Free Essay

Low Levels of Participation

In:

Submitted By ulpan
Words 1538
Pages 7
Some people claim that the rice in the quantity of passive political participation is forming democratic crisis in Britain. The main purpose of this essay is to explore the problem of low levels of participation and its connection with crisis of democracy. Firstly, it will highlight the role of parliament. Secondly, it will evaluate drawbacks and benefits of election systems and the devolution. Thirdly, it will illustrate the roles of political parties and low results of participation in elections.
Possibilities for and trends of becoming participated in the political process by people is political participation. Generally, political participation contains a number of points such as awareness of current issues, supporting online forums, taking part in all kinds of elections, standing for political office, joining and becoming active in pressure group and political party and participating in physical and e-petitions (McNaughton: 2012). Vlassopoulos (2009:29) mentions that direct popular participation in making decisions is the vital aspect in definition of democracy.
One of the main functions of Parliament is representation. This means that elected MPs should represent and defend the interests of their voters. However, in real life citizens have no significant impact on the activities of legislators. Another important function is that it is the origin of political authority and exercising of power is impossible without Parliament’s sanction. Furthermore, the UK government membership depends on it: the members have to be from the House of Lords or House of Commons. McNaughton (2012:65) says the Blair government created variety of reforms for House of Lords and House of Commons after election in 1997. It included changes in organization of Prime Minister’s Question Time; Prime Minister’s rights; number of hereditary peers (it was reduced to 92 people), life peers (527 people), bishops and archbishops (26 people) (Lynch:2013:26). In addition, another reform was about becoming more democratic and representative. In 2000 there was created the independent House of Lords Appointments Commission for recommending and approving appropriate candidates for membership.

Lynch (2013:21) notes that, the system, used for general elections in Britain, is plurality system (the first-past-the-post). According to this system, the elected one become the candidate, who receives the absolute majority of the votes. The candidate must pay £500 as a deposit, which will be refundable, if participant gets more than 5% of the voice cast. It provides a limit amount of candidates. One of the advantages of this system is acting simply and understandably. The results are clear and also, it leads to majority seats, belonged to one party, which can avoid forming of coalition government. However, there are some drawbacks of this system, such as the fact that most of electorate usually vote against the winner. Secondly, the small amount of people could be represented by the government. Thirdly, sometimes even if most of the voters vote for one party, the other party will receive majority of seats and will win the election. Furthermore, the voters have only one choice: it is impossible for them to vote against the particular party, that they dislike.

Held (1991:175) notes that the proportional representation involves voting by party lists. After the election, each party gets a number of seats, proportionally to the number of votes’ percentage. Proportional representation gives more opportunity to elect representatives of various minorities. When the electoral behaviour corresponds cultural or social stratification of society, the system of proportional representation can ensure that in the legislature were representatives from both the majority and the minority. This is because of the fact, that the proportional representation encourages the party to the preparation of balanced lists that focus on the full range of interests of voters. For example, in 1983 the Conservatives needed only 35000 votes for one MP, while Liberal Democratic needed more than 300000 votes. This issue would not have happened, using this system. However, weak links between elected representatives and their constituencies. The system was criticized for destroying the connection between voters and their representatives. By using closed lists, voters are unable to establish the identity of the people, who represent them.

A referendum is a form of direct citizen participation, expressed in voting in the most important matters of national, regional or local scale. Devolution is the delegation of power from the government to the authorities of the administrative-territorial units. The government retains ownership of the main directions of policy and legislation in all areas. It might happened in 1979 for Scotland and Wales: when Prime Minister James Callaghan accepted realization of referendum there. In the contrary to Scotland, in Wales, people did not support it and, according to government, votes for devolution were less than 40%. This situation demonstrates that government would not allow this happened, if it was not sure that the devolution would not win. Consequently, this situation undermined people trust to referendums. In Scotland, there was a referendum on independence. It passed a record with high voter turnout - 84.5% (voted 4,283,392 people). According to BBC, after counting all 32 polling stations, it was found that for the separation of Scotland from the UK voted only 44.7% (1,617,989) of participants and against was 55.3% (2,001,926).

In general, parliamentary parties are organised institutions, which want to achieve political power through general elections, to form a part of a government or to influence a government via their position in the Legislature. In present political conditions, the parties, such as Conservative and Labour, have more possibilities in winning general election. There are also some third political parties, such as the Green Party, the UK Independence Party and Scottish National Party. In the last 20 years, the increasing numbers of Green Party candidates have elected to local councils and to the European Parliament. Moreover, in the last by-election the Labour party has retained its place in the British Parliament, having won more elections in Heywood and Middleton. Labour won, receiving 11 633 thousand votes, while the UK Independence Party (UKIP) surprisingly took second place with 16 11 thousand votes (almost 39%). It is considered one of the best results for the last time. While the Conservative party gained the third place and received only 3496 votes in this constituency. Furthermore, some members of this party have left and joined UKIP (Douglas Carswell).

Cohen (1994:169) states that one of the main roles of political parties is encouragement and incitement democratic participation, but party membership has been diminishing. McNaughton (2012:30) notices that the membership of total electorate decreased from 4.12% to 0.95% in 28 years. Another indication of declining participation is a sharper fall of membership in the British Conservative Party, which usually has had high level of participation. Furthermore, there has been a process, called “patrician dealignment”, where voters no longer associate themselves with a particular party. Thus, significantly smaller amount of people are taking part in political parties and even less are interested in politics of party. However, British participatory democracy is not in deplorable state, even if traditional involvement in political party has decreased. People, who do not want to use parties in representing their concerns, take part in politics independently by strikes and protests. Moreover, pressure groups are completely taking part in process of democracy. In addition, there are four types of voters: intelligent, apathetic, disaffected and media-driven. Disaffected and apathetic voters are usually a youth, who does not find a reason in participation or even the difference in political parties. Intelligent voters are always aware of events, occurring in politics of the country. For example, some of them did not vote, due to the awareness of results in election of 2001: they knew, that the Labour would win. Media-driven voters do not know about elections until is advertised.

In conclusion, democracy in UK is not in decline, but it is in crisis. Firstly, because turnouts in elections and membership of political parties could not simply be the main indicators of political activity. Other forms of political expression are increasing, such as activities of pressure groups (Greenpeace) or strikes. Secondly, large regional variation is disguised by overall figure. Moreover, the levels of participation in other forms of elections are considerably lower, than in general elections. In addition, this problem could be solved by adding postal voting, text voting and e-mail voting. There are some types of voters, who could understand and consider, if this election is important and could decide not to vote due to the obvious results. Others could not be bothered, because of the lack of knowledge about political parties. However, the government, which was elected with small number of turnout, does not have the same degree of legality, as if the turnout was higher.

Reference list 1) Cohen J. and Arato A.; 1994; Civil Society and Political Theory; First MIT Press paperback edn; USA: MIT Press; 2) Held D.; 1991; Political Theory Today; the 1st edn; UK: Polity Press; 3) Lynch P. and Fairclough P.; 2013; AS UK Government and Politics; 4th edn; UK: Philip Allan Updates; 4) McNaughton, N.; 2012; Edexcel Government and Politics for AS; 4th edn;, UK: Hodder Education. 5) Vlassopoulos K.; 2009; Politics atiqvity and its legacy; Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

G/P Essex

...to non-electoral political participation. Traditionally, the political participation of the UK’s citizens is measured by turnout to general elections. For example, in 2005 turnout to the general election was just 60%. This was seen to be a participation crisis by some. This extract would argue that casting a ballot is only part of a person’s political participation. It shows that 62% of people had given money to an organization in the previous 12 months. Also, 50% of people had signed a petition. This suggests individuals choose their involvement in politics in their own way and generalizing that if general election turnout is low, political participation is low is incorrect. This is supported by the POWER report in 2006 that suggested there is not a political participation crisis as there is still involvement on a local level. This suggests that political participation should not just be judged on turnout for general elections but also other acts of political participation. Using your own knowledge as well as the extract, consider why some commentators have spoken of a ‘participation crisis’ in recent years. In recent general elections, declining levels of turnout have led some to believe Britain is having a participation crisis. Meaning, political participation is so low it threatens to undermine Britain’s democracy. In the 2005 general election just 60% of registered voters cast a ballot and this increased slightly in 2010 to 65%. Low levels of turnout cause numerous problems...

Words: 315 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Essay : to What Extent Does Democracy in the Uk Suffer from a ‘Participation Crisis’?

...Essay : To what extent does democracy in the UK suffer from a ‘participation crisis’? Political participation is defined as opportunities for and tendencies of the people to become involved in the political process. At a minimum level this will involve voting, but may also involve active work in political parties and pressure groups. At the higher/highest level it implies standing for public office. However with regards to the United Kingdom suffering from a participation crisis, I would like to agree. Simply because, there has been a low turnout at general elections, which undermines the mandate of the government and threatens the idea that the UK is a representative democracy. Between 1922 and 1997 turnout remained above 71%. At the 2001 general election the turnout was59.4%; in 2005 it was 61.4%; in 2010 it was 65.1%; and in 2015 it was66.1%. Various people may consider the minor increase in percentage but overall there has not been a significant increase. Key forms of participation, such as voting and party membership have declined significantly over time, but other newer, faster forms have arisen and are slowly becoming more popular to the newer generations such as Referendums, particularly in Scotland. Popular engagement with the formal processes and institutions of democracy has been in long – term decline since the 1960’s. The turnout in 2001 was the lowest; this is compared to how between 1945 and 1992 it was always about 75 percent. Through this, it can be seen that...

Words: 1334 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

June 2011

...to non-electoral political participation. Traditionally, the political participation of the UK’s citizens is measured by turnout to general elections. For example, in 2005 turnout to the general election was just 60%. This was seen to be a participation crisis by some. This extract would argue that casting a ballot is only part of a person’s political participation. It shows that 62% of people had given money to an organization in the previous 12 months. Also, 50% of people had signed a petition. This suggests individuals choose their involvement in politics in their own way and generalizing that if general election turnout is low, political participation is low is incorrect. This is supported by the POWER report in 2006 that suggested there is not a political participation crisis as there is still involvement on a local level. This suggests that political participation should not just be judged on turnout for general elections but also other acts of political participation. Using your own knowledge as well as the extract, consider why some commentators have spoken of a ‘participation crisis’ in recent years. In recent general elections, declining levels of turnout have led some to believe Britain is having a participation crisis. Meaning, political participation is so low it threatens to undermine Britain’s democracy. In the 2005 general election just 60% of registered voters cast a ballot and this increased slightly in 2010 to 65%. Low levels of turnout cause numerous problems...

Words: 1720 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mark Scheme

...1 Participation and Voting Behaviour Total for this topic: 40 marks (01) Explain the term turnout used in the extract. (5 marks) It is likely that the majority of candidates will define turnout as a measure of the number or proportion of people who vote at an election. Higher-level responses are likely to provide a more authoritative definition: ie the proportion of registered voters who cast a ballot at a given election, expressed as a percentage. Candidates may pick up on the reference in the extract (ie by identifying electoral turnout as one measure of political participation). At the higher levels of response, it is likely that candidates will look to develop their answers by introducing material from their own knowledge. Some may refer to varying levels of turnout witnessed at different types of elections or introduce the notion of differential turnout in a single electoral cycle, with top-level responses supporting such points with statistical evidence. It is likely that many candidates will also make reference to the relatively low levels of electoral turnout witnessed at some recent general elections (most famously in 2001) and such knowledge is obviously creditable here. (02) Using your own knowledge as well as the extract, consider why some commentators have spoken of a ‘participation crisis’ in recent years. (10 marks) The focus here is the issue of why commentators have spoken of a participation crisis, as opposed to the question of...

Words: 537 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Importance of Voting

...and Elections in Texas (chapter 21), Public Opinion (chapter 6), and Political Participation and Voting (chapter 8) to be the most interesting and informative. Parties and Elections in Texas Political parties play a major role in Texas politics. Approximately 91 percent of Texas voters either identify with or lean toward the Republican or the Democratic Party. Despite all of the complaints about parties, they perform roles that are critical to the operation of our democratic system and to the overall coordination and functioning of our political system. The most important function of parties in Texas is to provide a label under which candidates may run and voter may identify. The party label becomes the standard used in casting a ballot for a candidate. Parties recruit candidates, assist in getting out the vote, and helps to organize the government once officials have been elected. The organization of political parties in Texas can be somewhat complex. Texas does not have a system of party registration for voters. Texas parties conduct primaries to select each party’s candidates for office. The precinct chair heads the precinct convention and serves on the county executive committee. The county executive committee is responsible for running the county’s primary elections and planning the county convention. Conventions are held at the precinct, county, and state levels. Participation in Texas elections has changed over time. Texas has had a...

Words: 1112 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

The Fit Between Technology and Structure as a Predictor of Performance in Nursing Sub-Units

...[Introduction] Since a very long time, many researches are being done to observe the organizational behaviour, all having a more or less common motto – “Optimization of performance”. Effectiveness and efficiency are the most important factors to determine the company’s performance. In present day views, the fit between the technology and structure has become the focus of the discussion where as earlier theories used to have a different focal point. This study is more about regularizing the analysis level to each organization and measurement of contingency relationship between technology and structure. Studies which considered large units led to more enigma than studies which considered smaller sub-units. The research paper concentrates on highlighting the link between technology and structure; and how they can be utilized to improve the performance of an organization. The central disagreement revolves around the theory that instead of technology or structure or technology and structure, a fit between both the structure and technology is a better measurement of performance. One of authors Judith W.Alexander served as an assistant professor in college of nursing, University of South Carolina, the other author W. Alan Randolph is a professor of International business and leadership. They present the argument that performance can be better studied in sub-units than in large units(organization), considering the fact the factors influencing the performance would affect...

Words: 1992 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Water Resources Utilization in Ethiopia

...AN ASSESSMENT OF COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION IN THE MANAGEMENT OF PRIMARY SCHOOLS OF WAG HIMRA ZONE BY MELSEW TEFERA MEKONEN A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES OF ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS IN EDUCATIONAL PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT JUNE 2005 ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES An Assessment of Community Participation in the Management of Primary Schools of Wag Himra Zone By MELSEW TEFERA MEKONEN JUNE 2005 ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES AN ASSESSMENT OF COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION IN THE MANAGEMENT OF PRIMARY SCHOOLS OF WAG HIMRA ZONE BY MELSEW TEFERA MEKONEN APPROVAL OF BOARD OF EXAMINERS ATO GIRMAY BERHE ________________ Chairman, Department Graduate Committee Signature Ato AYALEW SHIBESHI (Assoc. Pro.) ______________ Advisor Signature Ato MELAKU _YIMAM _________________ Examiner, Internal Signature Ato GETACHEW YOSEPH _________________ Examiner, External Signature Acknowledgement First of all, my praise is to God and Virgin Marry for helping me to pass all the hard moments and reach this level. My greatest and heartfelt thanks go to my thesis advisor Ato Ayalew Shibeshi (Asso. Prof.) for his unreserved scholarly comments and technical advice. Without him, this study would not have been...

Words: 29649 - Pages: 119

Free Essay

Roscommon Sports Partnership

...to co-ordinate and promote the development of sport and physical activity at local level. The initiative was created following widespread consultation with other agencies and organisations with an interest in the development of sport. The objectives of the program are to: 1. Enhanced planning of sport at local level. 2. Increased levels of local participation, especially amongst specific target groups such as older people, girls and women, people with disabilities, unemployed people and those who live in identified disadvantaged communities. 3. Enhanced local coach deployment. 4. Club development. 5. Volunteer training. 6. Local directories of sports bodies and facilities. 7. Better use of existing facilities. 8. Clear priorities for local facility provision and improvement, with related quality management initiatives. 9. School/club/community. 10. Local sports event. Roscommon Sports Partnership focuses on the following Strategic Aims for 2012-2014: 1. Participation Pathways: To increase participation in Sports/Physical Activity for all of the citizens of County Roscommon through their life stages. 2. Training & Development: To promote Training & Development, both for all involved in Sports/Physical Activity and their clubs throughout County Roscommon. 3. Communications: To increase good methods of Communications, at all levels, throughout County Roscommon. 4. Effective Operations: To promote effective Operational...

Words: 1333 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

An Assessment of Women Participation in Farm Household Income: a Study in Some Selected Areas of Mymensingh District of Bangladesh

...IRJALS (2013) Vol. 02 Issue. 04 Article No. 03 Full length Original Research Paper An assessment of women participation in farm household income: a study in some selected areas of Mymensingh district of Bangladesh S. Parveen1, M. R. Hossain1*, A. K. M. G. Kausar2, M. M. A. Shibli1, M. M. Rahhan3 and J. U. Ahmed4 1 Former 2 Former M.S. Students, Dept. of Agricultural Economics, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh M.S. Student, Dept. of Agribusiness and Marketing, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh 3 Former Student, Faculty of Agricultural Economics and Rural Sociology, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh 4Associate professor, Dept. of Agricultural Economics and Policy, Sylhet Agricultural University, Sylhet, Bangladesh *Corresponding authors e-mail: bestboyisrajib@gmail.com Article History Received: 4.8.2013 Accepted: 31.8.2013 Published: 15.11.2013 Key words: Women empowerment, Household income, Gender role ABSTRACT The present study attempted to make visible the participation of rural women in farm activities, their contribution in generating household income and decision making power. The study was conducted in two villages namely Monkanda and Char Shahpur under Fulpur upazila of Mymensingh district. A total of 60 sample farmers (20 small, 20 medium, 20 large farmers) were selected by using stratified random sampling method. A pre-tested interview schedule used to collect data from respondents...

Words: 4617 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Insurance Sector Papers Review

...prompted studies to identify what are the important and significant variables that attract FDI in insurance. There have been many papers published that study the factors that lead to participation of in international insurers in a country’s insurance sector. A study by (Li & Moshirian, 2004) of the US insurance services for the period 1984-1998 tries to identify factors that increases the desirability for FDI in insurance. The major factors that this study identifies are national income, relative cost of capital, relative wage rate, total trade in insurance services, exchange rate volatility, FDI in banking, source country’s insurance market size and the financial development of the host country. Other studies that intend to find determinants that attract foreign participation in insurance market include study by (Ma & Pope, 2003) .The study reveals that major foreign market characteristics that determine international insurers participation are market structure , the trade barriers in the country and the GDP. The study further states that in countries that don’t have competitive markets can improve their desirability by lowering trade barriers. Further study by the same authors (Ma & Pope, 2008) reiterates that market structure is an important determinant of foreign insurer participation. It states that foreign insurers disdain...

Words: 1072 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Inequality In Dental Care

...care coverage offered for low-income populations is a health disparity, and the affected populations will face many challenges for accessing dental care (MacDougall, 2016). About two-thirds of Americans request care from a dentist regularly (Waldman & Perlman, 2002; Waldman & Truhlar, 2010). In 2013, Kaiser Family Foundation found that more than 35 percent of poor families were uninsured. (Majerol et al., 2014) As with many issues of health inequality...

Words: 448 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Entrepreneurship

...Women In Entrepreneurship The Entrepreneurial Advantage Of Nations: First Annual Global Entrepreneurship Symposium United Nations Headquarters April 29, 2003 Maria Minniti, Ph.D. Pia Arenius 1 WOMEN IN ENTREPRENEURSHIP Maria Minniti, Ph.D. Babson College minniti@babson.edu Pia Arenius Helsinki University of Technology pia.arenius@hut.fi In 1999 the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) program was initiated by Babson College and London Business School with sponsorship from the Kauffman Foundation to: • • • • Measure differences in the level of entrepreneurial activity between countries. Probe for a systematic relationship between entrepreneurship and national economic growth. Uncover factors that lead to higher level so of entrepreneurship. Suggest policies that may enhance the national level of entrepreneurial activity. Data were assembled for each participating country from four basic sources: 1) surveys of over a hundred thousand adults; 2) in-depth interviews with almost a thousand national experts on entrepreneurship; 3) standardized questionnaires completed by the national experts, and 4) a wide selection of standardized national data from such sources as the World Bank, International Monetary Fund, United Nations and the like. The 37 countries participating in 2002 provides a truly global assessment of these issues. The Kauffman Foundation and the Business Council for the United Nations recently convened the first international policy discussion related...

Words: 2163 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Socialization: Social Influences, Political Parties, And Mass Media

...reinforced throughout their lives. Common agents that have an effect on a person’s political socialization are family, peers, religious influences, political parties, and mass media. There are two distinctive levels of political socialization. There is a primary level which is the subliminal influence (unconscious), and there is the secondary level which is the more formal influences (conscious). The primary level is socialization through family, peers, and social groups. A person is actually unaware that they are being conditioned to think in a particular way...

Words: 788 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

India’s Labour Market

...areas, with urban areas showing greater unemployment in numbers, possibly due to inadequate employment planning in urban areas. Also, low Labour Force Participation Rate (LFPR) in both rural and urban economies for the age group 18-29 is also a trend that causes concern. These are areas are critical since they indicate (a) degree of growth in number of jobs in both rural and urban areas, and, (b) employability of youth in the prime working age group A critical perspective on the trend The number of unemployed people in India remains relatively high, with an average unemployment rate of 4.7% by UPS approach. The UPS measure includes, in the definition of employment and workforce, both principal and subsidiary status activities. This measure, therefore, includes not just regular employment, but also employment in the unorganized sector. We should expect that improvements in principal status employment or household well-being can and should lead to reductions in subsidiary employment. The absence of individuals from each group is for different reasons and has different social implications. For the population under the age of 24, the low participation in the workforce may be attributed to their attending school. This feature, though sharp in both males and females between the ages of 14-19, reflecting a rapid narrowing of the gender gap till the level of secondary education. Among rural males, a similar pattern is observed, except in the 25-29 age group, which may be attributed...

Words: 636 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Equity and Equality in Education

...Approaches to Equity in Policy for Lifelong Learning Ben Levin1 A paper commissioned by the Education and Training Policy Division, OECD, for the Equity in Education Thematic Review August 2003 EQUITY IN EDUCATION The opinions expressed in this paper are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the OECD or of the governments of its Member countries. 1 . Ben Levin, Ph D, The University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada. TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS................................................................................................................................ 2 APPROACHES TO EQUITY IN POLICY FOR LIFELONG LEARNING ................................................. 3 Origins of this report ................................................................................................................................... 3 Summary of the report................................................................................................................................. 3 PART 1 – THINKING ABOUT EQUITY IN LIFELONG LEARNING ...................................................... 5 A definition of equity? ................................................................................................................................ 5 The importance of equity ............................................................................................................................ 5 Current status of equity...

Words: 23530 - Pages: 95