Premium Essay

Domestic Violence Case Study

Submitted By
Words 1429
Pages 6
With more than ten million men and women being abused by an intimate partner in the United States each year, domestic violence remains a pressing issue in our society. Historically, domestic violence was seen as something that should be kept between and resolved by the feuding couple rather than an issue of criminality. Today, those views have changed, and it is now an issue that is dealt with in legal aspect. In this paper, I will address the mentality that judges and juries hold that perpetuate the cycle of violence among intimate partners, as well as sentencing disparities between domestic violence and violence outside of familial/intimate relationship contexts. While there is a significant occurrence of domestic violence against men, for …show more content…
How is a husband beating his wife less serious of a crime than a man who beats up a stranger? In their article “Similar Punishment? Comparing Sentencing Outcomes in Domestic and Non-Domestic Violence Cases,” Christine Bond and Samantha Jeffries (2014) found that “[d]omestic violence offenders in statistically similar circumstances were significantly less likely than those convicted of violent offences outside of familial/intimate relationship contexts to be sentenced to prison… In addition, if incarcerated, domestic violence offenders received significantly shorter terms.” The criminal justice system’s view of female victims plays a significant role in this sentencing discrepancy. In general, it is difficult for someone who has never been in an abusive relationship to understand why women decide to stay in these kinds of relationships. Because they do not understand this aspect of domestic violence, law enforcement officers and judges can grow tiresome and frustrated by working with the same victim time and time again (Epstein, 1999 (PG 699)). This can cause law enforcement officers, judges, and juries to assign blame to the victim for the abuse or believe that the abuse is not as serious as the victim has made it out to be since she has not left her abuser …show more content…
Unsurprisingly, they found that women were more likely to focus on the seriousness of the violence and treatment options for the offenders, and men were more likely to justify their shorter sentences by “explaining that his son needed his father at home” (Fradella & Fischer, ). This explanation by the male participants of this study negates the effect that domestic abuse has on a child. It is known that those who experienced abuse at a young age are likely to repeat that same behavior once they reach adulthood, and this mentality just perpetuates this vicious cycle. Further, those in the study who were given access to information regarding the effects of domestic violence on victims and their children were more likely to assign sentences to defendants that placed the safety and welfare of the woman and child first (Fradella & Fischer, ). This highlights the importance of education and training that should be provided to law enforcement, judges, and juries who are involved in domestic violence cases. There are many myths about domestic violence that many buy into because they do not know any better. When the safety and welfare of an innocent person or child is put in jeopardy, it is important that those who are responsible for providing that safety is knowledgeable and able to

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence Case Study

...comorbidity and domestic violence cases. Unfortunately, I have seen firsthand how the effect of a substance can enhance a person’s behavior and actions in a domestic violence situation. Many factors contribute to domestic violence cases. Perpetrators that participate in abusive behavior, sometimes have other issues going on with them including but not limited to, dealing with unresolved abuse as a child, substance abuse issues, and mental health issues. From these issues co-morbid diagnoses can occur in domestic violence perpetrators. Throughout this paper, I will explore the co-occurring diagnoses that accompany domestic violence. In addition, I will provide a reflection of my own personal experiences and ideas on the topic....

Words: 546 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence Case Study

...The Domestic Violence Resource Centre [DVRCV] is a state-wide non-profit organisation that aims to stop and respond to family violence; by providing support, education and training services to families, schools and professionals (DVRCV, 2017). Family violence is experienced by 1 in 4 women in Australia and out of every 3 family violence cases; 1 child witnesses it (DRCV, 2017). While it was estimated that the issue will increase due to governments not treating the issue with the seriousness it deserves in 2006 (Oberin, 2006), DVRC have been committed in decreasing such statistics since 1986 (DVRCV, 2017). Today, DVRC supports student’s wellbeing by working with schools and teachers to plan, implement and evaluate respectful relationships education...

Words: 1260 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Kathleen Rice Domestic Violence Case Study

...Kathleen Rice (Democrat) has served as the Congressional Representative for District 4 since January of 2015, her first term. Rice, a lifelong resident of Long Island who hails from Garden City, earned her law degree from Touro Law Center in 1991 after finishing her undergrad at the Catholic University in 1987. Prior to being sworn in as Congresswoman, she started her career as an Assistant District Attorney serving the public of Brooklyn, New York. Rice dealt with countless domestic violence cases, as well as cases of gang violence- all of which lead her to ultimately join the “Homicide Bureau.” This elite group serves as a legal adviser to police in homicide cases, and it aids in investigating and prosecuting some of the most high-profile...

Words: 999 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Law & Regulatory: What Does the Sarbanes-Oxyel Act Have

...DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IN WEBUYE COUNTY- WESTERN KENYA A RESEARCH PROPOSAL FOR THE FULFILLMENT OF A DIPLOMA COURSE IN THE UNIVERSITY OF ………. A STUDY CONDUCTED BY MR. SHDRACK MOMANYI OCHENGO PRESENTED TO PROF. …….. DATE OF SUBMISSION AUGUST 3, 2012 Table of Contents Chapter One (Introduction) 4 1.1 Background Information 4 1.2 Justification of the Study 6 2.0 Chapter 2: Literature Review 9 2.1 Introduction 9 2.2 Factors related to Domestic Violence 9 2. 3 Remedy to Domestic Violence. 11 2.4 Challenges in Resolving Domestic Violence 15 2.5 The Legal Framework 15 3.0 Chapter 3: Methodology 17 3.1 Introduction 17 3.2 Sample Design, Sampling Procedure and Data Collection. 17 3.3 Data Source and Data Collection Methods 18 3.4 Choice and Limitations of the Research Methods 19 3.5 Data Analysis and Ethical Issues 20 3.6 Problems, Constraints and Limitations of the Study 21 4.0 Chapter 4: Discussion of the Findings 22 4.1 Causes of Domestic Violence 22 4.2 Consequences of domestic violence 25 5.0 Chapter 5: Conclusions and Recommendations 29 5.1 Conclusion 29 5.2 Recommendations 31 Chapter 6: References 32 Appendices 34 6.1 Appendix One (Questionnaire and Interview Guide) 34 Chapter One (Introduction) 1.1 Background Information Since the beginning of the 20th...

Words: 8928 - Pages: 36

Free Essay

Domestic Violence Specialty Court Analysis and Effectiveness

...Domestic Violence Specialty Court Analysis and Effectiveness What is the leading cause of injury to women? It is domestic violence not rape, not car accidents, not muggings. Domestic Violence statistics are so bad that they do not even look real. A women is assaulted every 9 seconds, three women are murdered due to domestic violence and between 3- 10 million children witness domestic violence every year. Domestic violence is so apart of culture that 1 in 5 teenage girls are threatened by their boyfriend when she suggests breaking up with him. The worst part of domestic violence is that over half of all victims never contact the authorities or shelters for help. (“Domestic Violence Statistics”) Since money has and will always be a major part of domestic violence s courts, domestic violence costs more then 37 billion dollars a year when you add up law enforcement costs, medical and mental health treatment and lost productivity at companies. (“Domestic Violence the Stats”) Domestic violence specialty courts aim to solve the growing issue in this country. These courts want to lower recidivism rates, and make more women and children safe. The courts have supporters and people who are against them, but these courts are so new no one really has the authority to judge one side or the other. I have decided to look into how affective these courts are and if they are helping keep more people safe and helping offenders become valuable and good members of society. Before I go into...

Words: 2175 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence

...Thesis Statement Studies have shown that an increasing trend of domestic violence is being perpetrated in heterosexual households. Many of these cases involve the male abusing the female, and the female actively attempting to maintain an outward appearance of normalcy despite the silent suffering. This outward image is nothing but a cover to maintain an illusion to the world that everything is good in the relationship, and also in many cases for fear of further abuse for drawing attention to the issue. As a result a closed loop of suffering, pain, and violence is created. Annotated Bibliography What is Domestic Violence? (August, 2014) The United States Department of Justice. http://www.justice.gov/ovw/domestic-violence The U.S. Department of Justice profiles the various ways in which domestic violence can be perpetrated by the aggressor. The manners in which the aggressor may enact the abuse are; psychological, economic, emotional, physical, and sexual abuse. From this study the USDOJ is able to show how domestic violence is inflicted on females and the methods males use to gain control. The studies also show that abuse crosses all age and socioeconomic group boundaries. This study is credible as it comes from the U.S. Department of Justice. The USDOJ enforces laws and defends the interests and wellbeing of the American people. The USDOJ is continually researching various crimes, one of which being domestic abuse. This continual research gives women everywhere...

Words: 1696 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Community Attitudes Towards Domestic Violence Against Women

...Introduction This study is to focus on the attitudes of the community towards violence against women, this study introduce: * the origin of domestic violence, * the definition of domestic violence against women, * how it affects the society, * forms of domestic violence , * the cause of domestic violence * A Review of Literature is to emphasize on the importance of the attitudes of the community towards the topic, the determinant, the suggested improvements and the limitations. This study will also conclude what is to be done to improve the attitudes of the community. Personal experiences and perspective The concern of this topic has sparked my interests as a Marketing student due to the recent reports of inhuman violent acts against women in India that has raised commotion all over the country, however this report is not pin-pointing at any countries, but as a general subject. You need also to link your topic and your personal experience to the theoretical perspectives (epistemologies and paradigms) that were discussed in class. Domestic Violence against Women The status of women has been seen as unequal to the status of men in terms of authority, opportunity as well as independence. Although the society has reached a tremendous change from degradation (1990s) to a position of equality (2000s), Violence against women which is defined as “an act of gender-based violence that results in, physical, sexual or psychological harm, or suffering...

Words: 5104 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence

...Statistics about domestic violence Incidence and prevalence of domestic violence: General    There are no reliable national data on the general incidence of domestic violence in the UK1. In 2011/12, 7.3% women (1.2 million) and 5% men (800,000) report having experienced domestic abuse2. 31% women and 18% men have experienced domestic abuse since the age of 16 years. This amounts to 5 million women and 2.9 million men3. Domestic violence has repeatedly been identified as a major factor leading to death in or related to pregnancy and childbirth: see below. In 2011/12, the police reported nearly 800,000 incidents of domestic violence4. Domestic violence accounts for 10% of emergency calls5. Domestic violence has consistently accounted for between 16% and one quarter of all recorded violent crime6. There has been a 65% increase in number of domestic violence prosecutions between 2005/6 and 2010/11 and a corresponding 99% increase in number of defendents convicted7.   Despite this, domestic violence conviction rates in the five years to 2011 stood at just 6.5% of incidents reported to police – though a much higher proportion of around 70% of those charged8. Women are much more likely than men to be the victim of multiple incidents of abuse, of different types of domestic abuse (partner abuse, family abuse, sexual assault and stalking) and in particular of sexual violence9.        Hester, 2008. Office for National Statistics (ONS), 2013. 3 This is a smaller proportion...

Words: 6856 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

A Study on Gender-Based Violence

...found that domestic violence against women is still a universal problem. This paper will explore the phenomenon gender-based violence in Hong Kong as compared to the global situation. An extensive literature review was conducted to explore the existing theories and risk factors associated with domestic violence. A qualitative study of women victims was then undertaken to gain further insight on the current gender-based violence situation in Hong Kong. In the discussion, the limitations of the study were examined and the results were compared of with literature findings. A STUDY ON GENDER-BASED VIOLENCE IN HONG KONG INTRODUCTION Worldwide Phenomenon of Gender-based Violence Domestic Violence has endangered the lives and well-being of millions of women worldwide. This is no longer a private matter between individual family members but should be recognized “as an obstacle to equality, and as an intolerable offence to human dignity”. (United Nations, 1996). In a statement to the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing in September 1995, the United Nations Secretary-General, Boutros Boutros-Ghali, said that violence against women is a universal problem that must be universally condemned. Studies in 10 countries have found that between 17 per cent and 38 per cent of women have suffered physical assaults by a partner (United Nations, 1995). The United Nation (1995) defines violence against women as “any act of gender-based violence that results...

Words: 5204 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence In The United States

...Domestic Violence is one of the most common crime in the United States. One of the issue of violence against women is that is abhorrent and accept in our society. In some of the cases of domestic violence, victims don’t report the crime. They are in love with their partner and believe that they will change. Economic status is one of the big reason why victims of domestic violence don't leave their partner or report the crime. Also, if they have children, women accept the violent act because their children. In some circumstances domestic violence victims are blamed and are seen as their fault. According to Jayne Mooney, violence against women is society account if the women are sexually incidentally, neglect the house or household duties....

Words: 1248 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence

...changes in the police response to domestic violence however there are still many areas that need improving. The purpose of this essay is to analyse the relative response made by the police to crimes of domestic violence by examining the theories and statistics from the study of various criminology scholars as well as scrutinising the impact of any changes or improvement that may have since occurred in policing. The Government defines domestic violence (DV) as "Any incident of threatening behaviour, violence or abuse (psychological, physical, sexual, financial or emotional) between adults who are or have been intimate partners or family members, regardless of gender or sexuality." This includes issues of concern to black and minority ethnic (BME) communities such as so called 'honour killings' [homeoffice.gov.uk]. In analysing the adequacy of police response to domestic violence, it is vital to firstly understand the scale of abuse against victims of DV. Several statistics, such as Stanko’s study in the year 2000, found that police in the UK received one call every minute for support concerning domestic violence. According to Dodd et al (2004), only 40.2% of actual domestic violence crimes are reported to the police. Moreover, 20 incidents of DV may have occurred before it is reported [Walby and Myhill, 2000]. As of 2005, 17% of all reported crimes were of Domestic Violence (Nicholas et al). What's more, even though the concept of domestic violence is not targeted at a particular...

Words: 2918 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence a Cry for Help

...Domestic Violence a Cry for Help DeVry University Domestic Violence a Cry for Help Jan had finally succeeded in her goal of finding the perfect person, the person she could share the rest of her life with. He was strong, smart, and handsome and he had a great sense of humor. They were like two peas in a pod meant to be together. After six months of dating they decided to move in together. They started looking right away for a home that they could call their own. Within a week they found the perfect home and began moving in to start their life together. Once they were all moved in they decided to have a house warming party and invited all their friends to come share in their happiness. After the party, which did not end until 1 o’clock in the morning, Jan decided she would clean up in the morning it had been a long night all she wanted to do was go to bed. As Jan was walking to the bedroom, she felt this pull at the back of her head. It was the love of her life grabbing her by her hair and yelling at her that she was going to get the messed cleaned up before she does anything else. This is not an isolated incident. It happens to women not just in the U.S. but to women around the world. Domestic violence reaches to all parts of the world, 30 percent of women worldwide have experienced physical and/or sexual violence in their lifetime from an intimate partner (WHO 2013). Parents, teachers, and educators should pressure the government to pass legislative reform to make...

Words: 1986 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence Theory

...Domestic violence is a recognized worldwide problem that drastically affects the well-being of both the victims and abusers. Coker (2016) defines domestic violence as the violent abuse by one person against another at home. This form of abuse can entail intensive abuse of a spouse or partner or violence meted against children or elderly. Domestic violence takes several forms that range from physical, verbal, reproductive, and religious to sexual abuse among others. Given that social workers interact with people of different walks of life while executing their duties, chances of meeting victims of domestic violence are high (S. & Ilango, 2013; Littman & Paluck, 2015). Due to the prevalence of cases of domestic violence in society, it is emphatically...

Words: 1700 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Longitudinal Studies

...policies that address the intersection of domestic violence and substance abuse, ensuring that services are both available and accessible to those affected. The connection between substance use and domestic violence is a multifaceted issue that necessitates a comprehensive and informed approach from professionals. The intersection of substance abuse and domestic violence presents significant challenges and opportunities within the field of human services. Studies have shown a correlation between substance abuse and domestic violence, with substance abuse often exacerbating the severity of domestic violence. However, it is crucial to clarify that while they often occur together,...

Words: 1337 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Violence Against Women

...Domestic Violence/Abuse against Women Violence against women is a major issue around the world. A large part of that violence comes in the form of domestic violence/abuse. Domestic violence and violence against women as a whole are hard situations to define, Flowers explains how our definition of domestic violence is changing with our understanding: “With advances in understanding relationships and effect of behavior, the definition of the battered woman has broadened in recent years. The term now reflects not only physical abuse but also psychological and emotional abuse, thus indicating woman can be victimized by their mates in many ways” (Flowers, 1996). The Definition of domestic violence against women is a changing thing depending on what studies or journals you read. This leads to many different definitions, each created for their own studies and journals. Thus, we find inconsistencies in the data put out by domestic violence studies, some studies claiming 12 month prevalence ratings of 2.1% for woman while others claim 28% for total abuse against women and men (Hegarty and Roberts, 1998). We need a competent definition of domestic violence against women. In this paper I will give you what I think to be the most competent definition of domestic violence against woman and compare its rates to others. I found what I believe to be the most competent domestic violence/abuse definition in a study done by Hegaty and Roberts in 1998. The study was comprised of many other...

Words: 1838 - Pages: 8