Free Essay

Lateral Violence in the Workplace

In:

Submitted By lonaland
Words 1262
Pages 6
Lateral violence in the workplace
Lona A Smeltzer
Southern New Hampshire University

Lateral violence in the workplace Abstract
This paper explores five published articles as they relate to the concept of Lateral violence (LV) within the nursing profession and how it directly affects the work environment. The concept of LV is also known as abusive behavior, horizontal violence, bullying, aggression, horizontal hostility, verbal abuse or “nurses eating their young”. There are four main themes that appear throughout the five articles. The negative effects that LV has on nurses’ health, moral and sense of worth. The negative impact that LV has on patient care and outcome. The negative impact that LV has on the recruitment and retention of nurses by health care organizations. And who should be responsible for eliminating the phenomenon.
Within the articles there is a shared belief that strong leadership is needed to create codes of conduct and enforce zero-tolerance policies. Employees should be provided education and training on effective communication skills as well as conflict resolution. Furthermore nurses should hold themselves accountable through adopting and modeling professional ethical behaviors so that LV can be eradicated from the professional workplace.
Keywords: abusive behavior, lateral violence, horizontal violence, bullying, aggression, horizontal hostility, verbal abuse, nurse eating their young.

Thesis
Even though nursing is known as a caring profession, it is not uncommon to find Lateral violence (LV) within the field of nursing. Lateral violence is a negative phenomenon within the nursing profession therefor it is the responsibility of the organization, management, as well as the nursing professional to eradicate the behavior from within the workplace. Lateral violence behaviors are toxic to the nursing profession causing a negative impact on nurses' health, morale and self-esteem. Lateral violence has a negative impact on patient care and outcome. And LV has a negative impact on recruitment and retention (Rowe M. M. & Sherlock H, 2005, p. 243).

Introduction
Lateral violence has become an all too common negative phenomenon within the nursing profession and goes by many different names. According to Griffin (2004) lateral violence is also known as horizontal violence, bulling, or aggression. Griffin describes the manifestations of LV as non-verbal innuendo, verbal affront, under-mining activities, withholding information, sabotage, infighting, scapegoating, backstabbing, failure to respect privacy, and. Most commonly LV is made up of emotional or verbal abuse, However Longo & Sherman (2007) reports LV can become physical (as cited in Sheridan-Leos, 2008, p. 399). According to Lipley (2006) more than 50% of nurses reported being a victim of abuse at work, and more than 90% stated that they had witnessed abusive behavior in the workplace. And that workplace bullying among nurses is also reported to be on the rise (as cited in Olender-Russo, p. 75). According to Rowe & Sherlock (2005) the effects and consequences of verbal abuse can be devastating and long-lasting. They indicate research has focused on the consequences of verbal abuse and has determined that it is both physiologically and psychologically damaging. Furthermore Rowe & Sherlock state “Nurses who regularly experience [abuse] may be more stressed, may feel less satisfied with their jobs, may miss more work and may provide a substandard quality of care to patients”(Rowe & Sherlock, 2005). In fact healthcare literature according to Sauer (2012) suggests that significant numbers of nurses who are victimized by bullying will leave their jobs and may even leave the nursing profession within the first year of employment (Sauer, 2011). In fact LV according to Embree (2010) is the cause of approximately 60% of new nurses leaving their place of employment within the first 6 months (Embree & White, 2010).

There are many theories as to the origin of LV within the nursing profession. According to Roberts (1983) the most cited is the oppressed-group model. One theory behind the oppressed-group model according to DeMarco & Roberts (2003) is nurses perceive themselves as powerless, oppressed and dominated by others. From this perception arises the feelings of alienation and loss of control over ones practice. This in turn leads to a cycle of low self-esteem and feelings of powerlessness (as cited in Sheridan-Leos, 2008, p. 399). Sheridan-Leos (2008) further states that the oppressed nurse fears retaliation from those in leadership if the feelings of oppression are verbalized, causing further frustration. This frustration is then projected onto ones’ peers (Sheridan-Leos, 2008). An equally important theory discussed by Sauer (2012) supports the idea that an organization’s culture contributes to the prevalence of bullying. Sauer indicates some organizational factors that can increase or promote bullying are hierarchal management, restructuring or downsizing of the organization and employees who do not feel empowered (Sauer, 2012). This same belief is shared by Hutchinson, Vickers, Jackson & Wilkes (2006) they theorize organizations can be fully aware of bullying yet chose to focus on other priorities. They believe when leaders within an organization disregard the behavior they are aiding and abetting the very act itself (as cited in Olender-Russo, 2009, p. 76). Consequently Olender-Russo (2009) believes the targeted individual becomes a victim not just of the bully, but of the organization at large (Olender-Russo, 2009).
There is a cost factor to LV that must be recognized. For an organization it can be the loss of revenue related to complaints from patients and family members. Equally important the cost to nurses’ can be the loss of enthusiasm for the profession related to the extended exposure to LV. To illustrate this point Bland-Jones & Gates (2007) report recent studies estimate the economic cost of nurse turnover due to LV to be between $22,000 and $64,000 per nurse. Whereas Bartholomew (2006) describes the cost of LV on nurses can be low self-esteem, poor moral, the feeling of disconnect from other staff members, depression and excessive sick leave (Sheridan-Leos, 2008).
How do we eradicate this phenomenon called LV within the workplace? I believe organizations must first implement zero tolerance policies that address and enforce LV in the workplace. I believe management must make it a practice to investigate all cases of reported LV and discipline offenders according to policy. Furthermore I believe nurses must reflect on their own behavior and address LV behavior of others immediately. I believe Sauer (2012) makes an excellent point when she reminds us that a core principle of nursing is patient advocacy. She further states if nurses were to use these same principles to support colleagues and the profession against bullying, the negative behavior would stop (Sauer, 2011).
Who you ask should be responsible for eliminating LV in the workplace? The answer to this question as I have documented is multi-layered. I believe because LV is often inconspicuous throughout organizations, management and nursing all should adopt and model professional and ethical standards to facilitate the eradication of LV within the nursing profession.

References
Embree, J. L., & White, A. H. (2010). Concept Analysis: Nurse-to-Nurse Lateral Violence. Nursing Forum; Jul-Sep 2010; 45(3), 166-173.
Olender-Russo, L. (2009, November, 2). Creating a Culture of Regard: An Antidote for Workplace Bullying. Creative Nursing, 15(2), 75-81.
Rowe M. M. & Sherlock H. (2005). Stress and verbal abuse in nursing: do burned out nurses eat their young? Journal of Nursing Management, 13(13), 242-248.
Sauer, P. (2011, 12, November 2011). Do Nurses Eat Their Young? Truth and Consequences. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 38(1), 43-46.
Sheridan-Leos, N. (2008). Understanding Lateral Violence in Nursing. Clinical Journal of Oncology Nursing, 12(3), 399-403.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Lateral Violence Case Study

...Have you ever heard the phrase “old nurses eat their young”? This phrase was previously used in place of what is now called lateral violence. Lateral violence can also be called horizontal violence, or bullying, and it refers to the deliberate or harmful behavior presented in the workplace, between employees who handle the same level of responsibility (Christie & Jones, 2013). According to Christie & Jones (2013), senior nurses are culprits of initiating lateral violence towards novice nurses, which is very unfortunate because they are the future of nursing. “Studies estimate that 44% to 85% of nurses are victims of lateral violence and up to 93% of nurses’ reported witnessing lateral violence in the workplace” (Christie & Jones, 2013 p. 1) Lateral violence has resulted in “decreased sense of well-being, physical health complaints, sleep...

Words: 682 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Physician-Assisted Suicide: A Case Study

...to nurses as well. The concept of lateral violence or nurse bullying isn’t new. Purportedly, an article in The New York Times, published in 1909, noticed that head nurses abused their position in “the abominable outrages” and “outright persecution” against other nurses (Castronovo, Pillizzi, & Evans, 2015). This paper will explore modern day bullying behaviors, causes and impact and, more importantly, who is ultimately responsible for ending the cycle of violence. Given the entrenched nature of lateral violence, the change needed does not rest with one entity, but rather starts with nursing staff recognizing the offenders, continues on to nurse managers supporting their staff and recognizing the problem and ends with determined hospital administrators enforcing a zero-tolerance policy. Background Bullying occurs when a person, over time, becomes aware that they are enduring destructive or antagonistic behavior from one or more individuals, and the person bullied has a hard time guarding against the abuse. Three common indicators...

Words: 1002 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Incivility And Violence In Nursing

...what is truly happening, one need to understand what each of these terms mean. “Incivility is one or more rude, discourteous, or disrespectful actions that may or may not have a negative intent behind them” as stated by the American Nurse Association (2001). Examples of incivility in the nursing profession are as follows: (1) Not returning phone calls or e-mails (2) using inappropriate language such as profanity (3) saying negative things about people to coworkers (4) Spreading rumors or gossiping about a coworker behind their back. Jennifer Becher and Visovsky described horizontal violence as “hostile, aggressive, and harmful behavior by a nurse or group of nurses toward a coworker or group of nurses via attitudes, actions, words and/or behaviors” (2012). Other names for horizontal violence include but not limited to lateral violence, workplace incivility, interpersonal abuse, workplace violence, interpersonal conflict, and psychological...

Words: 1856 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

A Major Factor in the Nursing Shortage

...cited in Stevens, 2002), identified retention issues as being a major factor in the international nursing shortage. Stevens (2002), suggests that intimidation and the bullying of nurses by nurses and the management culture that dismisses it, as a major factor in retention of nurses. Stevens also suggests that intimidation is viewed as a minor annoyance, and how management improves the way in which this issue is addressed in nursing will be critical for the improvement of retention. Stevens reported that in a case study performed in an Australian teaching hospital found that the bullying culture was the main reason for nurses not wanting to stay at the hospital or in the nursing profession at all. Relationship to Nursing Workforce Trends Workplace bullying is prevalent in many organizations resulting in high turnovers, low productivity, and a negative organizational...

Words: 748 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Yoder-Wise Communication: Uncivility In The Workplace

...More often than not, incivility in the workplace (either external or internal) creates a tension-filled environment. The stress and negative energy generated from the detrimental behavior of even one colleague or patient can be contagious and exert its disruptive effect on the entire staff. Disruptions are often manifested in the splitting of staff, decreased communication and collaboration, lack of teamwork, low morale, and increased staff absenteeism and turnover (Yoder-Wise, 2015, p. 465). These disruptive factors lead to decreased efficiency, meaning more energy has to be expended to achieve the same productivity; subsequently, increasing the probability of mistakes/errors and putting the patient population at risk. Remarkably, Yoder-Wise...

Words: 622 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Disruptive Clinician Behavior and the Effect on Patient Outcomes

...Disruptive Clinician Behavior and the Effect on Patient Outcomes Abstract Hostility and disruptive behavior within healthcare facilities have been identified as factors that may contribute to poor patient outcomes. Studies have been conducted that have assessed bad behavior on the part of patients and patients’ families, but of more recent concern are disruptive behaviors by physicians and other healthcare workers. In an effort to reduce the frequency of these incidents of disruptive behavior mandates have been issued regarding the implementation of policies and procedures which specifically address disruptive behavior among healthcare workers. The aim of this paper is to review research relevant to frequency of disruptive behavior among healthcare workers, the effect of this type of behavior on clinical outcomes, and efforts to decrease its incidence. Disruptive Behavior is a Cause of Poor Patient Outcomes Disruptive behavior has been recently defined by the American Medical Association, and The Joint Commission now requires the facilities they accredit to create a plan to outline acceptable behaviors, unacceptable behaviors and how they will address the latter (Rosenstein & O’Daniel, 2005.) Members of the healthcare team should receive training in regards to an organization’s Code of Conduct. Causes of disruptive behavior may include a culture of power among physicians, a culture of oppression among nurses (especially female nurses when dealing with...

Words: 1748 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

None

...The term “Bully” is defined as a form of aggressive behavior manifested by the use of force or coercion to affect others (Citation?). It comes in different styles and degrees. It can happen during many stages of life and between cultures, sexes, and the list goes on. It occurs due to sexuality, size, color, creed and religion. It is in our schools, colleges, Universities and workplaces. I guess we can say the Bullying is not discriminatory. (This discussion needs to be more general, more objective, remove “us” and make declarative statements). Bullying today is a term well known and often referred to in conversations among old and young alike. What drives a person to be a bully? How did being bullied make you feel? Almost everyone would agree that there is no excuse for bullying. Why a person becomes a bully is not reason or excuse for the bad behavior. This paper will explore bullying by examining the causes and the effects of bullying behavior. Causes and Effects Bullying is seen in the television culture as an acceptable behavior. For example, bullying is expressed in television sitcoms such as “Big Bang Theory” where a group of friends that are employed by a university as scientists and engineers. These characters are considered “geeks” or “nerds” because, as adults, they like comic book action heroes, video gaming and have a high intellect. Society has chosen these names for these people who are a little different than their peers in their looks, likes and IQ. Often...

Words: 1154 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Stress in Nursing Practice

...Stress is a common occurrence in the workplace. In health care in particular, there are high levels of stress which can have a negative impact on the environment, the staff, and ultimately the patients. Nurses are subjected to a great deal of occupational stress which in turn impacts the quality of patient care. Occupational stress can be defined as, “the destructive physical and emotional response that occurs when the requirements of the job do not match the capabilities or desires of the employee” (Hall, 2004). The health care profession is unique in its ability to cause stress on its employees. Health care environments are fast-paced settings in which nurses and physicians are physically responsible for the well-being of other people (Hall, 2004). Nurses are held accountable to physicians, administrators, as well as patients and their families (Hughes & Clancy, 2009). They are continually being told what to do by multiple people who all have different goals and ideas, which can be very testing at times. A sample of ten RNs was interviewed from a University Hospital Level 1 Trauma Center about work-related stressors under normal working conditions (Hall, 2004). The top stressors identified among these nurses were: systems barriers to meeting patient needs, self-expectations, shortage of nurses, and colleague’s inexperience (Hall, 2004). All ten of the nurses identified lack of equipment and supplies needed to care for their patient’s as a major stressor. Another major source...

Words: 768 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Toxic Working Environments

...Toxic Working Environments: Recognizing Workplace Bullying   Aug 2, 2010 Andrew Mitchell A Bully's Tirade - bulagm Bullying affects workers that are usually at the "work unit" level. It occurs mostly when organizations support and reinforce its existence. Bullying in the workplace has a variety of labels, such as psychological harassment, emotional abuse and mobbing. Workplace bullying is characterized by:    intentional, repeated and enduring aggressive behaviors (most frequently verbal); intended to be hostile and/or perceived as hostile by the recipient; usually unpredictable, irrational, and unfair. Workplace bullying makes work an anxiety-ridden experience. No one wants to go where they've been chosen for target practice. A workplace prone to bullying is one where people do not respect or value the benefits of difference. There is usually an air of fear. Supervisors are typically without adequate training in managing people. Accountability structures are not properly defined. There is usually too much work and/or overly intense supervision. Performance appraisals are either too subjective or have little objectivity in criteria. Communication channels are unclear. The typical pattern of workplace bullying is when someone is genuinely going after a coworker. The bully singles out the coworker for abuse. Targets are usually good at their work, non-confrontational and/or unassertive. They may be friendly yet mind their own business and often are not members...

Words: 941 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Genius

...According to McShane and Von Glinow, “organization structure refers to the division of labor as well as patterns of coordination, communication, work flow, and formal power that direct organization activities” (2003, p. 446). The purposes of this memorandum are to identify and describe the formal organizational structure of the Smith & Falmouth (S & F) company. The S & F is a tele-shopping and mail order network that has operation in the United States and Canada. The memorandum also compares S & F’s structure with other organizational structures, analyze the effectiveness of the S & F organization’s informal culture with the formal structure. The memorandum also assesses the informal culture of the S & F’s company, determines its impacts on the formal structure, and discusses the role of power and politics within the organizational culture. In addition, the memorandum will demonstrate the power and politics within the S & F culture and recommend the most effective leadership style to Irene Seagrave, chief executive officer of the S & F.   In terms of labor and coordination, the formal structure of S & F was coordinated through informal communication under a formal hierarchy that included sharing information on the mutual task between the three managers and the chief executive operation. According to McShane and Von Glinow (2004), the Hierarchy assigns legitimate power to individuals for directing the work flow. In terms of elements of organizational structure, S & F was a flat...

Words: 2161 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Ineffective Communication

...Communication is a major component of the nursing profession. A problem that is common in the facility where I work is ineffective communication in the workplace. Ineffective communication in the nursing profession could potentially have a negative effect on nurses as well as the patients that are cared for on a daily basis. One example of ineffective communication that often comes to mind is in giving report from one unit to another. It is imperative to give a clear, concise report on your patient to others that may be involved in their care. So many times, when a patient is being transferred, report is called and given to one nurse. Many times the nurse who receives the report may not even be the nurse who will be caring for the patient. When this occurs, it is extremely easy for orders to be misunderstood, important parts of the patient’s history to be missed and allergies that are miscommunicated. Each of these points could end in a potentially life threatening situation for the patient. Ineffective communication can easily be contributed to by the workload of the nurses and physicians, the lack of time a nurse has to do his or her job and interruptions during the course of the shift. When these specific factors arise, the communication between physician and nurse as well as between nurse and patient begins to be burdened. When communication is burdened, patients ultimately lose. Certain orders do not get ordered, certain medications are not given, and patient...

Words: 1047 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Consensual Relationships

...Because men and women are visual beings, physical attraction is an occurrence that happens naturally. It is difficult to avoid the varying levels of interaction between male and female counterparts within the workplace. Trying to manage human nature and the evolution of interpersonal relationships at work have a positive and negative effect on all parties involved; directly and indirectly. Relationships in general are emotional roller coasters therefore anyone choosing to engage in romance in the workplace must be made aware that they are taking a gamble. Consequently, employers attempting to permit these interactions will also be taking a risk. Implementing a Consensual Relationship Agreement (CRA) may be beneficial with forming workplace boundaries and aid in the facilitation of continuity and maintenance of workplace efficiencies when these types of relationships exist. CRAs are virtually “love contracts” which implement guidelines and agreements between employer and employee regarding the handling of workplace romantic interactions. This type of agreement constitutes the relationship as consensual between individual adults, requires the parties to attest to the fact that it will not hinder the job performance of either individual, in the event the relationship is short lived it identifies the potential consequences of any irreconcilable differences resulting from the romantic relationship, and holds the employer harmless and releases the employer from liability of any negative...

Words: 1605 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

January 26

...Employee HANDBOOK PHILIPPINES Welcome to STARTEK Welcome Brand Warrior! Thank you for joining the STARTEK family. Our mission is to enable and empower you to successfully promote and defend our clients’ brands. Our focus is on ensuring that you are successful in your new position. You are now a Brand Warrior ready to empathize with your customers and fellow employees and take ownership to solve the customer’s issue. You have been hired because you have the determination, enthusiasm and passion for excellence. This handbook was developed to describe the expectations we have for our employees. It also outlines the policies, programs, and benefits available to eligible employees. I strongly encourage you to familiarize yourself with the contents of this employee handbook as soon as possible as it will answer many questions about employment with STARTEK. We are in the business of helping people through our interactions with them. We impact lives one conversation at a time every single day. Enjoy your experiences at STARTEK and know that all of us are here to help and be sure to have fun! Chad Carlson President & Chief Executive Officer Welcome to STARTEK Welcome Brand Warrior! I feel it’s a great honor to welcome to the STARTEK family our newest Brand Warriors. At STARTEK, being a Brand Warrior is an opportunity to make a difference. You’ll find the STARTEK team consists of talented individuals working together to create a winning team. The ONE TEAM ...

Words: 41887 - Pages: 168

Premium Essay

A Particular Car Manufacturer

...OB & HRM ASSIGNMENT 2 Summary Report for: Sales Associate Sell merchandise, such as furniture, motor vehicles, appliances, or apparel to consumers and also ringing up to your purchases. Education & Experience required | Goals and Objectives of position | Knowledge & Skills| Physical Requirements | Special Problems & Hazards| Work Styles | Major responsibilities of the job & Percentage |Factors responsible for successful Performance | Analysis of Physical abilities | Job Description | Personal and professional development goals | Date for next Development meeting | Wages | Additional Notes| Education & Experience required: Graduation/ High School Diploma 1 year work experience in similar field Goals and Objectives of position: Goal to develop new ideas for improvement of sales, try to keep respective company Ahead of others. Improve sales of the company enabling the rate of production of Particular product and hence making the company grow. | Knowledge and Skills: Sales and Marketing: Should have Knowledge of principles and methods for showing, promoting, and selling products or services. This includes marketing strategy and tactics, product demonstration, sales techniques, and sales control systems. Customer and Personal Service: Knowledge for providing customer and personal services. This includes customer needs assessment, meeting quality standards for services for customer satisfaction. English Language: Knowledge...

Words: 1193 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Heroin Addiction

...Proceed with the Weed Today in the United States there are twenty four states, three states are still pending to the next step, that have legalized marijuana for medicinal purposes only, for Washington and Colorado they have legalized it for recreational use (ProCon.org). There is a tremendous problem with marijuana in today’s society; people get arrested every day for this so called “crime.” This to most states is no longer a crime, being that most states are just starting to de-criminalize marijuana instead of legalizing marijuana. De-criminalization is not the same as legalization. De-criminalization determines whether or not someone should be taken to jail or not, all depending on the amount of marijuana they have on them. “De-criminalization means that a state repealed or amended its laws to make certain acts criminal, but no longer subject to prosecution. In the marijuana context, this means individuals caught with small amounts of marijuana for personal consumption won’t be prosecuted and won’t subsequently receive a criminal record or a jail sentence. In many states, possession of small amounts of marijuana is treated like a minor traffic violation” (Reuters). Marijuana should be legalized throughout the whole United States for three major reasons: money for the government, dropping crime rate, and medical conditions. Marijuana can be used as a medicine for the sick and for people with chronic pain issues or even anxiety. With the legalization of marijuana our...

Words: 1005 - Pages: 5