting, given a human body would be much smaller in size in comparison to a landmass. This simple principle of relative size gives Old Aqueduct spatial complexity. The landscape that takes up the majority of the piece is broad and minimally designed. The landscape actually appears to not be in focus much like it would be if this painting were a photograph. As the viewer’s eye lingers from the background to the foreground, the images in the painting become more detailed and meticulous. The vegetation in the ground is more clearly defined in the foreground then becomes less nuanced in the middle ground. These visual cues give this work the perception of depth. This work, also, appears to be painted in two-point perspective, giving this work sense of vastness. Andes of Ecuador also uses “Space” as its primary visual element. The relative size and linear perspective is much similar to Old Aqueduct’s. The mountainous terrain gradually goes from relatively large in the foreground and middle ground to relatively small in the background. The sun in the background also drowns out the mountains to a greater degree in the background than in the foreground. The sun’s ambiance gradually becomes less brilliant, providing less illumination as the viewer’s eye drifts from the background to the foreground. The gradients in the texture and hue saturation are especially evident in the mountains. The brightness gradient also contributes to the atmospheric perspective. Unlike Inness’s painting, Andes of Ecuador seems to be painted from a different vantage point. It appears that this work was painted in two-point perspective, but from a different eye-level. The viewer will see this from a higher ground than in Old Aqueduct which is painted from a lower ground.
George Inness. Early Autumn Montclair (1888)
Vincent Van Gogh. Sunflowers (1887)
Texture
Both of these works utilize “Texture” as their primary formal visual element. Early Autumn uses visual texture to depict a paucity of clarity. The artist uses a coarse brush which natural limits how the detailed the painting can be. This element makes the trees and blades of grass appear to be blowing in the wind. The distorted textures of the clouds, trees, and grass all contribute to the cool vibe of this work. Perhaps, the artist used this texture variety to evoke thoughts of dreariness in the viewer. There is no gradient in brightness or detail between the foreground and background. The texture remains constant throughout the painting. In contrast, Sunflowers utilizes actual texture to depict its coarseness. Van Gogh used impasto define his forms in this piece. The brush strokes applied paint liberally and this caused the paint to rise off of the canvas. The raised paint is able to be felt to the touch and gives this work a tactile surface texture. The texture remains constant throughout the painting, spanning from the foreground to the background.
Light and Value
George Inness. George Inness Sketching Outside his Montclair Studio (1889)

Pablo Picasso. Self-Portrait (1900)

Both of these works utilize “Texture” as their primary formal visual elements. The monotone hue of George Inness Sketching Outside his Montclair Studio gives this a cold and dreary vibe. The painting is speckled with a medley of different values of dark against light. The various shades of gray constitute the details in this work as there is no color. There is a large disparity in terms of the value contrast. There are segments of this painting where the shades are almost black, segments with various shades of gray and segments that are nearly white. The high value contrast makes the images and figures in the painting easy to see for the viewer. Inness also used chiaroscuro to give the figures in the painting a three-dimensional appearance.
Picasso’s Self-Portrait, like Inness’s painting, contains a vast amount of different values of dark on light. Picasso’s painting also has a paucity of color like Inness’s work. However, this work contains far more shades of black. The hair in the foreground and the vast majority of the background are close to black. The chiaroscuro is concentrated in the face and neck area to delineate his facial features. The subtle gradation is ahieved by the soft shading, particularly, around his cheek bones, jaw and nose. The shading becomes more aggressive around the outline of his face and neck to demarcate the blackish background. There are also chiaroscuro-esque elements in the eyes. The eyes contain lighter concentric circles of a lighter value and gradate to a darker value to depict reflections of light against his eyes. The heavy use of black, grays and white express somberness and gloominess.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Kandinsky Vs Braque

...Comparison Essays Comparison B Works Depicted: Self-Portrait on her Sixth Wedding Anniversary, Paula Modersohn-Becker, 1906 Les Demoiselles d'Avignon, Pablo Picasso, 1907 Primitivism. What is it? Primitivism is when those of one culture try to imitate that of another ‘simpler’ culture in their creative works. This becomes important in modern art for artist were looking for something different, artists wanted to be different. Many visited other countries to have the area influence their art although many were just there to influence their own art not appreciate the culture for that of itself. Paula Modersohn-Becker to my knowledge was not particularly influenced heavily by ‘primitive’ art other than the fact that woman’s art was more accepted...

Words: 471 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Art Appreciation

...Kayla Demel Art Appreciation 103 Online 04/1915 Comparison of Wendell Castle’s Cavalcade and Harry Bertoia’s Sounding Sculpture Comparison of Wendell Castle’s Cavalcade and Harry Bertoia’s Sounding Sculpture The artwork Cavalcade by Wendell Castle compared with Harry Bertoia’s sounding sculpture were designed for different purposes but both use elements of art to emphasis the meanings of each. I found these sculptures at the Wichita Art Museum. I selected these two because I found sculptures very interesting. The Cavalcade was made by grouping different shapes together to defy gravity and it grabbed my attention because it did not look correct because the ball was off certain and shouldn’t have been stable. The Sounding sculpture grabbed my attention because it was made to make music by many different bars hitting each other. The Cavalcade sculpture made by Wendell Castle is mahogany, lacewood, poplar, cooper, and gold leaf. The dimensions are 53 ½ by 21 ¼ by 17 1/2. This was made in 1989. There are many different shapes that has it owns color and identity. It wasn’t supposed to be symmetric because it makes a unique attack on gravity. The base of this piece is a blue green color and then a black longer piece that looks like it could be a vase is on top of that. The long black piece is not straight up it is slightly leaning to the left. Then there is a gold platter looking shape that is holding a ball off-center. I think that the artist is trying to make...

Words: 668 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Fine Art

...Name Instructor Date Compare and contrast pieces of fine art Fine art has been considered as the major source of history, which has articulated several formatives that depict on the essence of humanity. Based on different sources, fine art has navigated some comparatives that portray the nature of history that equally aligns some prospects that site on the major differences on art. To start with, the major goal of the fine art is mainly to promote a unique active and thoughtful approach towards analyzing some specification of art history. Therefore the process requires taking into consideration by comparing and contrasting some essentials of the two pieces of art that attempt to approach the critical thinking analysis. This assumption invites availing the simple analysis of the information that ideally addresses the craft of an effective subtlety that is undertaken on the process. Every step that is articulated on the preparation of the early course on the fine art is depicted as an informative exhibit that is consolidated in organizing the discrete bits in a larger notion. This is well crafted on the practice of the fine art that distinguishes the level of thinking in the history of art. Based on that note, the major exercise that reviews on fine history has added the benefit of the emerging success on the concepts of well-crafted images of fine art. This equally announces the expected comparison that focuses on this practice. The completion of the moral abstract by the major...

Words: 614 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

History of Pottery

...Japan's oldest art forms, when the earliest soft earthenware was coil-made, decorated by hand-impressed rope patterns, and baked in the open. Terracotta Warriors Fine art earthenware of Chinese clay warriors. Minoan Pottery A useful tool for dating the mute Minoan civilization. Its restless sequence of rapidly-maturing artistic styles reveal something of Minoan patrons' pleasure in novelty while they assist archaeologists assign relative dates to the strata of their sites. Pots that contained oils and ointments, exported from 18th century BC Crete, have been found at sites through the Aegean islands and mainland Greece, onCyprus, along the coastal Syria and in Egypt, showing the wide trading contacts of the Minoans. The extremely fine palace pottery called Kamares ware, and the Late Minoan all-over patterned "Marine style" are the high points of the Minoan pottery tradition. Greek Vase Painting There are two main styles in Greek vase painting – black figure and red figure. Mostly before about 530 BC people painted in black figure, and after that time people gradually began to paint in red figure. Mayan Vase Painting, Mexico  Mayan vase paintings are more akin to the art of the modern period than the art of any other pre-modern people. The principal valuation seems to have been on artistic quality rather than adherence to standardized forms.  Mimbres Pottery, American Southwest Contemporary research on the Mimbres culture relies heavily on comparisons with more modern...

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Giuliano Bugiardini’s, Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist, Northern vs. Southern

...effects on art which can be broken down and seen from Southern (Italian) and Northern paintings. With the renaissance, came disinterest in dogma, and more of a focus on naturalism and humanism. However, the strong influence of religion never left either the Northern or Southern art works, due to the commission by the church. Giuliano Bugiardini’s, Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist, 1510, is a pristine depiction of what Southern European art during the renaissance contained, element by element. Northern artists kept most their roots, focusing heavily on religion while enhancing on the details and adding few aspects of naturalism; while Southern artists took more of a maniera greca and humanistic type approach, where religion and abstraction was in a conflicting battle with what was reality. The color, light, and shadow of Bugiardini’s, Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist, emits a naturalistic feel that is seen throughout the whole painting. The painting’s main colors of brown and green are abundantly found in nature, usually representing trees, grass, dirt, etc. Mary’s red and blue gown contrasts with the rest of the scenery, making her stand out while emitting a calm (blue) but emotional (red) tone. The colors in the painting also seem to tell a story with a dull, dark brown in most of the foreground, and more vivid greens in the background. This could represent current dark times, followed by a future containing bright, happier times. Many Southern arts contained...

Words: 1362 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Art History Mid Term

...Comparison 1 The image on the left is of ‘The Parthenon, Acropolis’, a Pantelic marble structure, dating between 447 and 432 BCE, Ancient Greece. The original building on the site was built as an offering in honor of the Greek goddess Athena built in 490 BCE but destroyed in the Persian invasion of 480BCE. However in 447 BCE, Perikles commissioned a much grander and larger temple to be built over the existing foundation. The image to the right is of the ‘Hagia Sophia’, dated between 532-537, Byzantine Period. In a similar way to the Parthenon the Hagia Sophia was built over an existing fourth-century church that had been destroyed during the Nika Revolt in 532. An apparent similarity between both the places of prayer is that they were both aesthetically magnificent and groundbreaking works of art at the time, and are respectively one of the greatest examples of Greek and Byzantine architecture at it’s best. The building of the Parthenon required extraordinary skills of all forms -mathematical, mechanical, architectural, sculptural, and the culmination of this skill resulted in a beautifully harmonious monument. The Hagia Sophia was also planned and developed by the best scholar-theoreticians of the time who managed to...

Words: 1800 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

San David Dentzel Carousel Horse

...Many museums around the world display beautiful pieces of art. The Mingei International Museum of art in San Diego’s Balboa Park carries many types of art with a vast category of sculpture. One of the best pieces there is Carousel Horse by the Gustav A. Dentzel Carousel Company (1867-1928). Gustav Dentzel was a cabinetmaker, but decided to make carousel animals. His animals are the most anatomically correct than the work of other carvers. This horse in particular is a fine work because of the attention to detail, vivid colors, and realistic proportions. Detail is a great part of this sculpture, but the media that the piece was made shows the skill of the carver. It comes to life from the expression of the face. The opened mouth, wide eyes, and perked up ears really give the notion that the horse is alert, which makes it more life-like. Seeing this and realizing that it is carved from wood makes one admire it more. Wood is not a forgiving medial, so great skill is required and this piece reflects articulate craftsmanship. Additionally, the size of the horse makes it more intimidating and more realistic. If this was made from marble or anything other that wood it would not feel as real as it does....

Words: 539 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Paul Signac Post Impressionism

...Throughout the history of art, artist have continuously branched off previously existing ideas and techniques. However, many notable art periods and artists have gained recognition by pushing the barriers of technique and observation within their work, and this has resulted in a wide variety of artistic movements. Many of the successful artists who broke the constraints of what was expected were a crucial part of the Impressionist and Post-Impressionist Movement. One prominent example from the Post-Impressionist Movement that fits this idea, which also happens to be on display at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts, is Paul Signac's Blessing of the Tuna Fleet at Groix which he completed in 1923. This composition is approximately 28 ¼ x 35...

Words: 1403 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Vincent Van Goph

...these qualities were definitely innovative for the artists at the time, however some believed that it was too out of control. Post-impressionism still contained those bright vibrant colors, however artists of this period created pieces that were more planned instead of spontaneous. Perhaps one of the most famous of artists during this period was Vincent van Goph. Born in 1853, van Goph grew up in a strong Christian household and was immensely interested in priesthood. Unfortunately, he did not complete seminary due to mental health issues that would continue to affect him the rest of his life. One of the only things that helped abate his mental illness was art. Van Goph has perhaps some of the most recognizable pieces of art as they are so stylized with bright colors and impasto brush strokes. His subjects were generally landscapes and self-portraits. All of his works were so unconventional and stylized, he was not held highly and only one of his paintings was sold during his lifetime. Van Goph purposefully used unorthodox methods of color and disdained realism, making his pieces definitely impressionistic. Later in life, he had to be in a mental asylum...

Words: 436 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Malibu

...ART 2 • MUSEUM – BASED ESSAY • DUE: MAY 4/5 Suggested Locations* L.A. Country Museum of Art (LACMA) • lacma.org for info. The Getty Center (Santa Monica) or Getty Villa (Malibu) • getty.edu for info. The assignment is to write an expository essay that focuses on an interpretation of one artwork using a specific symbol or theme (see examples below). Your interpretation must include an analysis of the subject & style of artwork in relation to the function of the object, as we do in class. (Remember the 4 Steps of Interpretation). Also, you should identify the style characteristics of the period-culture to which it belongs. In the paper you will provide “proof” for identifying style and/or meaning by comparing it to objects in your textbook. This assignment is NOT a “report.” That is, you will not find much information about the artwork at the museum. The point of this paper is to interpret the object based on similarities to other objects that are more “known.” Your interpretation should be made primarily of your own observations in relation to the information provided by the textbook and research you conduct about the artworks’ style, symbolism, cultural context, etc. You must support your observations with facts. Also you must properly cite your sources of information in a works cited list. Consult the articles on writing available on our MyECC teamsite in the Writing Resources folder. Examples of Symbols: sun, moon, star, flower, halo, cross, tree, horn, offering...

Words: 1165 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Compare/Contrast 2 Ancient Sculptures

...For this essay I have chosen two sculptures, each from a different culture that I am very fond of, to compare and contrast. The first piece that I chose is an Egyptian sculpture of royalty (picture on the left). This statue represents an eternal existence reflected in its emotionless calm and enduring serenity. In this statue Menkure and His Chief Queen from the Old Kingdom’s 4th Dynasty are depicted; it is thought to have originally stood on the processional causeway leading to Menkure’s pyramid at Giza. However, the statue was discovered buried with him inside his tomb. “It is believed to have been the first double statue of its kind made.”This sculpture shares all of the conventional qualities common to most Egyptian sculptures of human figures. This type of statue is best viewed from the front or squarely from each side due to its monumentally frozen quality. “Symbolizing the absolute control of the god-ruler, this immobility serves as a visual counterpart of Egyptian belief in immutable laws that govern humans and nature.” This magnificent ancient sculpture can be found in the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston. Egyptian art is truly one of a kind, with its sophisticated beauty and uniqueness. So many cultures have learned and revised the art of the Egyptians; therefore leading me to my next choice; a glorious Greek masterpiece. The next piece I have chosen is of the Greek culture. It is a glorious statue called “Laocoon” also referred to as the “Laocoon Group” shown on the right...

Words: 769 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Cubism and Surrealism

...Cubism & Surrealism: A Break from Tradition Cubism & Surrealism: A Break from Tradition Since the introduction of perspective during the Renaissance, artists painted in a way that imitated the natural world. Some artists, such as the Impressionists, painted the world as seen through his own eyes. Others, such as the Realists, aimed to paint the world as it actually was by using precise detail and realistic subjects. It wasn’t until 1907 that artists began to look beyond nature and reality and into the creative corners of their minds to depict art that wasn’t based in the natural world.  Cubism pioneered the way for this break from tradition with its unique take on perspective while Surrealism deviated even further through exploration of the subconscious mind. Cubism developed in a time of technological advances. Photography had become common and was threatening painting as a way of documenting the natural world. Art needed to evolve its purpose. (Bewley, 2013) Cubists changed the way they approached painting by rejecting the tradition of painting the world as our eyes see it and, instead, they painted subjects broken up and reassembled in abstract form from different perspectives and viewpoints.  Influenced by African mask carvings, Picasso created Les Demoiselles d’Avignon, the first painting which exhibited cubism elements. (FozzyFozz, 2012) Although not considered a Cubist painting, Picasso’s Les Demoiselles d’Avignon is regarded by many as a pre-Cubist painting...

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Top Ten

...Top Ten Assignment The Enlightenment and Romanic Ages produced numerous masterpieces in art, music, architecture, and literature which people still enjoy today. These opus magnums along with the philosophies during the two periods are reflections of the developments in world events and cultural patterns. This paper will present two pieces of art, music, architecture, literature, and philosophy from the Enlightenment and Romanic Ages that best represents the developments patterns from that time. Philosophy in the Enlightenment Age focused on an individual’s right to life and liberty. One example of a philosopher from this age is Thomas Jefferson. He famously wrote the Declaration of Independence (1776) that the Continental Congress signed declaring the United States free from the oppression of England. The document begins with, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness” (us history, 2013). Another such example of philosophy during the Enlightenment Age are the works of Thomas Paine. He wrote two of the most highly influential pamphlets at the start of the American Revolution. One such pamphlet is Common Sense (1776) (us history, 2011) the all-time bestselling book that advocates America’s independence from Great Britain. Thomas Jefferson and Thomas Paine were chosen as examples because we believe the Declaration...

Words: 1558 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Art In American Culture

...Art from the past can depict and influence culture in a variety of ways, and can still be seen in our own culture today. At times, we might often wonder how a tradition or ritual had originally started, but never actually retrieve many answers. Fortunately, art from centuries ago could help us trace the clues to how things began. The things that we see and use nowadays could have easily be connected to the past as a sacred relic or a powerful symbol. Though we may not know it, we could very well be using some of the same customs that many have used in the past, but in our own modern way. Regardless of when it was made or where it was originated, art can take on different forms, but still hold some of the same meaning it had had from many years...

Words: 1470 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Bouuray God Analysis

...The piece of work I'm examining is the Bouray God, by an unknown artist from Bouray-sur-Juine, France. This is a Celtic work that dates from between the 1st century B.C.E. and 1st C.E, and depicts a naked, beardless man with hooves for legs and wearing a torque around his neck. The statue is fairly small, at 41.5 cm tall and is made of bronze, brass, and glass. It's missing both of its arms, one of its eyes, and has deteriorated significantly around the "knees" and arm stubs but is otherwise in fairly stable condition. The Bouray God is an excellent example of some of the motifs and features of this period of Celtic art. The piece was made out of two bronze casts that were molded together and shaped by hammering to smooth out the surface....

Words: 528 - Pages: 3