Free Essay

Scotland Independence Factors in Education

In:

Submitted By emanemayomkins
Words 734
Pages 3
PROS

Childcare Benefits
The Scottish government claim by the end of the first independent Scotland to have all children between 3-4 (and in some cases vulnerable 2 year olds) in full time childcare- equating to time spent at primary school

Raising Attainment amongst disadvantaged children
The Scottish government state, that the root of some educational problems, stem from children in severe poverty, who have messy home lives & poor diets. A hungry child cannot fulfill their education to the best of their ability and a child who is distracted at home cannot focus on learning. Their main aim is to change the tax & benefit system – tackling poverty will allow more parents to work and provide a better life for children who will then in turn have more time to focus on school and nursery

Protecting free tuition in Universities
The Scottish government claims to protect free tuition fees for Scottish students and still provide supports for living costs
University is one the main focuses of the Scottish economy following independence. The proposal is to remain the same by charging students from other parts of the UK to study for Scotland. This policy recognizes the requirement to keep a mix of students so that the Scottish people benefit from a free education and the universities benefit from a contribution from Students from other parts of the UK and further

Apprentiships

‘New Modern Apprenticeship’ would increase year by year with 30,000 modern apprentices to become available by 2020.
Since taking office, the Scottish government have increased apprentiships by 10,000 places. They believe this will boost opportunities for young people seeking to enter the labor market.

Tailored University Research

A strong research base is at the heard of the Scottish Governments ambition. Independence will be better placed to support a further strengthening and enhancement of the Scottish research base

They promise to continue to support research to allow us to remain internationally competitive

State we would be able to tailor research to Scotland’s strengths and needs. With independence we have the opportunity to provide a direct funding contribution to have a clearer view to the functioning of research councils and identify priorities within out research

The Scottish government claim the independence will attract academics from all over the world to factor in Scotland success – barriers would disappear. However our reputation will allow us to stay competitive and we would be in a better place to support a further strengthening of our “world class database”

CONS

There are many negatives to the education system against an independent Scotland – however two cases highlighted are..
Cons in Education
RESEARCH
A larger part of Scotland’s research relies on the UK charitable donations to carry out research. Contrary to the promises there is no proof that an independent Scotland will keep this level of funding as most will be lost when leaving the UK.

Senior academics and executives believe Scotland’s bet known universities would loose access to BILLIONS in funding and joint projects supported by the British Research Councils

There is a fear of massive spending cuts in education

Loss of uk charities supports. Scotland benefit vastly from medical research provided by uk charities. For example “The Wellcome Trust” who massively contribute to Scottish research funding has strict rules about funding research outside the uk. p It will become attractive for researches to move to other parts of the UK and in some cases even some entire research groups so they will be guaranteed the UK funding – something an independent Scotland cannot guarantee.

With Scotland only being 8% of the UK population – it uses 12% of the UK life sciences research budget – we are benefiting more from our UK budget.

FREE TUITION
Free tuition is granted to Scottish residents and others of EU countries, but English, Welsh and Northern Irish students must pay up to 9k a year to study in Scotland.
If Scotland were to become an independent member of the EU – all UK students would be allowed to study in Scotland without paying fees. Contrary to what the Scottish Government promised about protecting university fees there is no skating around this law. EU regulations state non-discrimination to other EU countries.
This would result in fewer places for Scottish students, as there would be an influx from the rest of the UK. Therefore Scottish universities would suffer a loss of revenue from lack of fees.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Scottish Independence

...Chapter II Arguments for and against the Scottish independence Arguments for the independence ----------------------------------------------- 6 Arguments against the independence ----------------------------------------- 7 Conclusion --------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10 Bibliography ------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11 Introduction The subject I have analyzed in this research paper is the possible independence of Scotland. I chose this topic because the Scottish independence is a problem of great importance not only for the UK and Scotland, but also for the whole Europe. While doing my research I found very strong and opposing opinions about this recent topic. Scottish independence is a relevant and important matter that has been debated for many years but is now at the pinnacle of debate. Both public and politicians and opposing opinions about independence and throughout this work I will evaluate the most current and most emotive arguments for and against independence. First, I will speak about the historical background of this issue and about the parties “fighting” for independence. Next, I will represent for and against arguments, which will help to understand this complicated issue. Chapter I General information Scotland was an independent country from 843, with the unification of the Scots and Picts. In medieval times, Scotland fought for freedom from England, which Mel Gibson...

Words: 2480 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Discuss the Causes and Consequences of Separatist Conflicts

...is the Basque area as well as Catalonia. As they had their own history and culture, the autonomy was split from Spain and they are now able to decide their own affairs. Catalonia has now been able to maintain their Catalan language which has been taught in all schools in the region since 1983 and has become the official language in education. This shows that separatism can be caused by differences in social aspects and that communities like to be recognised as their own state. The idea of separatism in many cases can also arise when there is a perception that exploitation of local resources by national government produces little economic gain for the region. This was the case in Scotland recently and was one of the main arguments for Scotland leaving the UK. Before its union with England, Scotland was a separate kingdom, with its own national church, separate education and legal systems and its own language called Gaelic which is spoken in parts of the country. One of the main problems the Scottish National Party felt was that the exploitation of the North Sea oil and gas had done little to develop the economy of Scotland. The drive for independence was partly satisfied by the establishment in 1999 of a parliament with limited tax-raising powers. In 2007, the Scottish National Party became...

Words: 1107 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

The Creative Industries and Scottish Film.

... With its exquisite landscapes, monumental architecture, and breath-taking coastlines, it is no wonder Scotland has always been such a powerful draw to film makers and producers alike. The Scottish film industry has grown from strength to strength in recent years. Arguably putting itself on the map in the nineties with films such as Braveheart (1995) and Trainspotting (1996), Scotland now lends its locations to multimillion-pound productions such as Skyfall (2012), The Dark Knight Rises (2012), Sunshine on Leith (2013) and The Railway Man (2014) as well as TV productions including Game of Thrones (2011) and Outlander (2014). To what extent have Scottish films such as Braveheart and Trainspotting impacted on the tourism industry and given their contrasting portrayals of the Scots, does one hinder tourism more than the other? Can we say whether or not there is a distinct notion of ‘Scottish national identity’ and if such a concept exists to what level is it illustrated in Scottish film? Has the Scottish film industry had an impact on the political landscape in Scotland since it was devolved in 1998? Finally given the effects of Scottish film in Scotland, what has the government put in place in order to develop the industry further? Scotland has produced many world renowned films over the last two decades and has had a large impact on the creative industries in Scotland. It has long retained a certain romance which frequently appeals to both UK and global audiences, no film...

Words: 5642 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Uk Counry Economy

...environment and economic status in today’s world. Political and Legal History Prior to 1707, the nations that currently make up the UK were each separate states. On May 1, 1707, the UK was formed by the unification of the kingdoms of England, Scotland, and Wales by the Act of Unions (Duncan 2010). This act formally joined all three kingdoms located on the British Isle under the same crown and government, with England remaining the most powerful entity within the UK. Also formed under the Act of Unions was the Parliament at Westminster, the UK’s main political body and rough equivalent to the United States’ Congress (Duncan 2010). Nearly 100 years later, the kingdom of Ireland joined the UK under the Union with Ireland Act of 1800 (Office of Public Sector Information). While Ireland would remain a part of the UK for over 120 years, they would leave the UK on December 6, 1921 as part of the Anglo-Irish Treaty (Factindex.com 1). During Ireland’s exit from the UK, the subdivisions of Ireland had to each approve the move to leave the UK. Because of this, some of the territory of Northern Ireland refused to approve this measure, and returned to the UK two days later (Factindex.com 1). Today, the territories of England, Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland make up the UK. Prior to 1945, the UK was one of the most active nations in the world as an imperial power. During the UK’s colonial reign, they controlled an empire...

Words: 2101 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

United Kingdom

...consumption by men aged 16-24 has fallen since 2000. Since 1998, there has been a general increase in drinking over recommended weekly limits, especially for women. Among men aged 16-24 drinking over weekly limits has decreased alongside overall consumption since 2000. In Northern Ireland, there has been a clear increase in both genders and especially in adults aged 18-24. Binge drinking levels (twice the recommended daily limit) have changed little between 1998 and 2006 in Great Britain. However, this masks an increase of 7 per cent in women – especially those over 25 – and a fall amongst men aged 16-24. There is some evidence that the proportion of drinkers under 16 has fallen slightly since 1988 in England, Northern Ireland and Scotland, though this is not consistent across boys and girls of different ages. Amongst those who do drink, average units consumed increased markedly between 1990 and 2006, with a larger increase amongst 11- to 13-year-old boys. This may have recently decreased in England in 2007: future surveys will show if this trend continues. Continued monitoring of women’s and under-16s drinking using consistent consumption measures, and greater recruitment from under-represented groups, such as different ethnic groups, are needed to help interpret future trends....

Words: 1701 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Protection of Individuals from Possible Harm

...Protection of Individuals from Possible Harm and Abuse Sharon Bann Living a life that is free from harm and abuse is a fundamental right of every person and when abuse does take place it needs to be dealt with swiftly, effectively and in ways which are appropriate to the issues and where the person in need of protection stays as much in control of the decision making as is possible. Not all abuse is physical and nonphysical abuse can break a person’s spirit and shatter their confidence and self-esteem. The person must be taken seriously in all matters when disclosing abuse or when abuse is suspected. The support and therapy of those affected by abuse is the determinant long-term factor in ensuring the well-being and safety of those who have been abused and the legal procedures will ensure the immediate short term safety and security of those concerned. If nothing is done to help the person who is being abused then the it is extremely likely that the effects of the abuse will continue and potentially increase in the severity on the persons growth, development and well being. Forms of abuse that happen are Physical Abuse which is where attempted or actual physical injury to a person, and there is definite knowledge or reasonable suspicion that the injury was inflicted or knowingly not prevented. “physical abuse is the use of strength or weapons or the threat of injury to hurt or control another person” (haley et al 2010:3) Sexual Abuse which is where a...

Words: 2163 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Dasdasp9Weqeru Ihdhsh

...ECS8C_C19.qxd 6/08/2007 16:00 Page 774 CASE STUDY Ekomate Systems and the Indian software industry: leveraging network relationships for international growth Shameen Prashantham The case study looks at the importance of developing and maintaining a network of relationships in international markets and in the local milieu as a critically important capability for smaller firms seeking international growth. It also illustrates how the indirect benefit of acquiring new knowledge (learning) through network relationships is likely to be more sustainable than the direct benefits of gaining new business opportunities. ● ● ● Origins of Ekomate Ekomate Systems was founded in 1996 by Tom Thomas upon his return to his hometown of Bangalore after obtaining an MS in computer engineering at the University of Texas in Austin. The son of an entrepreneur, Thomas felt that starting a business would be considerably more remunerative in comparison with employment. Moreover, he had gained some work experience at Intel, while in the USA, and was acutely aware of the great potential of the Internet. He was therefore keen to start a company that would ‘enable client companies to get on the Web’. According to him, when utilising Internet technology, companies ‘not only have the public side [that is, a website] that any visitor would come in and see but also a private side where their customers, suppliers and vendors also interact through the Web’. His company, Ekomate, works in this...

Words: 2684 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Management

...price 8.4 Promotion 9. BUDGET 10. IMPLEMENTATION. MARKETING PLAN FOR ANAMAZH COFFEE SHOP 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This summary contain the marketing plan for Anamazh coffee shop in Aberdeen. It examines the market situation of coffee business in Aberdeen and the United Kingdom. The document analyze the size and trend of the business, explaining the macro and micro environment using PESTLE and 3Cs model to study factors that can impact on the intended business. Base on the situation analysis, the sustainability of coffee business in Aberdeen and the United Kingdom is achievable, UK is known as a nation with coffee drinkers. Furthermore, the brand competitors were critically examine. There are many coffee shops business in the United Kingdom and Aberdeen. In UK the three top leading coffee brands are Costa, Starbucks and Café Nero, likewise in Aberdeen. They have the larger market, therefore, Anamaze brand must take its competitive advantage to penetrate the market. The document also explain the key issues of the intended business and also make assumption on factors that can influence Anamazh coffee shop and the objectives of the business. Furthermore, the plan explains the target market for Anamazh coffee shop and how to position its brand in the market. It state clearly the market strategy for the business using the marketing mix concept to explain. Furthermore, the implementation plan is also analysis for effective actualisation of...

Words: 3891 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Constitutional Reform Since 1997 Has Not Gone Far Enough. Discuss.

...Constitutional reform since 1997 has not gone far enough. Discuss. I believe that constitutional reform since 1997, ultimately has not gone far enough in the UK. Such reforms in the UK, including the House of Lords Act 1999 took reform in Westminster to quite a large extent, but this has be limited by a few factors. In addition, the Human Right Act 1998 was another significant reform under the Blair government allowing citizens clearer light on their rights and freedoms, however this Act of Parliament is not entrenched within the UK’s constitution. The electoral system has also been subject to interpretation under constitutional reform such as PR systems used for Scottish Parliament and devolved assemblies. The House of Lords Act 1999 put through under the Blair government removed all but 92 hereditary peers from the House of Lords. This meant that Parliament’s lower chamber could be seen as a more legitimate body as unelected and unappointed peers were seen as undemocratic and illegitimate to the UK political system. This also meant that there would be a more confident role of scrutiny in the House of Lords as appointed peers would be deemed fairer on legislation in the Lords chamber. An example of the House of Lords exerting this new role is the blocking of the NHS reform which led to the government having to amend their plans, as well as the Hunting Act 2004. Conversely, this reform to the House of Lords could be argued to have not gone far enough as 92 hereditary peers...

Words: 1071 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Uk Pestle Analysis

...Country Profile Series United Kingdom In-depth PESTLE insights PESTLE Country Analysis Report: United Kingdom REFERENCE CODE: ML00002-031 PUBLICATION DATE: May 2013 WWW.MARKETLINE.COM MARKETLINE. THIS PROFILE IS A LICENSED PRODUCT AND IS NOT TO BE PHOTOCOPIED ML00002-031/Published 05/2013 Page 1 © MarketLine. This report is a licensed product and is not to be photocopied OVERVIEW Catalyst This profile analyzes the political, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental (PESTLE) structure in the UK. Each of the PESTLE factors is explored on four parameters: current strengths, current challenges, future prospects, and future risks. Summary Key findings The UK has a strong democratic system, but differences between coalition partners in the incumbent government pose a challenge The UK adheres to a democratic, parliamentary system of governance known as the Westminster system. This system ensures adequate distribution of power between the executive branch led by the prime minister, the bicameral legislature and the judiciary. Growing ideological differences between the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats in the current government is making the coalition vulnerable. Tensions between pro-Europe Liberal Democrats and euroskeptic Conservatives continue to plague British politics. Further, conflicting views on issues such as welfare reforms, immigration and the economy are straining relations. The UK economy is developed, but rising government debt...

Words: 22764 - Pages: 92

Premium Essay

Background of Study: Schizophrenia

...Background of Study Jade Birkley PSY480/Senior Project February 14, 2013 Professor Eric Durbrow Background of the Study In a given year 2 million Americans and 25 million people worldwide suffer from one of the top ten most debilitating diseases. Schizophrenia is a long-term major mental disorder that affects several aspects of behavior, thinking, and emotion, which makes it difficult to tell between what is real and unreal; it is also characterized by positive and negative symptoms. Either being acute with a rapid beginning and good hopes of resurgence or a chronic longer term course that builds over time. Such variation in symptoms leads to observations of discord in patients. “According to the DSM-IV, schizophrenia is a disorder characterized by deteriorating ability to function in everyday life and by some combination of hallucinations, delusions, thought disorder, movement disorder, and inappropriate emotional expressions” (Kalat, 2009, p. 449). The positive symptoms fall into two cluster (psychotic and disorganized) and represent behaviors that are distorted version of normal functions. Psychotic symptoms consist of delusions (unsubstantiated beliefs) and hallucinations (hearing voices, seeing things others do not or feeling things that are not there). Disorganized symptoms “consist of inappropriate emotional displays, bizarre behaviors, incoherent speech, and thought disorder” (Kalat, 2009, p. 449). The negative symptoms represent behaviors deficiency or absence...

Words: 1243 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Squatter Settlement In Australia

...Many failed to gain land because of opposition from existing squatters. At the same time, a sense of nationalism was growing. British had granted self-government to all her colonies by the 1890s, and the leaders of the colonies had come to realize that some form of union was needed. None of the Australian colonies were willing to give up their individual independence, so in 1890s, after fierce arguments, the colonies agreed to unite in a federation. The Commonwealth of Australia was proclaimed on the first day of 1901, and the city of Canberra was chosen as the federal...

Words: 1804 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Language as a Resource of Internal and International Relations of "Nations Without States"

...language as a resource of internal and international activity of “nations without states”. bulat n. khalitov, kazan state power engineering university, kazan, russia The issues of language and language policy have become the objects of interest of different branches of political theory nowadays. From one side the basic reason for this is the fact that language can play an important role (either positive or negative) in the context of different political processes developing in the world and also in the context of a growing number of confrontations and conflicts, which often have linguistic diversity at their basis. From the other side, the development of political theory within the framework of general “linguistic turn” that influenced almost all social sciences leads to the studying of language policy aspects. In modern world linguistic diversity and other language issues have turned into a significant basis of contradictions that influence stability of different societies. In Western Europe we can distinguish several types of unsolved problems which have to do with language. Diachronically the most important and most severe are conflicts between the dominant language group and various linguistic minorities historically rooted in some areas within the state borders. As an example we can name linguistic conflicts in Belgium (Flanders), Spain (Catalonia and Basque country), Italy (South Tirol), Switzerland (french- and italian-speaking cantons). ...

Words: 4714 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Education Policy in U.S.a and United Kingdom

...and U.S.A’s Education Policy Student’s Name Institution Affiliation Introduction Education policy refers to the guidelines and principles that the government put in place as laws in order to govern the activities around education systems in their country (Dewey, 2012). These policies are meant to be implemented in all the stages of education that is from early childhood education, kindergarten through to 12th grade, university and college education, graduate, adult education and job training. The areas that the government focuses on while formulating and implementing education policy include school choice, class size, school size, teacher education, school privatization, teacher pay and certification, curricular content, teaching methods, school infrastructure and education requirements (Dewey, 2012). It also encompasses the values and missions that schools aim to uphold and achieve respectively. A country’s academic success is greatly determined by the kind of education policies that have been formulated and implemented by its government (Ravitch, 2012). Hence this is a very vital factor for citizens to consider when they are obligated to vote in a new government. They tend to look at the most beneficial and favorable education policies that are going to be for the good of the country. Politicians also prioritize this factor when they are campaigning for office. This essay aims at comparing two countries’ education policies that...

Words: 3688 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Old English Literature

...OLD ENGLISH LITERATURE • Palaeolithic nomads from mainland Europe; • New inhabitants came from western and possibly north-western Europe (New Stone Age); • in the 2nd millennium BC new inhabitants came from the Low Countries and the middle Rhine (Stonehenge); • Between 800 and 200 BC Celtic peoples moved into Britain from mainland Europe (Iron Age) • first experience of a literate civilisation in 55 B.C. • remoter areas in Scotland retained independence • Ireland, never conquered by Rome, Celtic tradition • The language of the pre-Roman settlers - British (Welsh, Breton); Cornish; Irish and Scottish Gaelic (Celtic dialect) • The Romans up to the fifth century • Britain - a province of the Roman Empire 400 years • the first half of the 5th century the Angles, Saxons, and Jutes (N Germany, Jutland) • The initial wave of migration - 449 A. D. • the Venerable Bede (c. 673-735) • the Britain of his time comprised four nations English, British (Welsh), Picts, and Scots. • invaders resembling those of the Germans as described by Tacitus in his Germania. • a warrior race • the chieftain, the companions or comitatus. • the Celtic languages were supplanted (e.g. ass, bannock, crag). * Christianity spread from two different directions: * In the 5th century St Patrick converted Ireland, in the 7th century the north of England was converted by Irish monks; * in the south at the end of the 6th century Aethelberht of Kent allowed the monk Augustine...

Words: 9579 - Pages: 39