Premium Essay

Vietnam War Source Analysis

Submitted By
Words 1834
Pages 8
IDENTIFICATION AND EVALUTAION OF SOURCES

The focused question of this internal assessment will be “ To what extent was U.S. military strategy in Vietnam effective?” and will will analyze the extent of how useful military strategies used by the U.S. was in the rural country of Vietnam. The United States first arrived in Vietnam region during the mid 20th century with a main focus of stopping the spread of communism. The U.S.’s wish to stop communism stemmed from the fear that it may spread to their country where democratic values are held high. With the determination to stop communism, the U.S. immediately backed South Vietnam in the fight against the communist North Vietnam, which became the longest war in U.S. history until the Afghan War …show more content…
The source focuses on how the Viet Cong got around the military attacks of the U.S. and problems that the U.S. occurred in Vietnam leading to a defeat. This document is a secondary source written in 2014 by an author name Alan Rohn published on the website, thevietnamwar.info. The purpose of this source is to present a simple and general informing document about how US tactics were ineffective during the Vietnam War, resulting in a defeat for the U.S.. The value of this source is the direct reference to U.S. operations and presidential decisions surrounding the Vietnam War, presenting clear information historians can use to further evaluate how U.S. tactics failed specifically in military operations and politically. However information within the document is mainly negative surrounding the topic of why the U.S. failed militarily, thus rendering it hard for historians to evaluate what succeeded against North …show more content…
Ten years after the start of the Vietnam War, President Johnson approved Operation Rolling Thunder on the 13th of February under the intention of pressuring the North Vietnamese government to end their support for the fighting group called the “Viet Cong” which were a party of communist guerrilla fighters who acted against the South Vietnamese government with help from North Vietnam and their allies. The hundreds of thousands of tons of American bombs dropped into action to stop supplies from entering South Vietnam from the North Vietnamese government, which were used to strengthen the Viet Cong’s fight against the U.S.. Although Operation Rolling Thunder was helpful for the U.S. in theory, the North Vietnamese and it’s allied forces were able to cause more damage to the U.S. in destroyed bombs and aircraft than damage inflicted to North Vietnam. According to Alan Rohn, “Heavy bombing... were used to clear out thick jungle areas & destroy the Ho Chi Minh Trail with little [effect because] Viet Cong[’s] use of underground tunnels & ambush tactics”, the use of underground tunnels rendered any type of bomb used by the U.S. useless. The U.S. spent millions of dollars on the bombs used in their

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

My Lai Massacre Analysis

...Annotated Bibliography Explorations: The Vietnam War as History (2016), Digital History, retrieved from www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/active_learning/explorations/vietnam/vietnam_mylai.cfm This site contains digital links to first hand testimony of individuals involved in addition to detailed chronology of events, and insight to rules of engagement criteria, known as the “nine rules”. The firsthand accounts will be used to detail events, and additional information will be used to cross check facts from other sources. Major Addicott, Jeffrey F., Major Hudson, William A. (1993) The Twenty-Fifth Anniversary of My Lai: A Time to Inculcate the Lessons Learned. Military law review-Volume 139 Major Addicott was a member of the Judge Advocate General Corps, assigned to International and Operational Law Division, Office of the Judge Advocate General of the US Army. Major Hudson was a member of the Judge Advocate General Corps, assigned as an Instructor of International and Operational War Division, Judge Advocate General School. This source was retrieved from a quarterly Military Law Review (volume 139) conducted at the Judge Advocate General’s school. It was selected for it’s in depth analysis of the findings and contributing factors of root causes for the My Lai Massacre. This Document is instrumental in displaying lessons learned....

Words: 430 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

What Role Do the Media Play in Forming Public Opinion?

...Executive Summary This report explores the question of what role the United States (U.S.) television media played in forming public opinion on the Vietnam War. The research, based on reviewing other primary and secondary sources, shows various opposing theories regarding this subject. Firstly, that television media was blamed for the U.S. loss in Vietnam. As Vietnam was the first televised war, it was argued that television swayed public support for the war by projecting the footage of conflict into the lounge rooms of Americans. One counter-theme showed that other factors such as opposition to the prolonged war and military policy were more likely to have changed public opinion. This report discusses how television media during the Vietnam war was just one aspect of how the public would have formed an opinion on such a complex issue, however concludes that further research is required to arrive at a definitive argument on such a controversial topic. Research Question This report explores what role the media played in forming public opinion within the U.S., regarding America’s involvement in the Vietnam War. The research is particularly focused on the level of influence the introduction of television journalism had on forming public opinion during the war efforts. Escalation of U.S. involvement from aid to major deployment within Vietnam began after the Gulf of Tonkin incident in 1964 (Gifford 2007, p. 18). This period also saw television established as a mass medium across homes...

Words: 1918 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Tet Offensive: The Vietnam War

...Section 1: Identification and Evaluation of sources The focus of this investigation is “To what extend did the Tet offensive change the United States’ public perception and military plans regarding Vietnam?” The essay will compare and contrast how the United States reacts to Vietnam before and after the Tet Offensive, while also evaluating any other factors that might also had a role. Since the Tet Offensive is a series of events, the essay will analyze all effects since the start of the offensive through the end. Source 1: “Tet” section of “Vietnam: A history” by Stanley Karnow Stanley Karnow worked for Time, Life, the Washington Post, and NBC to cover Asia from 1959-1974. He started to write this secondary source book when he arrived in Vietnam on July 1959. The book serves to...

Words: 2118 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Ptsd E.A.

...Annotated Bibliography Topic: War Related Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Sub Topics: Chronic PTSD in Vietnam Veterans PTSD in Iraq War Veterans SOURCE 1: What is PTSD? Retrieved on 13 Nov. 2011 http://www.ptsd.va.gov/public/pages/what-is-ptsd.asp UNDERSTANDING PTSD Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is an anxiety disorder that can occur after you have been through a traumatic event. A traumatic event is something horrible and scary that you see or that happens to you. During this type of event, you think that your life or others' lives are in danger. You may feel afraid or feel that you have no control over what is happening. Anyone who has gone through a life-threatening event can develop PTSD. These events can include: * Combat or military exposure * Child sexual or physical abuse * Terrorist attacks * Sexual or physical assault * Serious accidents, such as a car wreck. * Natural disasters, such as a fire, tornado, hurricane, flood, or earthquake. After the event, you may feel scared, confused, or angry. If these feelings don't go away or they get worse, you may have PTSD. These symptoms may disrupt your life, making it hard to continue with your daily activities. How does PTSD develop? All people with PTSD have lived through a traumatic event that caused them to fear for their lives, see horrible things, and feel helpless. Strong emotions caused by the event create changes in the brain that may result in PTSD...

Words: 4468 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Literature Review

...Introduction: India and Vietnam are both Asian countries who are quite similar in a number of aspects, and as such it is important to examine and analyze how globalization and other factors have had an impact on them from a social, political, and economic perspective. During the late part of the 20th century, the International Monetary Fund and other organizations collaborated with countries that were struggling economically and offered financial assistance and the creation and implementation of policies. Globalization has had a significant impact on countries around the world; both positive and negative outcomes have resulted from various factors pertaining to globalization. Revolutions such as the Arab Spring uprisings have been influenced by aspects of globalization, such as the changing political sphere and the unstable economic market. Furthermore, the revolutions are more successful in contemporary times as opposed to fifty or one hundred years ago because globalization has provided the world with many comforts, such as the convenience individuals possess in the usage of technology—namely social networking websites. Therefore, it is important to analyze and examine the social, political, and economic changes that have been brought about by globalization, the changing global-politics, as well as social and economic issues that may have caused by or formed after military conflict. India and Vietnam are two countries that are quite similar in terms of GPD per capita rates...

Words: 5002 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Capstone: War and Culture

...I & I L Capstone: War and Culture Abstract Statement Although culture is a key topic in the purview of theoretical discussions, the concept of war and culture is a new notion that has not been engaged by many analysts. Indeed Adrian Lewis underscores the importance of war and culture in "The American Culture of War in the Age of Artificial Limited War" when he posits that culture decisively influences the way nation-states conduct war (Lewis 226). This work aims to shift focus from the traditional focus on culture as a method of analysis and instead examine various commentary on the military and its application as a form of cultural activity. America's Self-Imposed Cultural Attitude Towards War There have been widespread calls to consider the normative cultural interpretations of war. Most notably, the works of Adrian Lewis as demonstrated in his treatise The American Culture of War, are a classic pointer of the dynamic and contested nature that culture assumes in the interpretation of war. Lewis poignantly articulates the need to apply such cultural interpretations in a deterministic fashion (Lewis 225). In writing The American Culture of War, Lewis depicts war as a systematic orchestrated phenomenon, which in essence is a prolongation of culture through other techniques (Lewis 227). To prove this argument Lewis presents two cardinal subjects. First he provides an explicit analysis of the transformations that America has undergone since...

Words: 2206 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Entrepreneurial Research

...Introduction The world has witnessed the significant growth of game industry over the last 10 years. There have been major changes in all aspects such as graphics, gameplay and along with it come a great number of big firms in this industry: Ubisoft, Square Enix, Crytek, and so on. On contrary to this rapid growth, there have been little or none game producers that come from Vietnam. This can only be explained by the fact that game piracy appears in every corners of Vietnam and that Vietnamese governments, as well as the societies, have a negative point of view in games. The situation made it nearly impossible for any game developers to set their feet in such field. However, a new and young company, Emobi Games, realized their opportunities and decided to take a risk with the goal is to prove to Vietnamese people and the whole world that Vietnamese games are able to compete at a global level. The purpose of this report is to provide information regarding how Emobi Games innovatively changes the whole industry. Emobi Games’ background Emobi Games is one of the very few game developers that come from Vietnam. It was originally founded in 2008 but it was not until April 2009 that Emobi Games became an independent company (Emobigames 2011). At the moment, the company’s staff is a group consists of 23 people with each person is high – skilled and have achieved certain degrees in programming, 3D designing. These people are not connected by the skills they possess but by sharing the...

Words: 1551 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Media's Role In The Vietnam War

...In an article, Robert Elegant, a former Vietnam War reporter, wrote: "For the first time in modern history, the outcome of a war was determined not on the battlefield but on the printed page and, above all, on the television screen . . . never before Vietnam had the collective policy --no less stringent a term will serve--sought, by graphic and unremitting distortion, the victory of the enemies of the correspondents' own side." His point of view on the war summarized the effect of media on ending the Vietnam War. To obtain understandable on the roles that media played during this war, it is important to first explore the history of the war. The longest war in the history, a proxy war between those that support communism and those that did not. The United States supported the South against the North that advocated for communism. In 1954, Eisenhower wrote a letter to Ngo Dinh Diem offered to aid Diem in preventing Vietnam from being a communist country. Following Eisenhower’s promise to Diem, Kennedy aided South Vietnam with military support to fight against North Vietnam. The Vietnam War was a catastrophic since it fought against itself and destroyed its own people. It is significant to take notice of the fact that at the beginning many Americans supported United States in this war. Many Anti-war protests occurred on college campus across the nation because of events like the Tet Offensive and My Lai Massacre. United States finally withdrawn in 1973. Therefore, without the media...

Words: 1641 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Downfall of News Coverage in Depicting War

...and Public Opinion Thalia Capilla POSC 146 Justin Nelson Downfall of News Coverage In Depicting War The ideal news coverage is a mirror image of reality, thousands of Americans tune in to their local or national news channel for quality coverage and accuracy. In the 1960’s Vietnam became the first war to be televised, resulting in a large disapproval rating on the war. However, the American people saw the truth and gave their opinion. Today the media is nowhere near the ideal news coverage, being characterized as corporate, concentrated and conglomerate. News Media is a profit making enterprise owned by a few companies. So what changed? How did the media evolve into something so filtered by the government? In this Literature Review I will cover how international affairs and war coverage quality has drastically declined to fit corporate news norms. It sacrifices quality over quantity, framing the American people. News media in a democracy should provide a forum for diverse views and provide the people with the truth of what is happening around the world, (McLeod 2009). That is what I would like shed light on in this paper. News framing, agenda setting and priming are broadly examined by Scheufelel and Tewksbury (2007) to see how all three are related and what the potential relationships can infer about the effects of mass media. This is an important analysis as these three components of the subtle effects model can greatly impact how people interpret what the press...

Words: 3579 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Historiography: The Cause Of World War I

...different sources, levels of credibility, motives of the historian(s), and perspectives. “Critical analysis” in history writing means that one is to analyze a text and the author’s purpose of writing it, and how it affects the argument being made and the evidence that is being used. i.e. When writing about the causes of World War I, one would have to discuss both sides because if only one side, like Germany, were to be discussed, then it would be seen as biased, but then one could also use that as evidence in his/her arguments. “Historical context” is being aware of the historical setting and situation of a certain event, which means that political and social issues and conditions should also be noted. Context will show what is relevant and/or significant to the event....

Words: 1266 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Santa Ana Winds

...increase coherence. Rhetorical structures, graphic organizers, and work on repetition, transitions, and emphasis are addressed. I comment on individual drafts, and I write memos to the class in a blog about whole-class concerns such as specificity of quotations, parallelism, and transitions. C13 Simultaneously, students review the simple, compound, complex, and compound-complex sentence classifications. We examine word order, length, and surprising constructions. Loose and periodic sentences are introduced. We examine sample sentences and discuss how change affects tone, purpose, and credibility of the author/speaker. In addition, feedback on producing sentence structure variety is focused on critical thinking skills, evaluating sources and resources, using specific details to support general conclusions, revising for the best possible way to sue the language to express ideas clearly, concisely, and elegantly as possible. The feedback is ongoing and frequent. C9 In order to encourage students to be successful lifelong learners, they will learn how to evaluate...

Words: 2702 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

War, Casualties, and Public Suport

...War, Casualties, and Public Support In the forum of international politics, war is—for the most part—an acceptable instrument in settling disputes. For democratic governments, however, citizens have the power to influence their politicians, and it is necessary for those politicians to garner the support of their public by making the case of why it is necessary to engage in an international conflict. Once the decision to go to war has been made, it is important to maintain public support. Currently, the United States has been engaged in two lengthy wars with Afghanistan and Iraq. The war in Afghanistan is presently in its tenth year, and the war in Iraq has been going on for nearly eight years. At the start of both wars, public support for them was extremely high with 80 percent to 90 percent of people supporting military action in Afghanistan according to a Gallup poll taken in November 2001, and a Pew Research Center poll conducted in April 2003 showed around 74 percent of people favored the invasion of Iraq. However, as these wars have dragged on, support for them has drastically diminished. The latest poll conducted by CNN/ORC in November 2011 shows that only 35 percent of the public supports the war in Afghanistan and 29 percent supports the war in Iraq. The question has been raised: how does the American public come to support or oppose the decision of its government to engage in military conflict? This question was first presented by John Mueller (1971) when he took...

Words: 1315 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Entry Strategy for Himalaya in Vietnam

...Entry strategy for Himalaya in Vietnam | Group Assignment (Group 2B) | | | 12/08/2012 | The Himalaya Company- Introducing our Animal Healthcare line in Vietnam Market study and entry strategy: The Himalaya Drug Company has been in the market of phtyo-pharmaceuticals for animal healthcare for quite a few years now. As compared to most other organizations which are in the chemical products segment, Himalaya’s products are created completely from natural products. They manufacture and export drugs for livestock, Poultry, Aquaculture, and domestic pets. As of today, the organization is expanding its market share within India and exports to over 82 countries. Target Country: We will be researching the feasibility of entering the animal healthcare sector in Vietnam. The country has a population of 86 million people and the economy has been growing at 7-8% for the past two decades. About 70% of the population earn their livelihood from agriculture and animal husbandry. Furthermore, about 60% of the agriculture segment is also dependant on livestock and poultry. From the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD), livestock in Vietnam exists mainly in two forms: industrial farms and farmer (family) households. In 2011, there were 23’000 farms and 8.5 million household farms country-wide. They consist of 10,100 pig farms, 8.7 cattle farms and 3,800 poultry farms. As seen, there has been a phenomenal increase in population which has more than matched the...

Words: 1873 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Seasonal Tourism in Ho Chi Minh City

...Contents 1 Introduction 3 2 Theoretical basis and research methods 4 2.1 Theoretical basis and Analysis framework 4 2.1.1 Methods of analysis of variance (ANOVA) 4 2.1.2 Literature review 5 2.2 Research methodology 7 3 Results and discussion 7 3.1 Results 7 3.2 Discussion 9 4 Conclusion 10 Figure 31: The average number of foreign visitors to Ho Chi Minh City per month (2005 - 2013). (Source: Table 3-1). Unit: tourists. 9 Table 31: Foreign Tourists having arrived in Ho Chi Minh City (2005-2013) (Source: Ho Chi Minh City Department of Culture, Sports and Tourism; Unit: Tourists) 7 Table 32: the output of the ANOVA analysis – The Summary table (Source: Excel) 8 Table 33: the output of the ANOVA analysis – the ANOVA table (Source: Excel) 8 Abstract Seasonality is “a temporal imbalance in the phenomenon of tourism” (Butler, 1994). The topic of tourism seasonality has been analyzed over decades, by many touristic enterprises and policymakers. It is useful to have an understanding of the seasonality phenomenon in Vietnamese tourism. The former will represent the seasonal concentration of the number for foreign visitors coming to Ho Chi Minh City. Besides, the results conducted, the latter investigates the causes of seasonal tourism in Ho Chi Minh City. The decomposition technique used in this study is primarily ANOVA statistical model for a single factor based on the secondary data of monthly tourist arrivals in the City during the period...

Words: 2916 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Doc, Docx, Pdf

...Smith I appreciate the opportunity to advise you regarding this tax matter. To ensure a complete understanding between us, I am starting the pertinent information about the advice that I will be rendering and the facts I have researched. Responsibilities I use my judgment in considering the potential and value of Vietnamese retail & distribution market. Unless you instruct me otherwise, I resolve such questions in your favor whenever possible. However, I cannot guarantee the outcome in the event of force majeure such as war, political crisis. Facts The following facts are based on my research on the Vietnamese macroeconomics and microeconomics as well as the available forms of legal entity under Vietnamese regulations. To specify, on the Vietnamese macroeconomics aspects: Population : 90,000,000 ( 90 million in 2013, source: generation family planning office for population of Vietnam ) , Vietnam is holding " gold retail index " compared with other countries in the world with 68 % of the population...

Words: 1060 - Pages: 5