Premium Essay

Susan Sontag Photography

Submitted By
Words 814
Pages 4
Most believe a photograph is worth a thousand words, as almost everyone recognizes the impressive ability photographs have to describe, explain, and express ideas and messages. Yet, Susan Sontag claims photography is detrimental to the world’s ability to think and dictate its emotions. However, Sontag’s claim that photography limits our understanding of the world is untrue, as photography is the only form of communication that can fully express every possible sentiment around the world, regardless of language. Photography has the power to explain and deliver a complex and intricate issue in an instant. In the passage, the author implies a photograph cannot teach or educate. However, this can easily be refuted by countless real world examples where photography did educate …show more content…
Before television and cameras, in the United Kingdom, manufacturing industries and factories had no limitations on the amount of pollution they could release into the country’s air and waterways. Because the majority of British people were not aware of the pollution the industries were creating, they did nothing to protest their detrimental efforts. In fact, in 1959, the Guardian reported the River Thames, a river running through the center of London, to be biologically dead. However, as soon as photography had advanced to the point where the obvious environmental degradation was visible, with color photos and high resolution pictures, the British were up in arms about the manner in which these corporations had abused their home. Because of the restoration efforts that were implemented after the people were informed of the pollution in the waterways from photographs, today, the River Thames is home to thousands of aquatic species and organisms (BBC). As the people of Britain of the state of their environment, beyond their physical surroundings, they were able to

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

On Photography Susan Sontag Analysis

...Humanity has always had a fickle obsession with capturing the world around them and putting them into little boxes. The art of photography became a device for that. ‘On Photography’ by Susan Sontag successfully captures the elusive effect a photograph can have on a human being, and the true nature of the supposed knowledge it imparts on those who experience. The age old phrase “a picture is worth a thousand words”, is a lie, and Sontag’s essay assures us of that. Words can carry knowledge, an ability to assure understanding in a reader, and photographs, as Sontag so astutely points out, act in the opposite manner - they eliminate understanding. Our society, as the essay to astutely points out, often takes photo’s as unassailable proof of...

Words: 708 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Scene

...photographer, picture-taking is an event in itself, and one with ever more peremptory rights – to interfere with, to invade, or to ignore whatever is going on” (Sontag, 11). Photography narrates the world. A simple photograph can freeze time, halt any moment you please. Photographers have a choice to choose between telling a narrative and expressing art. But when it comes down to it, no matter how complete or comprehensive a narrative appears it will always be the product of including some elements and excluding others based on what the creator wants to be viewed. Inclusion/exclusion is part of what construction is all about, but knowing what is best included or excluded requires an understanding of context. With narrative or art photography events are not found objects waiting to be discovered, they are created, whether by the photographer or the person within the photograph. If it is a live action, journalistic photograph, something led up to that moment in time, it was created. In photography, narrative is related to the idea of context, that is where the photographer comes in and adds their point of view and taste on a subject matter. Ralph Eugene Meatyard uses a narrative format to portray exactly what he wants to be seen in his photographs “Untitled” ca. 1960 and “Romance (N.) from Ambrose Bierce #3” from portfolio 3 ca. 1964. Susan Sontag’s ideas of Plato’s Cave and Allan Sekula’s idea of possible meaning; will relate to what Meatyard is depicting throughout his photographs. He uses...

Words: 1371 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Shelby Lee Adams

...he wants to give a glimpse of the impoverished lifestyle of his subjects. While it is interesting to see the disparity between our culture and theirs, it’s also shocking to realize that people live like this every day. Although he denies it, Adams’ photographs are frequently seen as exploitive because they create a distorted image of society for his own personal gain. The photographs’ dismal qualities seem to display a lifestyle where the people look distraught amidst a culture of despair. Despite the controversial appearances of his photos, his finished works still make an impression on society, whether it’s a good or bad one. The photographs are professionally done, and they reveal his prowess as an artist and photographer. While the photography of Shelby Lee Adams is widely criticized for being exploitive of the Appalachian culture, it should be valued for its validity in the eyes of his subjects and artistic qualities. While Adams has been criticized for faking his camaraderie with the people of Appalachia in order to gain their trust, his link to the area cannot be disputed. He was born in Hazard, in eastern Kentucky and after moving around from place to place, he returned to Hot Spot, KY where he attended high school. He accredits his childhood experiences as the inspiration of his photographs. His statement, “When your blood’s connected, and you’re born and raised in a place, you’re always connected”, pretty much sums up the bond he feels with the Appalachian residents....

Words: 1466 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Susan Sontag

...On Photography: Agree to Disagree Photography has become a big part of everyday life. Susan Sontag, who was a famous American writer, teacher, filmmaker, and political activist, had a negative look on photography and what it means to us. To be honest I see where she is coming from. Nowadays you see people taking selfies, pictures of funny moments, or just something that doesn’t seem to have much meaning. But to a certain person, that one photo could hold so much more than just sentimental value than what we see from an unknowing and non-understanding mind. “Strictly speaking, one never understands anything from a photograph. Of course, photographs fill in blanks in our mental pictures of the present and past…” wrote Sontag in a claim on her opinion of the concept of photography. She then continued with,...

Words: 987 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Edward Steichen's The Family Of Man

...1955, The Family of Man, which presented photography as a giant three-dimensional photo essay through which visitors could wander (Kelsey 268). Steichen’s curatorial methods suggested that photography in the art museum should feature not the aesthetically refined and personally expressive individual print, but rather a selection of images that could impart a clear message to a broad public (Kelsey 268). This photographic exhibition was considered the greatest of all time, and included 503 pictures from 68 countries (Kelsey 270). Connecting the bond between the camera operator and the photograph made way for calling into question the traditional model of authorship in the fine arts (Kelsey 270). Steichen celebrated photography as a universal language, capable of bringing the world together. He purposed that photographic art required no...

Words: 1282 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Instant Gratifying Information

...We often take for granted how simple it is to capture time and memories in an instant. The click of a button will provide instant gratification in the form of a photograph or other digital media. As one of the first centuries to have the ability to snap and shoot instant pictures, we need to consider the risks and benefits to the images and accumulation of images that surround us. Many take the position that the consequences of photography have nearly paralyzed us as a culture, and impacted our brains in a very real way. Constantly bombarded with images, our brains now process deeper more complex amounts of information. But the overflow of pictures does not always yield educational edifying information. Privacy is constantly infringed...

Words: 329 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethical Responsiveness

...According to Sontag, the photograph succeeds in informing or moving us politically, only if it is established within the context of an applicable political awareness (Butler, 2007). In 1977 In her book On Photography she argued that promoting the act of suffering and pain doesn’t affect us anymore and our ability to ethically respond and react has come to an end “… the photographic image no longer has the power to enrage, to incite, that the visual representation of suffering has become clichéd, that we have become bombarded by sensationalist photography and that, as a result, our capacity for ethical responsiveness has become diminished.” (Cited in Butler, P: 955, 2007) However, later on in “Regarding the pain of others” (2003) Sontag counters...

Words: 1251 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Evolution Of Photography Research Paper

...chemicals to produce fixed photographic pictures and analogue photography being the pioneers of the first photograph are gradually being forgotten. Traditional photography is no longer widely practised and may soon, no longer be in existence. Grant Romer says that, “the stretching and blurring of the definition of “photograph” is a direct result of the evolution of electronic imaging, which has profoundly disrupted the traditional photographic industry” (Romer 2005, p.1). The Oxford dictionary defines a photograph as “a picture made using a camera, in which an image is focused on to light-sensitive material and then...

Words: 1662 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

7 Eleven

...states that he “could not stand it any longer and went away”, Orwell tries to avoid his guilt by simply walking away finding it unbearable to watch it die, and then says he “legally” had done the right thing. “Death of a Moth” by Virginia Woolf describes her thoughts of when she was observing a moth’s death. Woolf’s thoughts turn an insignificant moths death into a whole new perspective of what death really symbolizes. Woolf quotes, “One could only watch the extraordinary efforts made by these tiny legs…” which reveals Woolf’s fascination of the aspect of life and death. The significance of this story reveals how all of death is the same, whether we are humans or insignificant creatures like a moth. “Regarding the Pain of Others” by Susan Sontag uses...

Words: 430 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Good Guy, Bad Guy and the American President

...2012: Good Guy, Bad Guy and the American President Md. Mahmudul Hoque1 Figure 1: 2012 by Ronald Emmerich (2009) The media has substituted them for the older world. Even if we should wish to recover that older world we can do it only by an intensive study of the ways in which the media have swallowed it. -Marshall McLuhan (Sontag, 1977) Introduction ‘2012’- a film by Ronald Emmerich Hollywood's reigning king of catastrophe (Kois, November 13, 2009), came into public on 13th November 2009 with a view to making the audience experience the end of the world. While 2012 enthusiasts point to Nostradamus’ Lost Book, Bible codes, the WebBot computer project, the Hopi and Cherokee Indians, the I Ching (Chinese Book of Changes) and Mother Shipton to 1 Md. Mahmudul Hoque is an alumnus (Batch-54) of the Department of International Relations at the University of Dhaka. He is currently working as an Assistant Commissioner and Executive Magistrate to the Government of People’s Republic of Bangladesh. He can be reached at mhmoni24@yahoo.com Page 1 of 8 support their theory, it all ultimately goes back to the Mayans. The theory suggests that the world shall come to an end on December 21, 2012 through a mega natural disaster (Hitchcock, 2009). Ronald utilized this fashionable chronicle as the plot of the movie, and came out immensely successful to draw the interest of the audiences across the world. The character of the American President played by Danny Glover ...

Words: 2196 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Photography

...strike me more than the events of the Holocaust. As I continued to learn and grow older, I would begin to understand the atrocities that took place during this time, half a world a way, and the images and films that I saw in regards to the Holocaust would haunt me most of all. A photo essay, compiled by the English department at the University of Illinois, contains a number of photographs from the Holocaust that demonstrates the atrocities that occurred during this time. These photographs support the argument developed by Susan Sontag that photographers must make the decision between a photograph and a life, and that the viewers of these images also have a responsibility to actions of atrocity and human suffering. In Susan Sontag’s book On Photography, she develops the argument that photography is an act of nonintervention; that the photographer is faced with the choice between capturing a photograph of atrocity and putting an effort to stop the atrocity. Sontag brings up an interesting point that you cannot have it both way, you either capture the photo or intervene whatever atrocity may be beyond the lens of the camera. It is in this sense that photographer is faced with a ethical and moral decision, and it causes us to question the responsibility of those of us who are faced...

Words: 3126 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Santa Ana Winds

...Mr. Macomber English 3 AP Syllabus 1.5 English 3 AP Course Overview Students in this introductory college-level course read and carefully analyze a broad and challenging range of nonfiction prose selections, deepening their awareness of rhetoric and how language works. Through close reading and frequent writing, students develop their ability to work with language and texts in order to establish greater awareness of purpose and strategy, while strengthening their own composing abilities. C16 Students examine rhetoric in essays, images, movies, novels, and speeches. They frequently confer about their writing by conferencing in class. C 14 Feedback is given both before and after students revise their work to help them develop logical organization, enhanced by specific techniques to increase coherence. Rhetorical structures, graphic organizers, and work on repetition, transitions, and emphasis are addressed. I comment on individual drafts, and I write memos to the class in a blog about whole-class concerns such as specificity of quotations, parallelism, and transitions. C13 Simultaneously, students review the simple, compound, complex, and compound-complex sentence classifications. We examine word order, length, and surprising constructions. Loose and periodic sentences are introduced. We examine sample sentences and discuss how change affects tone, purpose, and credibility of the author/speaker. In addition, feedback on producing sentence structure variety...

Words: 2702 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Leni Riefenstahl

...Leni Riefenstahl Historical Context • Very popular in 1920’s was ‘mountain films’ • Hitler great movie fan and caught attention of Leni in such a film • 1933 – Nazi began consolidating control through propaganda, which was very effective, using the media to present an attractive image of Hitler. • Nazi’s exploited Leni’s talents as a film director – seen in such films as ‘Victory of Faith’, ‘Triumph of the Will’, ‘Day of Freedom’ and ‘Olpympia’ Background • Riefenstahl had a comfortable middle class upbringing • Father Alfred sought to control her life, totally opposed to his daughter’s plan to go on stage • Leni conspired with her mother and took private dance lessons • When her father found out, he threatened for divorce and arranged for Leni to go to boarding school • At age 21 dance career begun – 6 months = 60 performances in Europe • Concluded in Prague when tore knee ligament • Demonstrated her resilience – posting off press cuttings to film director Arnold Fanek, as she set her mind on becoming a movie star • Secured lead in film ‘ The Holy Mountain’ – premiering December 1926 – it was well received Rise to Prominence The Blue Light • 1931 – ‘The Blue light’ was directed and starred in by Leni – meticulously planning the filming of each scene • Premiered March 1932, Leni declared – ‘A courageous women, faithful to her work and to her obsession’ • It won a Silver medal a Venice Biennale Relationship with Hitler • Touring Germany promoting...

Words: 1156 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Art and Story Proceedings 2004

...Elstir……………………………………………………….. David Carrier SECTION TWO: Film and Video Narrative Brief Narrative on Film-The Case of John Updike……………………………………. Thomas P. Adler With a Pen of Light …………………………………………………………………… Michael Fink Media and the Message: Does Media Shape or Serve the Story: Visual Storytelling and New Media ……………………………………………………. June Bisantz Evans Visual Literacy: The Language of Cultural Signifiers…………………………………. Tammy Knipp SECTION THREE: Narrative and Fine Art Beyond Illustration: Visual Narrative Strategies in Picasso’s Celestina Prints………… Susan J. Baker and William Novak Narrative, Allegory, and Commentary in Emil Nolde’s Legend: St. Mary of Egypt…… William B. Sieger A Narrative of Belonging: The Art of Beauford Delaney and Glenn Ligon…………… Catherine St. John Art and Narrative Under the Third Reich ……………………………………………… Ashley Labrie 28 15 1 22 25 27 36 43 51 Hopper Stories in an Imaginary Museum……………………………………………. Joseph Stanton SECTION FOUR: Photography and Narrative Black & White: Two Worlds/Two Distinct Stories……………………………………….. Elaine A. King Relinquishing His Own Story: Abandonment and Appropriation in the Edward Weston Narrative………………………………………………………………………….. David Peeler Narrative Stretegies in the Worlds of Jean Le Gac and Sophe Calle…………………….. Stefanie Rentsch SECTION FIVE: Memory Does The History of Western Art Tell a Grand Story?…………………………………… Eugene E. Selk Storylines………………………………………………………………………………… Bozenna Wisniewsak SECTION SIX: Art and Identity Two Late Crisis Paintings...

Words: 117240 - Pages: 469

Premium Essay

Allan Poe

...Comics as Archives: MetaMetaMaus Hillary Chute | University of Chicago Abstract: In the view of some critics, the form of comics is a locus of the archival, a place where we can identify an archival turn. Art Spiegelman’s Maus first and perhaps most forcefully established the connection between archives and comics. His groundbreaking work documenting his father’s experience in WWII Poland, where he survived internment in Auschwitz, is a visual narrative based on oral testimony that consistently heightens our awareness of visual, written, and oral archives, and where they interact, overlap, or get transposed one into the other. Hillary Chute recounts and interprets her collaboration with Spiegelman in the process of assembling MetaMaus, a book compiling interviews and archival materials on the making of Maus. MetaMaus, argues Chute, reflects the tension between different kinds of extant archives—oral, written, photographic—and the cross-discursive work of (re)building new archives that motivates Maus. Its defining feature is that it shows the materiality of Spiegelman’s archive; it is about the embodiment of archives. The subject of Maus is the retrieval of memory and ultimately, the creation of memory…. It’s about choices being made, of finding what one can tell, and what one can reveal, and what one can reveal beyond what one knows one is revealing. Those are the things that give real tensile strength to the work—putting the dead into little boxes. – Art Spiegelman (MetaMaus...

Words: 10659 - Pages: 43