Premium Essay

Howard Zinn's View On American History

Submitted By
Words 715
Pages 3
Howard Zinn’s unique perspective on American history and the beloved American hero makes for an interesting novel. His book, A People's History of the United States, paints history in a whole new light. While most teachers tell the story of the iconic Andrew Jackson and his role models, like Burren, being right in their actions, the other side is rarely looked at, as most believe their good outweighs the bad. Zinn believes that Jackson and Burren were American villains that tainted our history. He speaks of this in the seventh chapter of his book, which is also a Jackson quote, “As Long as a Grass Grows or Water Runs.” He uses other like-minded historians and historical events to support his claims. These claims are that the Indian was an obstacle …show more content…
His positions are very controversial, but with the many direct quotes by renowned historians it makes his point more accountable. Right off the bat, Zinn hits the reader with statistics. He uses a quote from historian Michael Rogin's book, Fathers and Children, which says, "In 1790, there were 3,900,000 Americans…By 1844, fewer than 30,000 were left.” This shows the sheer devastation that the American people caused in just 50 years. Numbers are an effective way to convey a point and Rogin demonstrates the unjust actions against the Indians with them. Later in the chapter, Rogin speaks about Jackson. He points out that through Jackson's selfish motives to acquire as much Indian Territory as possible, he was solely responsible for a vast majority of the inhumanity towards the natives. And he states that Jackson’s “friends and relatives received many of the patronage appointments-as Indian agents …[as he] practiced extensive bribery.” The negativity Rogin spread about the president helps supports Zinn's villainous opinion on Andrew Jackson's Indian removal policy. Another pivotal Historian towards Zinn's argument was Van Every. In his book, The Disinherited, he summarizes Indian removal and quotes, “In the long record of man’s inhumanity exile has wrung moans of anguish from many...Upon no people could it ever have fallen with a more shattering impact than upon the eastern Indians.” The quote supports

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Howard Zinn Analysis

...is it factual? Columbus’s discovery of the new world led to victory and havoc, even though these two words appropriately describe Columbus’s expedition, they still oppose one another. In history and life, there are always two sides to a story, two different perspectives of the same story. Therefore, there are two perspectives of Columbus’s voyage, one told by the American Pageant and one told by Howard Zinn in A People’s History of the United States , both of which in retrospect are entirely different on the way they betray Christopher Columbus. Howard Zinn’s ideology of Columbus as a villain is contradictory in nature to the American Pageant’s view of Columbus as a hero....

Words: 1184 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

A Patriot's History Versus a People's History

...A People’s History Versus A Patriot’s History Public consensus, similar to politics, varies greatly when it comes to American history, especially as it pertains to the classroom. Views about the content and historical interpretation included in history texts have reached a heightened polarization in recent years. This can be seen in the vast differences between the diatribes of Howard Zinn’s, A People’s History of the United States, and Larry Schweikart and Michael Allen’s, A Patriot’s History of the United States. While both books, prescribed by this introductory course into American History, cover many of the same topics, they clearly paint different pictures. I feel that any text seeking to represent a responsible survey of a subject, should strive to include a full range of views on a particular issue. There is no question that this requirement is fulfilled by the inclusion of both books. However, if one book would need to be selected over the other, my choice would be Schweikart and Allen’s. This is simply because I believe their book offers more facts and details surrounding the historical events in question. In an age where political perspective is often spoon-fed to us by dueling cablenews networks and political talk-radio shows, it is no wonder that our nation’s history is a hot topic for debate. A common perspective in conservative circles is that liberals seek to use the educational system to indoctrinate the nation’s youth. Although, a current issue in rebuttal...

Words: 1368 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Industrialization of the United States

...changed the way Americans produced goods, it also changed how Americans ran their lives and what the focus of society became. Besides these outcomes of the industrialization period, along with an increase in technology and production, there were other important side effects. The most important side effect of the industrialization period and topic of my paper that was mentioned in all three textbooks, was it’s effect on the relationship between social classes. This topic is a very important section, imbedded throughout Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States, George Brown Tindall and David Emory Shi’s America: A Narrative History, and Paul Johnson’s A History of the American People. First we must take a look at the personal views of these authors before looking at how they each analyzed the topic. Zinn has a radical, Marxist interpretation of early US history in which he believes the entire history of the United States was based off of conflict. This includes racial conflict, gender conflict, and in our case, class conflict. Tindall and Shi have, as most history books do, a liberal interpretation of early US history in which they believe the history of the United States is based on consensus and agreement of core values among Americans. They believe the US has a good future because of the agreement on these values which include freedom, democracy, capitalism, and equal opportunities. Johnson has a conservative interpretation of early US history in which he believes...

Words: 1880 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Strategic Bombing Analysis

...this taboo section of history, Zinn has paved the way for Americans to look back on their own history, and even modern-day events, and critically examine the truth that we accept so easily, without a second thought, especially since some events today and their justifications mirror similar events seen throughout history. The ongoing debate about drone strikes, their accuracy, and the ethics behind them closely mirror Zinn’s “Strategic Bombing” missions and their effects. While drones may be more accurate than the bombs used in World War II, their effectiveness is still called into question. In an article from the New York Times, it is revealed that “…when operators in...

Words: 584 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Summary Chapter 1 Summary Zinn

...journey. He chastises other historians for excluding and burying truths and lesser point of views. He exposes the cruelties the Indians went through, as well as the sailors crazed ambition for gold. The total control over the Indians brought complete cruelty and caused the Indian population to decrease immensely. Zinn includes the good and the bad of all the parties involves, allowing the reader to see clearly the actions of everyone involved. Chapter Two The desperate need for labor was one of the many factors that brought slavery to America. Zinn exposes the hardships the settlers went through as they failed to keep themselves fed and well. Zinn introduces the reader to the horrible treatments the slaves went through on the way to America and once there. The relationships between white servants and black slaves had a less violent presence within it, but racism materialized even more when “a law was passed requiring masters to provide white servants” more rights. This created an even more prominent color line. Chapter Three Zinn analyses the Bacon Rebellion and introduces the reader to Nathaniel Bacon, the leader. In that...

Words: 524 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Comparing Zinn And Paul Johnson's Views On Early American History

...Paul Johnson and Howard Zinn are both famous historians; however, they have different viewpoints on early American history. Paul Johnson, a right-wing activist, was born in England. Concerning early American history, Johnson strongly believes that colonization brought by Christopher Columbus was beneficial and vital for the economic, social, and political development of America. Howard Zinn, a left-wing activist, was born in New York City. Zinn believes that Columbus is not the hero that most people think. Zinn believes that the mass slaughter of Indians and colonization that Columbus brought greatly harmed America and the local Indians. My opinion is similar to Paul Johnson’s because I believe that Columbus’s voyage and discovery of America brought various positive impacts and helped shape the America today. Paul Johnson is convinced that Columbus’s voyage to America is the greatest of allhuman adventures. As a right-wing activist, Johnson supports the leaders of thegovernment and affluent...

Words: 680 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Essay Comparing Columbus And Mann

...is given about his arrival to the Americas, and much of the information that is given is incorrect or inaccurate. Howard Zinn's A People’s History and Charles C. Mann’s 1491 talk about the facts of the before and after of the voyages of Columbus and how they are misinterpreted. Zinn’s and Mann’s views of the Americas before and after Columbus compare to the traditional more vague notions, because they present the idea that the Native Americans were as advanced as the Europeans , and that Columbus and his men oppressed the natives soon after interacting with them. Both Zinn and Mann have written in their texts that before Columbus came into contact with the New World,...

Words: 902 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Response to Howard Zinn's Passionate Declarations

...19, 2013 The Status Quo In Howard Zinn’s book, Passionate Declarations: Essays on War and Justice, Chapter 1 entitled, “Introduction: American Ideology,” begins with a discussion of a few instances in history where groups of people believed that other races and social classes were inferior to others. The end result of these instances was that many, if not all, of the inferior people were killed. From these occurrences, Zinn concludes that our thinking does not merely spark debates, but ultimately is a variable of life and death. He also believes that although we live in a democratic country, the ideas of ethical behavior that were formulated by our forefathers has condemned us to accept them as right, without questioning why they are right. These American ideologies were not framed by a group of conspirators, nor were they accidental; these ideas were a result of natural selection in which ideas were encouraged, financed, and pushed forward by those who were in power or by those who had great influence on the general public. People who were in power pushed these ideologies because they wanted more control. If people were allowed to do and think as they pleased, they would end up having no control over the public. Although these beliefs were written off as correct, Zinn believes that if we decide to reexamine these beliefs, and see that they are not “natural” ideas, we have come to a major turning point: we are examining and confronting American ideology (Zinn 1-8). These ideas...

Words: 1003 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Absolute Objectivity

...In A People’s History of the United States, Howard Zinn provides some of the most useful correctives to the mindless American triumphalism of many textbooks. When I say “correctives” it might seem that I am implying the existence of absolute objectivity. I do not mean to. I am referring to relative objectivity. There are countless reasons why our peculiar little human vantage point gives us only a fragmentary and systematically distorted perspective on the world. We can see only about two octaves of the electromagnetic spectrum, which certainly extends to well beyond fifty. Similarly, the space and time scales we are aware of are a minuscule segment of the possible ones. Ours appears to be chiefly the result of the size of the earth, whose...

Words: 1588 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Howard Zinn: The Misguided Notion Of Patriotism

...Watch the two video clips "Zinn: The Misguided Notion of Patriotism" featuring Howard Zinn in "Howard Zinn: The Misguided Notion of Patriotism" in module # 12 "Critical Thinking and Mass Media Propaganda". Identify one main claim made by Howard Zinn in each of these two video clips and his supporting reason for the claim. Compare his views to those of Noam Chomsky in the clip "Anti-Americanism" in the same module page. Probe their claims and reasons with essential questions and justify your agreement or disagreement with them. (ANSWER) Essential Questions: What is beneficial for Americans to be aware of about World history? What does it mean to be...

Words: 2247 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Christopher Columbus

...Christopher Columbus: The Original American Hero? Was Columbus a hero or a villain? Maybe it’s neither. Columbus was brave and daring, and did things that were important to world history. But he wasn’t heroic in the sense of displaying great moral qualities. Courage, while generally a good character trait, isn’t necessarily heroic or even highly honorable and praiseworthy unless it’s deployed in certain kinds of actions or causes. But he also wasn’t especially villainous in the sense of displaying particular evil qualities. His arrival in the Americas caused a great deal of death to American Indians, chiefly from disease. And it caused the subjugation and literal or virtual enslavement of the Indians. But this didn’t stem from Columbus’s being an unusually evil person. It stemmed from the brutality of the time, coupled with the contact between one culture that was much more powerful than another (and that carried many communicable diseases to which members of the other culture lacked resistance). I’m inclined to say that we shouldn’t celebrate Columbus Day, precisely because such national celebrations should be focused on honoring people who did things that were both especially important and especially honorable (such as veterans, President Washington, or Martin Luther King, Jr.) and not just on people who did things that were especially important. This might conceivably include not-necessarily-good people who did things that were unambiguously good. But European expansion...

Words: 2988 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Notes

...help in your understanding of the Discussion Board task? * What approaches could have yielded additional valuable information in the students' networking? * What is still unclear after the discussion with your classmates that needs to be clarified? During week ones discussion board assignment, we discussed the different types of health insurance billing and reimbursement methods. This discussion board assignment required taking the time to research the history of health insurance and how it has evolved over the years to the system that we know it as today. By utilizing the discussion board portion of this class, I was able to learn many things from my classmates’ postings. I learned the many different methods of healthcare reimbursement that is still currently used today. I learned the history of health insurance, and why it was developed for the patients in the first place. I also learned many different views and opinions of my classmates that allowed me to reconsider and further educate myself on the views of the future of the healthcare industry. The most compelling points that I absorbed from reading my classmates postings was reading every ones ideas and opinions regarding the future of the healthcare insurance industry. It was interesting to me to learn the different aspects of the universal health care plan that is in motion right now that I never would have considered before this assignment. By participating in this discussion board...

Words: 13668 - Pages: 55

Free Essay

Frontline

...Communist split 89 FOOD SEC UR I T Y Understanding the PDS Kerala: Power of literacy Bihar: Coupon fiasco Jharkhand: Strong revival Chhattisgarh: Loud no to cash E CONOM Y Losing momentum Interview: C. Rangarajan, Chairman, PMEAC CL IM A TE C H A N G E Uncertain stand in Durban CONTR OV E R S Y Mullaperiyar dispute: Deep distrust Fallout of fear OBITU A R Y Humble genius: Mario Miranda Korea’s Kim Jong-il COL U M N Bhaskar Ghose: Looking back Praful Bidwai: Durban greenwash 96 98 101 104 106 RELA T ED S TOR I E S Language barrier 14 Poet of the Padma17 The other Tagore 22 Unique landlord 29 Man of science 37 110 112 114 120 124 129 132 83 94 W O RLD A F F A I RS The American occupation troops withdraw from Iraq after waging a ‘dumb...

Words: 77117 - Pages: 309

Premium Essay

Power of Logic

...Frances Howard-Snyder Daniel Howard-Snyder Ryan Wasserman WESTERN WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY Published by McGraw-Hill, an imprint of The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., 1221 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020. Copyright © 2009, 2005, 2002, 1999, by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in a database or retrieval system, without the prior written consent of The McGrawHill Companies, Inc., including, but not limited to, in any network or other electronic storage or transmission, or broadcast for distance learning. This book is printed on acid-free paper. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 DOC/DOC 0 9 8 ISBN: 978-0-07-340737-1 MHID: 0-07-340737-2 Editor in Chief: Michael Ryan Editorial Director: Beth Mejia Sponsoring Editor: Mark Georgiev Marketing Manager: Pamela Cooper Editorial Coordinator: Briana Porco Production Editors: Melissa Williams/Melanie Field, Strawberry Field Publishing Cover Designer: Ashley Bedell Cover Photo: © Dan Trist/Corbis Media Project Manager: Thomas Brierly Production Supervisor: Louis Swaim Composition: This text was set in 10.5/12.5 Goudy by Aptara, Inc. Printing: Printed on 45# New Era Matte by R.R. Donnelley & Sons, Inc. Credits: The credits section for this book is on page 647, following the Answer Key in the back of the book, and is considered an extension of the copyright page. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Howard-Snyder...

Words: 173379 - Pages: 694