Free Essay

Does Poverty Cause Crime

In:

Submitted By dxrigo
Words 1492
Pages 6
Personal development and Academic Skills | Poverty and Crime | Does poverty foster crime? | | SHI Hanwei | 28 September 2012 |

Introduction:
There has been an ongoing discussion over the relationship between poverty and crime. Some of the researches have concluded that poverty does not increase the crime rate, because in some of the most undeveloped countries where people have low standard of living and some even struggle to survive, the crime rate was proven to be low (Christine 2005). However, in contrast, some scholars have developed a direct relationship between poverty and crime. The researchers indicated that since people who live in poverty are already having a bad life and the benefit of committing a crime is greater than the cost of committing it and ultimately, people who live in poverty is more likely to commit a crime (Niskanen 1996). This essay will examine both perspectives over the relationship between poverty and crime and subjectively suggest possible causes of crime rate. However, since only secondary data are gathered, there might not be sufficient information to present the real issue.
Contents of Discussion:
In order to prove the direct relationship between poverty and crime, it is crucial to understand the direct influences of poverty and then the potential threats it might oppose to the society. Poverty is defined as the state of having little or no money, goods, or means of support; condition of poor (Dictionary.com 2012). The money is the key part of the definition. People’s wealth is judged based on the money they have on hand and their purchase power. Thus, it is reasonable to conclude that while people with lower income are having difficult times in their life and when the benefit of committing a crime will give them greater benefit, they are willing to do it. However, the question lies in how countries measure poverty.
The level of poverty can be different among countries. For example, U.S. census has indicated that, U.S. households is generally make up with parents and two kids, and they are considered to be poverty families when the household income is less than $25,000 (United State Census Bureau 2012). In contrast, poverty is measured different in other countries. For example, imaging families in developing countries with household income of USD $25,000, they are definitely considered as part of the wealthy families. If a family is considered poor in U.S. becomes rich in another country, there is not direct relationship between poverty and crime, because there is no standard measurement of “poor” in global accepted term.
In other words, due to the different definition of poverty will change people’s expectation over life. As shown previously, the “poor” U.S. family might be expecting a vehicle and a large house while making stable income in order for them to consider themselves as regular families. While in other developing country, the expectation over life might be simple as obtaining food and shelter. The difference in definition of poverty influences people’s expectation which ultimately changes the benefit people are seeking. It is clueless to state that people are more likely to commit crime due to the benefits they are getting. For example, compare a poverty family member who conducted a crime over stealing car key; because he is seeking the benefit of having a car versus a person who conducted rubbery because he is hungry, the benefit seeking is totally different. However the reason of conducting the crime is different (want versus need). Ultimately, it is the reason of conducting a crime that matters instead of judging crime rate over a person’s social status. Therefore, the difference in between measurement of poverty makes it hard to prove that poverty produces higher level of crime rate.
On the other hand, poverty does produce poorer level of education level which results in lower awareness of laws and regulations. In almost every country, the government will have to spend large amount of money on its educational institution. The goal of developing a higher level education is to educate people and to foster greater pace of development. However, it is impossible in reality for governments to take care their every citizen for their education. The government is financial incapable of providing this kind of service, especially in large population countries such as China. Thus, people who live in poverty find it challenging to pay for the higher tuition fee. There has been a theory suggesting that, people who are rich will continuously be rich, due to their higher level of education, greater material surroundings and better network and resources. In contrast, people who are poor will continually be poor because they are unable to afford the high tuition fee and therefore, their life can be hardly changed, this is referred to as the “poverty trap” (The economist 2011). The theory has presented an important aspect of education – education produces better living condition. In developed countries such as Canada, the government provides free tuition till high school. However, in developing countries such as China, families have to afford the high tuition fee after primary school. While poverty families are considering as people with less money, they cannot afford the high tuition fee. Ultimately, with lack of higher level of education, they are more likely to conduct crimes because they lack of understanding over laws. It was further proven by the research conducted by the Canadian government. The research has shown that seventy percent of the people who entered prison have dropped out or have never entered high school (Thestar.com 2012). Furthermore, the research further indicated that people who entered the prison has either substance-abuse problem or have difficulties in obtaining jobs. Additionally, people who have committed crimes are below poverty lines.
The research has provided greater insights to the study. Educational background is important factor influencing crime rate, which has direct relationship with poverty. Furthermore, while economic condition does influence the crime rate, but the increase in crime is dependent not solely on economic condition, but on the level of economic condition. As stated in the research, people who have committed crime are below poverty lines. It is further evidenced by their difficulties in obtaining jobs, which affects their ability to obtain shelter and goods. Other researchers have also proven the point by stating that economic power has influences over crime rate, but it is hard to link crime rate to poverty, because there are other people who live above poverty bust still commits crime (Howsen & Jarrell1987). Therefore, poverty has influence over crime rate, but the level of influences is dependent on poverty member’s level of life difficulty.
Conclusion:
While it is evidenced that poverty has influence over crime rates, but the relationship between the two subjects is weak. Poverty does influence crime rate due to the poverty member’s inability to obtain higher level of education which results in lacking of lawful knowledge. However, the increase in crime rate should not be attributed to poverty, but deep poverty. Deep poverty is referring to people who are struggling to survive. In other words, without committing crimes, it is threatening their lives. Therefore, the increase in crime is affected by multiple issues such as one’s mental state, educational background, financial power, personal beliefs, culture etc. It is the government’s job to promote and provide educations over laws. Furthermore, governments should establish international measurement scales over poverty people. Only people who are struggling to live should be included in such area, and special help should be granted. It is important for government to realize that, there is no relationship between poverty and crime rate, but there is a heavy relationship between people who live below poverty and crime rate.
After all, as indicated by one of the scholars, it is the government’s responsibility to improve poverty within the country and it does not matter if poverty causes crime, because it is the government’s job to help poverty and to improve the current situation. (Tadros 2009).

References:
Christine, I. E. (2005). Under siege: Poverty and crime in a public housing community. Contemporary Sociology, 34(3), 245-246.

Dictionary.com (2012), Poverty, Viewed: 25 Sept 2012, Retrieved from: <http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/poverty>

Howsen, R. M., & Jarrell, S. B. (1987). Some determinants of property crime: Economic factors influence criminal behavior but cannot completely explain the syndrome. The American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 46(4), 445-445

Niskanen, W. A. (1996). Welfare and the culture of poverty. Cato Journal, 16(1), 1-15.

Thestar.com (2012), Tough on poverty, tough on crime, Viewed: 21 Sept 2012, Retrieved from: http://www.thestar.com/opinion/editorialopinion/article/941753--tough-on-poverty-tough-on-crime

The Economist (2011). International: The economics of violence; conflict and theory, The Economist Intelligence Unit, 8729(399), p. 45

United State Census Bureau, (2012), How the Census Bureau Measures Poverty, Viewed: 23 Sept 2012, Retrieved from: http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/poverty/about/overview/measure.html

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Does Poverty Lead to Engaging in Criminal Activity?

...Does Poverty Lead to Engaging in Criminal Activity? Within the African community of the Kipsigis, in the South Rift valley Province of Kenya, there is a common saying which is used to insult someone who is lazy and is bound to die poor. The saying goes “May thieves never visit you.” The assumption in the saying is that thieves will only visit the one who has something to be stolen. Hence, the saying expresses a sarcastic wish on the lazy one that ‘may you be so poor that even thieves cannot think of visiting you because you have nothing valuable in your house.’ Inherent within the saying is also the assumption that ‘thieves’ steal because they need something they do not have, i.e. they are poor. It is commonly assumed that there is a direct causal link between poverty and crime. Hardly does a day pass before the highlights in, say, a newspaper, radio or TV, report of crime associated with the poorest areas of any subject society. We are more easily appalled to hear of a burglary in those places where the rich and the well-off live than in the slums, for example. But, is it always true that poverty is an impetus to crime? This paper challenges this assumption by showing how an unclear definition of what we mean by ‘poverty’ and ‘crime’ or ‘criminal activities’ makes it difficult not only to identify crime or a criminal activity but also to prevent it. What, then, can be conceived as a more elaborate definition of poverty? According to the Scottish Poverty Information Unit (as...

Words: 1116 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Poverty in the Phillipines

...Santayana Professor Ashley Trunko English 101 25 June 2014 Writer’s Checklist for Cause and Effect Essay 1. Have I identified the cause or effect I am analyzing in my thesis? Yes I have by describing what the causes are for poverty and the great effects this has. 2. Have I explained the cause-and-effect relationship convincingly? Yes I have by citing examples. 3. Have I organized my causes and/or effects logically? Yes I have by using transtions. 4. Have I used sound logic? Yes I did. 5. Have I concluded my essay effectively? Yes I did 6. Have I proofread thoroughly? Yes I did. Sharon K. Santayana Professor Ashley Trunko English 101 25 June 2014 The Poor Get Poorer “It’s More Fun in the Philippines!” a famous tourism campaign for this island of 7,107. The Philippines is one of the major countries frequently visited by tourists every year. From its booming nightlife to its immaculate white sand beaches, one would think that this country has it all. Think again. Poverty is a big problem in the country. With its lack of education, health care, food, shelter, and jobs, to add the high crime rate, this country is far from where someone would imagine living in. “Poverty is often identified as a situational condition contributing to the possibility of negative outcome for at-risk populations” (Tuason 40). What causes poverty? Who are affected? Poverty stems from the lack of resources for an over populated geographic location. In 2014...

Words: 623 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Crime

... four banks were attacked in an hour-and-a-half; one daytime raid took place just steps from the Lincoln Center in downtown Manhattan. The week before, San Diego had seen four bank holdups in a single day. Criminologists wondered if the holiday spree was the first sign of a looming crime wave in recession-battered America. Take an uptick in poverty and economic misery, toss in budget cuts to police departments across the country, and that should be a blueprint for chaos—right? Except, as it turns out, the exact opposite occurred. According to FBI statistics, crime rates went down across the board in 2009. Way down. Murder, rape, robbery, assault, auto theft—plummeted, one and all. Then, this week, the FBI released preliminary data for the first six months of 2010, and again the same pattern emerged. Violent crimes and property crimes alike have been falling in every region of the country. What gives? Have experts just completely misunderstood what causes people to commit crimes?   There's certainly no shortage of theories for why crime rates have gone down over the past two years. The simplest is that crime just isn’t closely related to economic conditions. Consider, after all, the two big crime epidemics in the twentieth century—the first took root in the late 1960s, during a period of healthy growth; the other came during the economic doldrums of the late ‘80s and early ‘90s. The only constant here, it seems, is that both outbreaks were fueled by a major expansion of drug...

Words: 10363 - Pages: 42

Free Essay

Crime

...  This article was an interessting read of the statistics concerning violent crime in  america. It takes into account income and educations as being major factors that contribute to the  rate of crime that we experience here in the United States.  While this relation is not 100%, it still  is very useful in understanding how and why crime is more prevalent in certain areas of the  country than in others.     To better understand this article it’s important to understand what crime really is. Crime is  defined as an action or an instance of negligence that is deemed injurious to the public welfare or  morals or to the interests of the state and that illegally prohibited. There is a long list of different  categories of crimes. Crimes can generally be divided up into 4 categories: Personal crimes,  Property crimes, Inchoate crimes and statutory crimes. Personal crimes are  “Offenses against the  Person”: These are crimes result in physical or mental harm to another person. Personal crimes  include: Assault , Battery, False Imprisonment, Kidnapping, Homicide – crimes such as first and  second degree, murder, and involuntary manslaughter, and vehicular homicide, Rape, statutory  rape, sexual assault and other offenses of a sexual nature. Property Crimes – “Offenses against  Property”: These are crimes that do not necessarily involve harm to another person. Instead, they  involve an interference with another person’s right to use or enjoy their property. Property  crimes include: Larceny (theft), Robbery (theft by force) – Note: this is also considered a ...

Words: 1820 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Crime Is the Result of Individual Behaviour, Rather Than the Product of a Socialisation Process”

...“Crime is the result of individual behaviour, rather than the product of a socialisation process” Discuss. For decades sociologists from around the world have been debating what factors lead people to commit crime. Some have deduced that individual behaviour is the primary factor while others have concluded that crime is more the product of a socialisation process. In order to understand this contentious issue it is necessary to consider the credibility of a number of theories: physiological, psychological, right realism, Marxism, subculturalism, and left realism. Through the analysis of these theories, a conclusion will then be arrived at as to whether individual behaviour, rather than the socialisation process, is the main cause of crime. Physiological theories focus on the relationship between a person’s biology and crime. Therefore, this theoretical area of study clearly links the individual to crime. Today, a number of criminologists continue to support physiological explanations, even though, historically, many of theories linked to physiology have been disproved. Anne Moir and David Jessel are two such theorists who have proposed a link between biology and crime. They have suggested that a low IQ (which can be inherited) leads to impulsive behaviour, which may in turn lead a person to be more likely to commit crime. Moir and Jessel also claim that there is a link between crime and hormonal differences which make males more aggressive than females and therefore...

Words: 2394 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Cause of Crime

...CAUSES OF CRIME In this modern era, there are a lot of crimes keep happening around the world. Crime is the breaking of rules or laws for which some governing authority can ultimately prescribe a conviction. Crimes that we usually found in newspaper are disappearance of children, serial murders, single homicides, serial rapes, extortions, threats, kidnappings and many more. All these crimes need to be control to ensure our country is in a peaceful condition. However, what are the causes of crimes? Firstly, one of the causes of crime is poor parenting. According to the research by Currie and Tekin (April 2006) which using data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health, it shows that the child maltreatment are having doubles the probability that an individual engages in many types of crime. According to Bloom (May 2011), parents serve as role models not only through direct interactions with their children but through the examples they set with their attitude and behavior within the family and in the outside world. Parents’ behaviors and attitudes usually will be imitated by their children. Therefore, family care and love are important to reduce the crimes rate Furthermore, lack of education may lead to the crimes. According to a paper from the University of Western Ontario and the University of California, Los Angeles, people that educated are probably less to involve themselves in crimes. They are more patience and also not likely to take risk to commit a crime...

Words: 833 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Crime

...Crime and poverty have been problems and subjects of social discussion for as long as civilization has been in existence. Even today, society still struggles with the question of how to fix and reduce both of these problems. As the decades go by and more and more statistics are collected, we can see a pattern of poverty and crime rates. What many hope to see in these graphs and statistics is a reduction of both poverty and crime. Every year billions of dollars are spent on fighting crime and helping those who find their selves struggling through poverty. Will the effort spent on reducing crime through better security make the impact on criminal activity we hope it does, or should we work on bringing those who commit crimes to a higher standard of living? Many would argue that the two are linked together and that poverty is the number one promoter and cause of criminal activity, and that adults and children who grow up living in poverty are more likely to be apart of this criminal activity. Should the government spent more money on fighting crime, or more on those who live in poverty and that are more likely to commit the crimes? The answer to that is simple; we should spend more on bringing those in poverty, out of it. Facts have shown that adults and children who live and are raised in poverty stricken areas are more likely to commit crime. As poverty levels fluctuate throughout history, so do crime levels. There are many aspects that come into play for those living...

Words: 751 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Importance Of Crime

...Tittle : Crime     “Coities and Murders.”          “Kidnappings and rapes.”      “Hold-ups of trains and hijackings of planes.” These are the news that we could read everyday in the newspaper. Crime has becoming an alarming issue in these days of civilization. Over the last few decades, undoubtedly crimes have been increased day by day. Based on the Crime and Safety Reports 2014, crime is one of the most prevailing and worrying aspects in any societies. Why do people commit crime? Some commit crime because they lack of money and there even some who commit crime simply because they find it fun to do. Specialist has conducted researchers and has come to the conclusion that the main cause of crime to occur is due to poverty. However, there...

Words: 917 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Crime of Poverty

...If we diminish poverty, then we will receive less delinquency. Poverty and crime has been major issues in our society over the past few years. Do you think these two issues correlate to each other? I think society today does see poverty as a factor in crime rates and the correlation between each is valid. The cause and effect theory is: because of poverty, crime rates are high. If this is true, one way to solve crime is to solve poverty. The sociological perspective on this topic involves looking at the bigger picture. The structural functionalism for poverty is lack of education, unemployed, preferring to “live for the moment”, and resigning themselves to a culture of poverty (which nothing can be done to change their economic outcomes). We can solve poverty by; (1) understanding the factors that play into poverty and crimes, (2) advancing our education levels, and (3) lowering our unemployment rates. With these three solutions we can diminish poverty and receive less delinquency. (Macionis, 2010, p.59). According to census, in 2014 there were more than 45 million Americans living below the poverty line. A family of three making less than $19,790 year is considered living below the poverty level. $19,790 averages out to about 10$ per hour. (Gongoff, 2014, para. 2). A single mom working at minimum wages with two kids lives in poverty. A third of all poverty households are single mothers. Single mothers are more likely to become a victim of a crime. I found...

Words: 726 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Teenage Crimes

...In Teenage Crimes Contents Executive Summary 3 Introduction 4 Teenage Crimes 4 In Pakistan 4 Background 5 Peer Pressure: 5 Poverty: 5 Poor Parenting Skills 5 Findings 6 Survey 6 Interview 6 Small Scale Implementations 7 Conclusion 8 Bibliography 9 Charts……………………………………………………………………………………………………10 Appendix 11 Executive Summary Teenage crimes as we all know are those crimes which are performed by people aging between 13-19 years old. These crimes are performed all over the world but unfortunately these crimes have been on the rise in Pakistan for the last 5 years. My objective was to find out who are responsible for the increase in teenage crimes. For this purpose I Conducted a survey from our fellow students and also interviewed a Deputy Supretendant of Police to get his views about this particular issue. The results we found showed that teenage crimes are a reason behind many problems of our country and steps should be taken to reduce this as soon as possible otherwise condition of our country will become much worse because a country cannot develop without its youth. “The Youth of today are the future of tomorrow and a country cannot prosper and develop without the contribution of its youth”:- (Bill Gates) Introduction Teenage Crimes Teenage Crimes or Juvenile...

Words: 1667 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Project 2 Literature Review

...Review October 20, 2014 “Poverty refers to a situation which the basic resources to maintain an average standard of living within a specific geographic region are lacking.” (Bartol & Bartol, 2014, p. 31) It is known that there is a definite connection between poverty and criminal activity. The connection leaves little doubt that poverty is a legitimate risk factor and those who are forced to survive in impoverished conditions are more likely to engage in criminal activity. “There is little doubt that poverty has a strong connection to persistent, violent offending, as measured by official, victimization and self-report data on both adult and juvenile offenders.” (Bartol & Bartol, 2014, p. 32) Treatment of those who reside in impoverished areas by law enforcement is much different than individuals who reside in more affluent neighborhoods. “In many communities, children from the lower socioeconomic class are targeted by law enforcement practices more than are children of the middle and upper classes” (Bartol & Bartol, 2014, p. 33) Impoverished environments also connect the individuals who reside in them to other issues which make the risk factor of poverty even more complex. According to the text (Bartol & Bartol, 2014) attending inadequate schools, not completing school, being unemployed, carrying a firearm, being victimized, along with being a witness to violent crimes are more likely to occur when an individual lives in poverty. The articles “Public housing...

Words: 2705 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Juvenile Recidivism

...Policy is created by the government for the public in response to a problem or need involving a group of people or a particular population. Normally, a policy should generate a solution to the problem, in which the public and the government would benefit simultaneously. Though, one can only allude to the government benefiting more than the American people; and as a result, people’s reaction to this has dampened their beliefs on the ‘American Dream’ of liberty, security, and equality. In spite of this, are these problems curable? Do we know the root cause of the problems? If so, the solution to fix it is simple, right? Or has the government purposely not defined the root cause of the problem in order to have a certain group of people dependent...

Words: 1521 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Poverty On Children

...Immediate and long-term consequences of poverty on children The Immediate and long-term consequences that poverty has on a child are: Developmental difficulties that include cognitive delays, physical health problems, and lack of social skills; having high-risk behavior such as teen pregnancy, drug abuse and involvement in criminal activities; and problems associated with studying that include unwillingness to attend school, repetition of class/grade and poor academic achievement. These consequences have a direct impact on how a child will turn-out in future as an adult. How might consequence of poverty affect a child’s future functioning as an adult 1) Developmental problems- Parent who lives in poverty have difficulty in providing good...

Words: 875 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Sociology

...approaches to our understanding of crime Realism views crime as a real problem that undermines solidarity and social order in society. There are two types of realists that focus on different aspects of crime to create an understanding. Right realists focus on providing realistic solutions whereas left realists focus on the rooted causes of crime, for example, poverty and marginalisation and then aim to find strategies to tackle crime. Right realists argue to understand crime we must be aware that crime happens due to three factors, biological differences, socialisation and the underclass and lastly rational choice. Right realists such as Wilson and Herrnstein put forward a biosocial theory of criminal behaviour- a combination of biological and social factors. Wilson and Herrnstein argue some individuals are innately more aggressive and therefore are more likely to commit crimes. Also, Herrnstein and Murray argue the main cause of crime is low intelligence, which is yet another biological factor that can explain the occurrence of crime. This therefore gives us an understanding that crime can occur due to biological factors such as being genetically more aggressive and having low intelligence. Rights realists also argue crime also occurs due to poor socialisation and the underclass. Right realists explain that to decrease offending we need to therefore be socialised into a nuclear family and socialised with norms and values. Charles Murray argues that crime rate is increasing due to...

Words: 1193 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Poverty Breeds Crime

...Poverty is the mother of crime Poverty is the lack of income source to buy food. In some cases it is not only the state of having income that is below the line of poverty but it is also the inability to sustain a specified level of well being. So it is in fact that most of the crimes that occur are due to poverty. No matter how much moral the person is, if the poverty threatens his or her life then he/she is likely to indulge into such criminal acts and could try to attack the prevailing social structure. Sometimes honest people who hate corruption from depth of their beings fail to keep their mental balance and due to the pressure of poverty and resort to crimes just to maintain their existence. In such circumstances the judge only looks at the crime committed instead of finding out the cause that lead the committer to such an act. What happens is the person is sent to jail and is labelled as a criminal and after his release he is further humiliated by the society and therefore is forced to become a habitual thief. The majority of men that are locked up came from a background of poverty. They did not have their fathers. Many of their mothers had them at a young age. They did not have any positive, real male role models. They basically had to raise themselves. The fathers did not have the money to get abortions and then once the baby arrived, they did not have the money to raise the child. Then once the baby arrived, they were living in squalor and poverty and they turned on...

Words: 789 - Pages: 4